Ferry or tunnel?

(10 Posts)
babybouncer Sat 22-Feb-14 09:36:51

We're heading to Western Loire in France in the summer. It'll be about a 3-3 1/2 drive to either Portsmouth or Dover, then we could do a 4hr ferry crossing and 3 hr drive to the holiday house or go through the tunnel and have a 5 hr drive. We have 2 yr old and a 5 yr old and the ferry is about £500 compared to £150 for the tunnel, but mum Mum says we should take the ferry and she usually gives good advice.

Which would you recommend?

magimedi Sat 22-Feb-14 10:41:34

Tunnel - every time. So quick & easy & good autoroutes from Calais - straight onto to it when you leave the tunnel. You can get out the car in the tunnell - just to stand by it & it only takes 35 mins & unloading takes about 4 minutes. You can wait ages to load/unload with the ferry & if it is rough can be horrid.

Glitterfeet Sat 22-Feb-14 10:57:07

Brittany ferries are bringing out a budget service soon.

How do your kids behave on ferries? When my eldest was small he'd not sit still for a moment and we found longer sea crossings more exhausting than a longer car journey. My other son would snuggle up one of the reclining ferry chairs and snooze.

I would probably choose the tunnel as it only increases your time in the car by two hours. You'd probably spend a lot of that time boarding and disembarking from one of the Portsmouth ferries.

Pascha Sat 22-Feb-14 10:58:12

Tunnel is far less faff.

Goldencity1 Sat 22-Feb-14 11:23:34

Which channel crossing you use depends on where you are in the UK and where you are going in France.
We travel from the Midlands to central France and have done long and short crossings plus the tunnel.
We much prefer Portsmouth - Caen with Britany Ferrys. It's easier to get to Portsmouth for us, We have to get round the m25 to get to Dover. The journey is longer in France as well. We like the longer ferry crossing, we can go on the overnight crossing and get to the port in time even after being at work during the day. We have a meal on the boat, a good night's sleep and off the boat and away in the morning. It is more expensive to do the overnight crossing (you have to pay for the cabin, wouldn't consider overnight without one) and if you travel on a day crossing there are children's entertainers and play areas as well as being cheaper. There is space for kids to run around, it makes a good break in the journey.

We have also used the cheaper western channel crossings with transmanche/ DFDS / OF Lines (all part of same group) who go from Newhaven/Dieppe (cheapest option) or Portsmouth Le Harvre. There are more "budget airlines" type, not as good food or stuff for children, boats not as nice, and we find the crossing times really inconvenient. Also, overnight cabins are even more pricey than BFerries and book up fast.
On the other hand, book with Transmanche on newhaven dieppe and you get 20% discount if you are under 25, a student, disabled, over 60. The discount applies to the whole group if booked by the person entitled....

The shorter crossings seem cheaper, but you have to factor in the cost of the extra driving including the extra motorway tolls in France ( about €30 each way for us) plus longer for kids cooped up in the car! However, you can still have a meal on board and there is play stuff and space for children to let off steam.

Some people really like the tunnel. We used it after Xmas this year as I had left it too late to get a ferry crossing. Yes it is quick, the loading and unloading is very organised and you are straight off onto the auto route.
But we don't like it. It's boring, you can walk about round the car, but that's all. No cafe, no real rest for the driver. You have to factor in more rest stops when driving to make up for this.

We do this journey about 5 times a year, and have worked out the inclusive cost of just about every combination! We have a frequent traveller club membership for BFerries which reduces their prices by 30%, and with this they work out only a few pounds more than the short crossing as well as being the most comfortable and convenient. If you know someone who is a member, they can give you their code and you can get 10% off as their guest. Could pm this to you if you like.

As for rough weather,we have never been seasick even in a winter Gale! Our kids used to find it exciting and were disappointed when it was calm. Modern boats have good stabilizers, and the only time it has been really bad was in the winter.

Goldencity1 Sat 22-Feb-14 11:30:22

Also, the time for loading on the tunnel was about the same as loading the ferry. Unloading on the tunnel is quicker though. It normally takes about 10 to 15 minutes to get out of the dock area in France, more like 15 to 30 in th UK, as clearing customs takes longer.

Hope all this helps.

PestoSnowissimos Sat 22-Feb-14 11:37:05

Tunnel

Retropear Sat 22-Feb-14 17:02:26

I hate being on the ferry for long.

I like the way you can stock up on lunch at the tunnel terminal which saves time the other side.There is nothing at the ferry terminal so you end up having to stop in France.

I also like the way you can sit in the car drinking a nice coffee with the tunnel as opposed to dealing with bored kids you're constantly trying to stop spending entire purses full of holiday money in the over priced ferry shop.

cathpip Sat 22-Feb-14 17:15:40

Tunnel smile we have always used this, our children are 3 and 5. You can always pack a picnic and stop at a picnic area by the motorway in France, they are safe, have plenty of picnic areas and space for little ones to run around in to let of steam. After a successful trip by car to Switzerland last year we are driving to the south of France this year (May need an extra couple of stops as will have a small baby smile)

redkindof Mon 24-Feb-14 19:57:08

Definitely go with tunnel so easy and quick and no travel sickness, you can stick in your own car with own comforts also it can be practically free if you shop at Tesco and use clubcard scheme

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now