Could we have a button that takes us straight to our last comment

(35 Posts)
WakeUpFast Tue 12-Apr-16 13:55:33

...when we use the "I'm on" tab?

Sometimes threads move along so quickly I have to keep going through trying to find my last comment. It would be really good to have some kind of feature that would automatically take us to our last comment.

I use the mobile version on my iPhone so apologies if it's already available on desktop or the app!

FruStefanOla Wed 13-Apr-16 05:53:33

You can bookmark your last comment, although I have no idea how it works on the mobile version.

On the desktop version the bookmark is in the bottom, right hand corner of your post (when you hover your cursor over that area, then you have to click on the word Bookmark). But first you have to go into Customise and check the box that says 'Display Bookmark Links'.

Baconyum Wed 13-Apr-16 05:58:25

Other chat sites have this I'd like one too but have asked before and it's been ignored.

RolandaHooch Wed 13-Apr-16 05:59:40

Yes, as Fru says, use bookmark. On the mobile version swipe to the left and tap bookmark. You can do this on the last post you read or your own post. Next time you go on that thread it will begin at that point.

Pipbin Wed 13-Apr-16 06:18:34

I agree. I've tried to bookmark but I've never got it to work.

WipsGlitter Wed 13-Apr-16 06:51:22

I've never got bookmark to work either. Is it just a visual label or does it actually take you to the marked spot?

WhoKnowsWhereTheT1meGoes Wed 13-Apr-16 06:59:35

It takes you there but in TIO you have to touch the thread title not one of the posts. In the mobile version each post has 3 dots in the bottom RH corner, touch these and one option is bookmark.

If you've forgotten, you can use your search button, on my phone (Iphone) just type in a unique part of your name in the search box (so for me wheret works, for you pfast should) and one of the options is "on this page, pick that and it goes straight to wherever your name first is, you can skip through to your last post easily.

TheDrsDocMartens Wed 13-Apr-16 07:19:37

Book mark takes you whereever you marked.invluding on mobile.
On TIO you used to be able to click on the post rather than title & it would take you there.doesnt appear to work now.

WakeUpFast Wed 13-Apr-16 07:47:14

Thanks for the replies. The only problem with bookmarking is that I'll end up with hundreds of bookmarks which makes it all confusing. I will try it out though.

The easiest thing would be perhaps a little tab on top of the thread labelled "my comments", which you'd press and you'd get a link to Your last comment.

FruStefanOla Wed 13-Apr-16 07:53:07

But you only have one bookmark per thread. So you might bookmark your last post, or bookmark the last post that you read (posted by someone else).

When you go back to that thread, it takes you to your bookmark. You read more of the thread, maybe you post another comment yourself - and then bookmark the last post you read, or your last comment. Then the bookmark 'moves' to that place. You don't get a series of bookmarks on one thread, just your last bookmark.

Gruach Wed 13-Apr-16 08:03:47

Wakeup you're definitely not doing it right!

I'm on the mobile site. Every post above the box I'm typing in has three dots beneath the least line. Touch them, you get the Bookmark option. When you bookmark a post the last bookmark you made disappears - so you don't end up with several.

And are your posts highlighted? You do need that as well.

BrieAndChilli Wed 13-Apr-16 08:15:05

I'm on the mobile site and touching the 3 little dots but there's no bookmark option????

Gruach Wed 13-Apr-16 08:17:06

But look!

FruStefanOla Wed 13-Apr-16 08:18:38

Brie, I don't know about the mobile site, but on the desktop site you have to go into Customise first and check the box that says 'Display Bookmarks Link', save that change and then when you go back to any thread you can bookmark your place.

FruStefanOla Wed 13-Apr-16 08:20:30

Gruach, you have the bookmark option turned on - but maybe Brie doesn't?

Gruach Wed 13-Apr-16 08:54:17

Fair point.

But why (MNHQ) is bookmarking optional? That and the highlighting of OP and own posts are both necessary, surely?

WakeUpFast Wed 13-Apr-16 09:12:24

Oh I see, so when I bookmark my last comment, I'll go back to it when I open the thread? I'm going to test it quickly.

WakeUpFast Wed 13-Apr-16 09:16:13

Right, I've got it! So you bookmark your last comment on a thread. This will definitely make life easier, but still quite a long winded process when then could be a simple "my comments" tab somewhere on the screen.

Thanks for all your help!

Gruach Wed 13-Apr-16 09:24:07

I bookmark wherever I am on a thread - doesn't have to be my own post.

FruStefanOla Wed 13-Apr-16 09:46:46

"But why is bookmarking optional?" I agree, Gruach, when I first joined and noticed people saying "bookmarking" all over the place I couldn't figure out how to bookmark at all! It took me ages to find the 'opt in' in Customise.

And, what Gruach said, WakeUp, it doesn't have to be your last post that you bookmark - just the last one that you read before you close the thread.

WakeUpFast Wed 13-Apr-16 09:50:34

Thanks Gruach and Fru, will be using the bookmark feature on all long threads from now on!

Gruach Wed 13-Apr-16 09:55:45

Sorry to keep on but you didn't answer about having your own posts highlighted. Do you?

It's really not longwinded if you do.

WakeUpFast Wed 13-Apr-16 10:51:13

sorry, yes I do have my own posts highlighted, but by the time I come back to a popular thread it's moved on a few pages and I forget which page I posted on. Also, I have the pages set to a 100 comments per page, as full page took ages to load and constantly went blank as I scrolled down. 100 per page works better for me.

Gruach Wed 13-Apr-16 11:05:28

Oh I see. I don't have pages and freely admit I found them rather fiddly when I tried that format.

I'm always surprised to find that other people don't have MN set up exactly as I do! I must try to feel less impatient when posters say they "couldn't be bothered to scroll through 15 pages" or when they don't highlight and then miss the post where the OP says the crisis has been averted or whatever. Still waiting for the app to reach peak tweek and become equally easy to use ...

ShowOfHands Wed 13-Apr-16 11:17:19

I have bookmark turned on. I bookmark my place. Never once has it taken me back to that post.

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now