If you are a parent whose child may take the 11 Plus in the next seven years, then please read this.
Calderdale 11 Plus Consultation
If you are a parent whose child may take the 11 Plus in the next seven years, then please read this.
The changes proposed by North Halifax Grammar School (NHGS) and The Crossley Heath School Academy Trust (CHSAT) to their admission policy will have huge implications for your child’s chance of securing a place at one of the schools, even if they score highly on the entrance exam.
Both NHGS and CHSAT have published their proposed policies on their websites. The schools have to allow a six-week consultation period on any changes to their policies. The consultation period runs from 23rd November 2015 to the 3rd January 2016. The schools must consult a number of groups and this includes parents with children between the ages of 2–18.
There are a number of changes proposed, including the changes to the entrance exam itself, which were expected. However, my concern lies with the changes to the oversubscription criteria. I am aware that some of you will have a lot of knowledge about the previous policy and others will not know anything. I will therefore attempt to summarise the changes.
Previous Oversubscription Policy
Both schools have one test and children are ranked according to their performance from 1–1000 (approximately 1000 children take the exam). This is referred to as the order of merit.
There is an increase this year in the number of places, also known as the Published Admissions Number (PAN). Each school has 180 places; therefore there are a total of 360 places available for the 2017 admission. If your child is ranked between 1–360 then they would have been offered a place at one of the schools. The higher they rank the more chance you would have of securing your preferred choice. Children who ranked a bit lower may still be offered a place as some children, who have been accepted, may not want to take up their place.
If there were a number of children who obtained the same score for the last place/s then the school will consider the following criteria in deciding who will be offered the place:-
a) Children looked after and children previously looked after,
b) Proximity of child’s home to school,
c) Last place to pupils with siblings.
Proposed Oversubscription Criteria for 2017 Admission
For the first time, NHGS and CHSAT have slightly different policies.
Both schools still have one test and children are ranked according to their performance from 1–1000 (approximately 1000 children take the exam).
North Halifax Grammar School
In order to reach the required standard, your child will need to be in the top 500, although historically a child who ranked over 400 would be unlikely to obtain a place.
The policy then states that if more children reach the required standard in the test then there are places at the school (as there are approximately 1000 children that take the test and there are only 360 places, this situation will occur).
The places will then be offered according to the following criteria:-
a) Children looked after and children previously looked after.
b) Children attracting the Pupil Premium (this includes anyone registered for free school meals any time over the last six years). This does not take into account any change of circumstances for the family.
c) Twins, multiple births or two or more siblings within the same school year. This means that if a child falls into this category they will be offered a place as long as they are in the top 500 over a child who ranks first. This, in my view, discriminates against children who are not twins, etc. This also does not define what the term ‘siblings’ in the same year will include, ie does it include step-siblings? What safeguards are there to prevent two parents moving in together with children in the same year to obtain priority?
d) Siblings (to include step-siblings, foster siblings, and adopted siblings living permanently at the same address) of children presently attending the school. This is the most concerning part of the policy and will severely impact upon a child, who does not have sibling at the school securing a place. The policy does not specify at what point the sibling has to be on the roll, ie at the time of registration for the exam or at the time the child would attend the school. Potentially if there were a high number of siblings in a certain year group taking the entrance exam, then a child ranking first may still not secure a place at the school. I also think that this will impact upon children trying to secure a place at CHSAT as it will have a knock on effect.
Furthermore, I consider that this is unlawful as it breaches the Section 1.9( j) of the Schools Admissions Code 2014, which states :-
It is for admission authorities to formulate their admission arrangements, but they must not in designated grammar schools that rank all children according to a pre-determined pass mark and then allocate places to those who score highest, give priority to siblings of current or former pupils.
The policy then states that once these places have been offered, the remaining places will be offered according to the order of merit until the school reaches its PAN. Therefore, if your child is in the top 360 and does not fall into the categories a to d above, then they will not be considered until this point.
Crossley Heath School Academy Trust
This policy is similar to the above, however, CHSAT have not included section d so will not consider siblings before the order of merit. They will only consider the siblings and proximity to school if it is the last place and children have the same score. However, as stated above, NHGS policy will still impact upon your child’s ability to secure a place at CHSAT. CHSAT will also give priority to twins, etc so although these are likely to be fewer in number, I still consider it significant.
Other Legal Points
Section 1.8 of the Schools Admission Code states oversubscription criteria must be reasonable, clear, objective, procedurally fair and comply with all relevant legislation including equalities legislation.
Section 1.32(c) states that admission authorities must take all reasonable steps to inform parents of the outcome of the selection tests before the closing date for secondary school applications on 31 October so as to allow parents time to make an informed choice of school – while making clear that this does not equate to a guarantee of a selective place. Previously, the order of merit gave a fairly good indication if a child was ranked between 1–360 that they would successfully obtain a place. However, technically even if your child ranked first that is no indication that they will secure a place. It will depend on how many children in the top 500 fall into categories a–d above for NHGS and a–c for CHSAT. Unless the schools are able to provide the numbers that fall into the above categories, I would argue that parents will not be able to make an informed choice of school.
What Can You Do?
The consultation runs until the 3rd January and if you oppose the policy you can write to the schools before the deadline. I would suggest that you write to each school as the policies do differ.
You can pass this on to whoever you know that will be affected. Please note that if this policy comes into force, then it will be more difficult to oppose it in future years, as schools only have to consult every seven years where the admission arrangements have not changed from the previous year.
The consultation includes all parents who have a child between the ages of 2–18, so each parent can object separately. The more objections they receive the more likely we are to succeed in stopping the changes coming in.
I would also suggest you keep a record of your email.
Contact Details for Sending Comments on the Proposed Policies
NHGS – Paula Wright – Principal’s PA at [email protected]
CHSAT – Lynne Sharples – Head Teacher’s PA at [email protected]
DEADLINE 03/01/16
Where Can You Get Further Information?
www.nhgs.co.uk
www.crossleyheath.org.uk
www.gov.uk/government/publications/school-admissions-code--2
Connect with other parents whose children are starting secondary school on this forum.
Secondary education
New admissions policy for Calderdale selective grammar
Starof3 · 30/11/2015 22:58
This reply has been deleted
Message withdrawn at poster's request.
This reply has been deleted
Message withdrawn at poster's request.
This reply has been deleted
Message withdrawn at poster's request.
This reply has been deleted
Message withdrawn at poster's request.
Don’t want to miss threads like this?
Weekly
Sign up to our weekly round up and get all the best threads sent straight to your inbox!
Log in to update your newsletter preferences.
You've subscribed!
To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.