Hide
Mumsnet

Our SN area is not a substitute for expert advice. While many Mumsnetters have a specialist knowledge of special needs, if they post here they are posting as members, not experts. There are, however, lots of organisations that can help - some suggestions are listed here. If you've come across an organisation that you've found helpful, please tell us. Go to Parents with disabilities, SN children, SN teens, SN legal, SN recommendations.

Possible over diagnosing of special needs

(8 Posts)
AmandaLondon Thu 17-Nov-11 02:16:50

Hi

I was wondering if anyone could advise me. My child just joined reception and is probably the youngest in her class.

What does one do when (absolutely objectively and unemotionally) you think the teacher might be under pressure to get your child classifed as special needs in order to maintain class performance averages?

The teacher keeps coming up with really silly comments regarding my child's performance in PE activities and has said she is thinking of getting the senco to write to my child's gp if things do not 'improve' soon.

My child is physically fine. Academically she is a quick learner and is doing ok considering her age relative to the rest of the class.

Thanks

AmandaLondon Thu 17-Nov-11 02:44:58

In other words, can they insist on classifying the child as special needs, even if the GP says everything is fine??

DownbytheRiverside Thu 17-Nov-11 06:51:32

If your child is physically fit, what exactly is she worried about?
Is she a very experienced teacher? Have you had a meeting with the SENCO to discuss what their concerns are?
If there is a concern, why are you confident that they are wrong?
If your child was given specific support, would you object?

uniCorny Thu 17-Nov-11 07:12:57

'getting the senco to write to my child's gp if things do not 'improve' soon.'
Do schools even do this? Don't they refer through the school nurse - which would not be the decision of the class teacher anyway. How strange.
What are her concerns?

IndigoBell Thu 17-Nov-11 16:48:10

SEN (Special Educational Needs) is not the same thing as Sn (Special Needs).

It means what it says on the tin. That there is some aspect of school she needs extra help with.

It could be her fine or gross motor skills, or socialising, or behaving, or academic, or staying on task.

Having a child on the SEN register does not help the teacher in terms of 'maintaining class averages'. Children on the SEN register are expected to make the same progress as every other child.

The most likely scenario is that she genuinely thinks your child needs extra help.

hanaka88 Sun 20-Nov-11 14:10:48

In fact a child on the SEN register puts more pressure on teachers to get them achieving. If a child doesn't make progress it's 1 in 30. If an SEN child doesn't it's 1 in 2 or 3 so ratios for ofsted are higher

IndigoBell Sun 20-Nov-11 14:17:19

hanka - about a third of the class will be on the SEN register, so it'll be 1 in 9 or 10.........

hanaka88 Sun 20-Nov-11 15:31:06

Depends on the school.in my class there was 3. In DSs class just him. In my second class there was 2.

Add your message here

To post you need a valid nickname and password. Log in if you are a returning member, or join for free.

If you have forgotten your nickname or your password, you can get a reminder.