should i keep these boots?

[heather1980]

www.clarks.co.uk/find/keyword-is-madison+rose/product-is-20333187?redirected=true

i can't decide if i like them or not, and they are tight in the calf so i can't wear my jeans tucked in to them.
they were £59 with the code.

over to you mumnet jury

[tethersend]

No, they are vile.

[vonnyh]

What tethers said.

[HellonHeels]

They are inoffensive I suppose. I wouldn't look twice at them though (sorry) precisely because they are slightly dull and don't have anything that marks them out as a bit special.

Tight in the calf sounds uncomfortable.

If you can't decide if you like them, that's a very good reason to return them.

[MissVerinder]

No, send them back, they are not particularly nice, to be honest.

[lostinindia]

Top half is quite nice but the shoe bit lets it down. The toes looks like it's been taken from a blokes shoe. There are similar but nicer boots out there. Have you looked in Next or M&S, they are slightly generous in the calf.

[MadameOvary]

Yuck, Fly-lite and failing miserably

[meltedchocolate]

Oh dear, not the nicest. A bit mumsy on the bottom. sorry!

[heather1980]

i thought so, i'll take them back, the search goes on for black boots.

[LydiaWickham]

No, the toe isn't nice. Clarks have some other very nice black knee high boots.

[vincenta]

If I were you I would give them back, they didn't like very stylish and if you can't wear your jeans tucked in to them then its definitely no.no.no.