Best black waterproof mascara... HELP!!!!!

[EmpressOfJurisfiction]

I need some advice from the experts!

I know less than nothing about makeup, haven't worn it since uni, but I'm putting a pampering set together for my lovely DSis's birthday & the one thing she's asked for specifically is black waterproof mascara.

I know she'd be happy with whatever brand I got, but she's had a rough time lately and I'd love to surprise her with a really good mascara. Could you give me some suggestions?

Thank you!!!!!!!!!!!

[holeinmyheart]

Estée Lauder black waterproof mascara is what I use, and it does what it says on the tin. It will not come off. You need to buy her some really oily eye make up remover to get it off with. I buy the Eastee Lauder remover but there are cheaper versions.

[HelenF350]

Max factor masterpiece max waterproof is great.

[HelenF350]

Max factor masterpiece max waterproof is great.

[HelenF350]

Sorry double post

[SwedeDreams]

Was coming on to say Max factor masterpiece - tis very good

[EmpressOfJurisfiction]

Brilliant, this is just what I needed. Thank you.

[MarchesMum]

I find Rimmel 100% waterproof black mascara is the best. It has remained in place swimming and at rather emotional funerals.

I have tried others but always gone back to that. Xx

[yellowsun]

Lancôme doll eyes is fab.

[EmpressOfJurisfiction]

[Kennington]

No 7 gold tube
But apply to top lashes on both sides

[DameDiazepamTheDramaQueen]

Maybelline Great Lash waterproof or No 7 waterproof.