drink and teen DSS(38 Posts)
I am looking for some perspectives on the latest incident with DSS. I do not want us to over-react, but historically, we have tended towards under-reaction and Id like to avoid that as well.
DH and I went away for a long weekend (work conference, not a holiday). DSD is 18, DSS is 15. They are not very mature for their ages, and do not always have very good judgement about even quite small things. We debated leaving them on their own, to look after house and pets and selves for four days. We have had a few instances of quite bad behaviour from DSS in the last six months, but things seemed to be going along OK, and we thought it might even be a good thing to give them the responsibility. We had the usual sort of talk before we went, told them it was a big responsibility, and an opportunity to show us they could handle it. Neither of the kids has ever given us any previous cause for concern about drugs/drinking; DSD doesnt drink and neither do her friends.
We didnt hear much from them over the weekend, but DH had a daily check-in with DSD, who said everything was going fine. To make a long story a bit shorter, we found out when we came back that DSS had been out on Saturday and he came home with vomit on his jeans. DSD told us a rather evasive account of him coming home; DH then asked DSS who at first lied completely and said hed fallen down a muddy hill; when told that his story didnt match up with DSDs, DSS changed his story and admitted to drinking but said the vomit was someone elses, a girl who was too drunk to stand up. DSD, when pressed, said that he was acting OK when he came home but did smell of drink (of course, he had vomit on him); I think from her demeanour that there is more to the story, especially in light of her comment to DH on Saturday about them having had a row.
There was also, in DSSs laundry basket, an undershirt with a great many obvious vomit stains on it. He says he has no idea what the stains are or where they came from. To me, this looks like evidence that is inconsistent with a girl having vomited once on his jeans; on the other hand, I obviously cant really say for sure. I do not know what shirt he was wearing on top but there was nothing else in the laundry.
I am cross with both of them, frankly. DSD for covering for him and for not letting us know right away that hed come home in such a state. DSS for the obvious reasons of law-breaking; lying to DH about it when asked; the fact that this is just the latest in a series of unacceptable behaviours (that include property damage, laying hands on me, and general disrespect to DH); and most of all for taking advantage of us going away like this.
So far, DH has told him only that he is grounded. When DSS asked how long for, DH said he had to think about it. DSS started getting bolshy and complained that he is being punished for doing the right thing by trying to help a girl who was sick.
I havent spoken to DSS about it at all; DH did. He did not ask any of what seem to me to be obvious questions who were you with, where did you get the drink, who is the girl who was so drunk and what happened to her Well. You can see that I am unimpressed. What do other people do in these kind of situations?
By the way, the vomited-upon jeans have been left for me to launder.
Glad you got it sorted, and feel happy about the situation.
I agree with you that you can't allow DSS to have totally different rules to those you've had for his older sister.
I wasn't advocating kids lying and sneaking about - I'd just rather mine spoke to me and listened to advice, and I guess there will be some events/parties we'll just say no, they can't go to. My eldest is only 12 at the moment, so I may be being naive and over-hopeful thinking that talking about drink etc, rather than punishing when they do it will be the better way to go.
In your situation though, you're dealing with more than him just drinking, it's a trust issue about when you were away, and then potentially lies when you asked about it once home (i.e. the vomit on clothes from the "girl"). To me, those are the real issues, and I think they are to you too?
Sounds like you dealt with it all v well..
Well, we had a session with our counselor tonight, coincidentally, and that was very helpful. She was quite plain-spoken about it, and helped us come up with a plan of action and way to speak to them both about teh weekend.
DSS will be grounded, and DH has said that he will be keeping closer tabs on what he is up to and talking to friends' parents, etc...We won't be leaving them at home alone again for quite some time, and we'll be letting them know we are not happy with their choices. DH is also going to be having some firm words of warning with DSS about the things that could happen.
I have a 16 yr old ds - he goes out 'instantly' because someone invites him at that moment... they don't think ahead or stop to consider if this particular person's house would be acceptable to you on this particular weekend, etc., they just go.
See, that isn't what these kids do, and they aren't allowed to do it. I don't really think you can make this generalisation, either, because I certainly remember very clearly how I was as a teenager, and how most of my friends were, and most of us did have to have permission from our parents to go out. That isn't to say we didn't break the rules, but there was no blind eye turned when we did. DSD has pretty much always obeyed the rules, so we have been lucky, but DSS is a different kid. The rules are going to stay the same.
I really do expect better than this from these kids, and I'm not about to lower those expectations. Lots of teenagers do routinely lie to sneak around and act out, but DSD has not. DSS has just started, and we're not inclined to accept it as a matter of course.
Reading these replies has been interesting, but I think in the end I am happy with what we've decided upon, and the counselor has helped us figure out how to best deliver the message that is right for us, and I guess that is what I really needed advice about.
I'm with most people.
If you are daft enough to leave a 15yr old without adult supervision (and no, I don't count an 18yr old sister as adult for this purpose) it is very much like SonShines says at the top of the page - like leaving a toddler alone in a room with a paintbrush and pots and pots of paints.
Yes, there can be some small consequence (although, as others say, I'd have thought he'd learn more from the hangover and feeling sick), but in reality your lucky you didn't come home to a trashed house.
I have a 16 yr old ds - he goes out 'instantly' beacause someone invites him at that moment... they don't think ahead or stop to consider if this particular person's house would be acceptable to you on this particular weekend, etc., they just go. They also think they will be alrught if they have a can/bottle or two. Now he knows he isn't!
I think it was very unfair to lump responsibility for him onto his sister too - you can't seriously think it's a good thing to force her to drop him in it ?
You are right to ground him. I would be taking pocket money away too.
I would also want to know where he was, who he was with and what he was drinking.
You can't just say teens will be teens. They need to know there are consequences to bad behaviour, same as when they are small, or else they will grow up to be out of control.
Where I live, in a busy town centre, I see a lot of under age drinkers, and it isn't a nice sight. They can't handle drink at that age and have no idea of when enough is enough. They need punishing.
brdgrl I actually think you were right to ground him.
In my much younger days, I went out to places I shouldn't have and drank when I was too young - I do think this is a normal teenage rebellion. I had a sister who was much older and so used to stay at hers or my friends if I could when drinking.
I stayed out and lied because I KNEW it was wrong and if my parents found out they would punish me and with me the most effective form of punishment was grounding (I hated it).
Yes it was to be expected that he would do something he shouldn't
Yes it was expected that his sister tried to cover for him (but may now think twice in the future).
Yes it is to be expected by him that if he was caught out on a lie and drinking that he would be punished.
It is not a court with a life sentence, you are grounding him - you do not have to prove beyond reasonable doubt - he has been silly and caught bang to rights and now has to earn back any trust.
Hmmm, well. If it was him who was so drunk, then I would assume he felt pretty awful the next day, and if it was me, I'd leave that as enough punishment. Unfortunately, I really think the only way a teen is going to learn his limits is by testing them. I think punishing him by grounding him is going to alienate him, and you may lose any hope of discussing drinking, drugs etc. with him on a sensible level. I'd go for the tack of a serious conversation about damage to his liver, binge drinking etc.
I speak as a pretty much non-drinker, and also as someone who is quite strict in other respects. I'd punish for example for wanton damage to items, breakages, lack of care.
But ultimately I think the punishment for drinking like this has to be the hangover.
Plus you don't really know for sure that it wasn't someone else. Someone vomitted on me once - it was hideous - and put me off drinking for a long time. Far more than my parents punishing me for coming home with vomit covered clothes would have done. I would have been really annoyed at that!!!
Please see my last post. I have already said that we shouldn't have done it.
If my DD painted on the walls, she'd have a time-out, actually.
It's a bit like leaving a toddler in a room full of paints and expecting him not to cover the walls though, I think. If I were to do that, I would have to take responsibility for my part in that.
You said yourself he's young for his age, as is your DSD. You've said you've been having issues with his behaviour, at what point did you decide now was the right time to leave them alone with all that responsibility? Perhaps a night, to give them a chance to prove themselves, but 4 days?!
Sorry, just to say - I have to go to work now, so will reply later.
What did you expect he's 15?
what does he expect?
When I was 15 and broke rules, I expected to get in trouble for it.
We expected him not to do this, because he has never done it before. That was a mistake, obviously, and as I have said, we will not be letting him have the same responsibility again.
I agree that these things happen - they did with me - but the other thing that happens, or should happen, is that parents impose consequences, right?
I totally expect him to get into trouble and do irresponsible things. And then we'll make sure he has consequences for it. And that's how he learns.
Really, I am glad for and did ask for other perspectives, but I have to be very clear in saying that I'm not asking whether he did something wrong - he did, because he broke the rules of our house, and he'll be punished for that.
What did you expect he's 15?
Oh I still think it was unfair and I am 45
She won't grass on him and it's not really fair to expect her to.
freddie, that seems very unfair to you. I am cross with DSD, but I also think it is a tough situation for her; she clearly is hiding something but she doesn't want her brother to get into trouble. I don't want to blame her for it; I just think it shows that the set-up - leaving her with him like that - isn't going to work and we should not do it again.
1 and 2 are fair enough, but 3 - what did you expect? he's 15 that's what happens - or at least it does fairly often with 15 year olds.
I think really you knew he couldn't be trusted (going on past, but recent, behaviour). So by going away you were kind of asking for it, sorry. This was obviously going to happen, and it could've been a lot worse, actually.
an unspecific 'crime'
1) underage drinking
2) lying to DH
3) acting irresponsibly when he'd been asked (and agreed) to be on best behaviour whilst we were away
Brdgrl - yes. It was all my fault. I should have stopped him. I needed to learn to take responsibility.
If you do ground him make sure he's doing boring chores like washing windows, cutting the lawn, otherwise it's just an excuse to sit about moaning about how it's not fair, with nothing useful to show at the end of it.
freddie, your parents presumably had a reaction to what your brother did?
Join the discussion
Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.Register now
Already registered with Mumsnet? Log in to leave your comment or alternatively, sign in with Facebook or Google.
Please login first.