I can only keep one. Which one?

[Dontletthemgetyoudown]

Ordered a couple of bags and now torn between which to keep as I like them all, but only need one. (although am trying hard to think of reasons I need three new tan handbags )

JOULES

RADLEY

JOHN LEWIS

and this one that hasn't arrived yet
FOSSIL

[lifesgreatquestions]

Hm, I like the green JL one but I most prefer the fossil bag. I think the Joules one will sometimes clash (as would the green one I guess) and I think the Radley one is the least interesting.

[FracturedViewOfLife]

I would keep the green JL one and try to keep the fossil one too.

[noddyholder]

Fossil although I have similar to teh joules one and like it a lot!

[Onlyconnect]

I like the Joules one and the Radley one best.

[maudpringle]

I love the John Lewis one too

[PrimalLass]

Joules or Fossil for me.

[NoComet]

The Fossil one is clever, but might be heavy. The JL one is OK. The first two are too gimmicky, in the wrong way.

Also I use a £70 JL black bag and it's lasting really well and is still lovely and soft.

DSIS had a Fossil bag for her 40th and three years later it still looks like new (which thinking about it makes my JL bag almost 4 years old).

[NoComet]

Should add I don't, collect bags so my JL one is used everyday for everything.

[Dontletthemgetyoudown]

the radley one I would take the charm off of, as I hate things like that. its the tan version of the john lewis one I have. I like the green but have nothing to go with it.

[amyshellfish]

I like the joules one and the radley one.

[Dontletthemgetyoudown]

I try not to collect bags, but have a weakness for that lovely new leather smell

[KosherBacon]

Radley one with the dangly crap taken off.

[dexter73]

The Joules one would drive me bonkers with that blue buckle on the pocket!! I like the Radley without the charm.

[CecyHall]

Radley for me. Which is weird as I never usually like Radley.

[CecyHall]

I also agree with Dexter the blue buckle on the Joules made my teeth itch

[Dontletthemgetyoudown]

I'm not a huge radley fan either, I have a Grosvenor and a few years old black tote, but neither has the dog on and aren't twee at all.

[Dontletthemgetyoudown]

Joules I probably the least favourite, I have to admit to buying it because of the blue buckle and the webbing handle but now not so sure that it I as versatile as the others.

It's my Christmas present from the children. DP has put some money towards it, ds1 (16) and ds2 (11), but know how fussy I am so have told me to choose. My poor credit card groaning at the moment with all 4 on it, so have to be sensible and send some back.

[buttercrumble]

Joules , I have pre ordered this and can't wait for it to arrive

[JaxTellerIsAllMine]

I am not usually a Radley fan, but I like this bag. Also like the Fossil - the other two are not my fave.

[SundaySimmons]

I don't like the joules one at all. It looks cheap and old fashioned.

The radley one I was surprised at, as it's quite nice and I'm not a fan of radley.

I like the John Lewis one but it could look cheap, a bit topshoppy.

The fossil one is really nice, I like that one best.

[Snowbility]

Radley as long as the tag is removed.

[eurochick]

The Fossil.

I don't like the mismatched buckle on the Joules. I can't stand Radley - the little dog makes me feel stabby. The JL one isn't bad, but I prefer the fossil.

[Cocochops]

Fossil is my fave. Don't like the joules one sorry

[trixymalixy]

John Lewis but in the tan or grey.