Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you need help urgently, please see our domestic violence webguide and/or relationships webguide, which can point you to expert advice and support.
How to I teach my children to be safe when their father is drunk?(61 Posts)
My DDs are 7.75 and just 9. I was divorced from their dad 5.5 years ago. He was a drunk when I met him although I didn't spot it. He doesn't drink every day, but will manufacture social reasons to drink. One drink and he cannot stop. He is never hung over. He doesn't admit that he has any kind of problem. He doesn't have very many friends, because when he gets drunk he insults them.
We live in France, he is French, and we have been to court 4 times already including the divorce. And apart from the divorce, never instigated by me. If we go back to court again it will have to be the children's choice, not mine. They will need to write to the judge to say why they want to change the current set up and they will then get awarded their own lawyer. If they choose to do this, they will then get to "choose" who they get to spend their time with. This is just the way the system works here, and in general the system is pretty good and I have had way too much experience of it. Before the summer they wanted to do this, but of late they don't seem to want to.
He has the children every other weekend and half the holidays which is standard minimum in France.
They know that there Dad has a drinking problem, but they don't seem to be able to recognise when he is drunk. He used to live with someone who pretty much protected them, but now he lives alone. In the last 10 days I have had telephone contact with him and all 3 times he has been roaring drunk, and on one of those occasions the girls were with him. Generally speaking he is a pretty hideous drunk. The girls recognise "nasty" drunk better than "nice" drunk, but honestly it is screamingly obvious from his voice, eyes, posture - everything.
What can I tell my DDs to keep them safe when they are at his house? I have read up on information, mostly US, but it is more focused at teens, and the language is complicated. They would need to understand about addiction, abuse, that they are at risk of becoming addicts themselves etc in order to get a grip on the information I have found. They used to take a phone with them but he found it and has banned it, and they aren't willing to defy him (he is bloody scary, so I don't blame them).
You can't possibly expect children that young to handle a drunk grown man. It's a non-starter. They are being neglected and in danger of harm and I'm amazed that you're even thinking this way. I'm sorry but I would go get the kids, call the police, get it on record that he was drunk again and then keep them home. Let him sue you to get supervised access.... Protect your kids.
The reason that what you have read is aimed at teens and adults is because it is never, ever a child's responsibility to protect themselves from a drunk adult. That is an adult responsibility.
I think you should contact French children's services (or equivalent), this is a dangerous situation for them and they cannot protect themselves.
Agree with Cogito. One incident like this is more than enough. It's unsafe and irresponsible to leave your kids with him. Whether he agrees with this or not is not relevant.
I was left with a drunk when I was 10 and was far too young to keep me and little sibs safe. Luckily I had sense to go to a neighbour.
If he is drunk in charge of your kids they need to be rescued. You cannot make it their problem. It's a police matter.
What the others have said.
Your children will love their dad but they will be scared and confused if they are with him when he's like that.
It's your job (since he's the problem) to keep them safe. Pick them up, call the police, tell social services.
agree with all the other posters, they cannot keep themselves safe in his company, BUT they perhaps need some guidance on what to do in an emergency, like go to neighbour, go to police...if they really can't call you...can they use a public phone box?
maybe there are organisations for children of alcoholics in France?
What Cogito stated; this is a complete non starter and the children are at risk.
They do not warrant this in their lives and they should not actually have any obligation to see him at all; they are being let down here.
This is France, it just doesn't work like that. I have already written to the judge and the only way that the situation can change is if they write to the judge themselves and I cannot make them do it. The police are aware of the situation and the kids are already on the at risk register. If I stop them going I will loose them, and they will either end up with him full time or in care, it is that simple here. Children are almost NEVER taken away from drunk parents here. I am not speaking for the whole of France but the area I am in. Social services are aware of the situation, and I have friends who work in social services. I need advice that I can use, not a judgement or a drama.
The other point is that the children still actually want to go to him.
You need to involve social services, not the normal agency but the one that deals with domestic violence and abuse, as well as any charities in your area that deal with these things. I'm also in France and a friend of mine has gotten loads of help from a local agency who helps women deal with abusive exes.
If you are British, contact the consulate in France and see if they can offer any advice or refer you to any specialists. I don't understand why you can't go to court again?
Beyond that, the only thing you can teach your girls is to call the police when their dad is that drunk. Basically: if you're scared, call the police. I would hope this would trigger a readjustment of your arrangements.
Lots of adults, including doctors and nurses, are unable to tell when a hardened drinker has had too much.
I agree with the other posters.
I understand that you can't go through the courts again but I would involve the police or child services.
If he is drunk in charge of your children they are immediately at risk. They police should be called.
What if there were a fire or one of them were injured?
The above is Al-anon's French homepage. This site can be readily translated into English.
The police were also very clear to me that it has to be the kids that call them and not me. The kids know how to call the police, we have talked to the police about this situation.
Thanks Attila. I'll contact them.
really? they would not respond to a third party call informing them that a child was in danger?
I can back up what the OP is saying, France is VERY different from the UK.
I'm not sure what advice you can get though, to be honest. I realise you're in a tough spot but I think people are going to be ethically uncomfortable advising you how to teach your kids to stay safe with such a drunk.
I think all you can do is tell your girls to call the police EVERY time things are bad. When you say the police are aware, what does that mean? I would hope if they show up and see the situation they would at least remove the kids from his care at that time.
That's terrible - so your 7 and 9 year old children are in danger because they have to stay with a nasty drunk and unless they themselves make a complaint, nothing can be done?
How does a 7yo write to a judge? Quite honestly I would write the letter & get them to sign it on pain of death. Stuff ethics... their safety is at risk and you have to play the system to the wire. I'm very sure French people don't follow this ridiculous rule literally.
They used to take a phone with them but he found it and has banned it, and they aren't willing to defy him (he is bloody scary, so I don't blame them)
You need advice on how vulnerable children negotiate and manage the behaviour of a grown man who is pissed and sometimes angry?
I have been a small child around drunk adults. It is fucking terrifying. I could tell you things that happened that would ensure you didn't sleep while they were with him.
That's fact. Not drama or judgement.
You need to move heaven and earth to protect them. I do not have the knowledge of French Family Law to advise strategy.
Is he rational sober? Could he have the visits chez his family?
But please believe me that they are not, and should not be expected to be, remotely capable of protecting themselves. That is your job.
The very best of luck to you, it must be a nightmare for all concerned.
What a very sad situation.
Apologies if you've already thought of/done this:
Can you give each child a pay as you go phone and laminated card with brief advice and then telephone numbers (police, SS, a Childline equivalent) to take with them to their father's?
They need to know it is ok to go to bed or take themselves off away from their father if he is drunk and distressing them, and to stay together. And ring you, of course.
Also discuss with them where they should go if they feel they have to leave the house immediately (and what kind of circumstances should make them feel that). Is there a nearby household they could go to if necessary, and could you prime whoever lives there to agree to take them in?
So, just recalled he found the phone. Bugger.
People don't realise it, but it's actually still 1953 in France.
No joke, what my friend has been through is absolutely insane, they don't seem to give a fuck about abused women and kids.
My friend left her partner because he was abusive (controlling and physically violent) yet she still needs his permission to take their son more than 50 km from here, even for a day trip. They have 50/50 care and she has to personally do the handovers because there are no contact centres or anything.
When she called the police when he hit her, they showed up, spoke to him and went to leave. She chased after them saying, can't I tell you what happened? And they said, we don't need to, he told us. And they just left!
So I'm not surprised the OP is in this situation. I just don't know realistically what can be done if the kids won't do anything.
Thanks Elditch. Some of that is in place. They know never to leave the other one, to stick together, to try and stay out of his way. Calling the police is just dialling 17, so we have practised that. They do know people in the village where he lives, so we could talk that one through too.
Have you contacted SOS Femmes & Solidarité Femmes OP?
Fuck I was thinking of living in France, having second thought. Are you in a rural area OP. Is moving back to UK an option?
Would it be worth getting a lawyer to write to the social services and other authorities if they are not listening to you? I am worried (as I am sure you are) that your children are in real danger from your ex. They are simply not old enough to protect themselves - and they shouldn't be in the position of having to protect themselves from a drunken adult! I understand that they want to see their father, but perhaps French law makes provision for a lawyer to write to the court on their behalf, given their ages? Good luck with what must be a very stressful situation.
Oh yes, I think it's SOS Femmes that helped my friend so much. They're wonderful. I mean, she's still in a pretty awful situation, but it would have been so much worse without them.
Blossom -- the OP will not be allowed to leave with her kids, unfortunately.
Good they know people in the village. Just thinking it is worth organising it so that even if they know a local number, dial it and hang up, the person called knows to pop round on a pretext to see if they are ok.
No Twinkle - I'm not really aware of those groups. Any my guess is that they deal with women and not kids. I am out of what was a hideously EA relationship. I have learnt a lot reading MN. Honestly DDs do not need any extra drama in their lives, and I am really conscious of that. I have followed up on Attilas advice and have been passed to 9 different services. None of them can help; none of them deal with children of this age group. The best anyone could offer was for the children to talk with a psy for children in April 2014. We have already followed that path in the past, and I pretty much had to bribe them to go and talk. I'm not saying it was a disaster, but it certainly wasn't a success. They weren't harmed by the experience, but they weren't helped much either.
Contrary to what you might expect my kids are not f**ked up! (Yet). Or at least that is the general opinion. They are very well surrounded by people friends, good school, lots of attention etc. The fly in the ointment, is their dad. But they love him and the eldest particularly, wants to see him.
Kids often want things that are inappropriate and not good for them. I'm staggered by a system that places the responsibility for choosing one parent over the other on the shoulders of very young children. It's too much for a child. What would happen if you wrote the letter and told them they had to sign it?
The judge knows all this already, the judge ordered a report to be done by social services previously, for another reason, about visitation rights of the paternal grandparents. Everyone knows (apart from him) that he has a problem.
Blossom - rural normandy - been here 18 years, love it/hate it. Have 2 businesses here, so not wild about moving back to the UK. To move away from here, I would have to go back to the judge and it is unlikely that the judge would consider uprooting the children to be in their best interests. Dad lives 10 minutes away, so he would most likely get full custody in that situation.
Elditch - that's an excellent idea. That's a plan I can work on.
I am really not passive about all this, but you have to work within the law here. As a "foreigner" you are not necessarily going to be anyones first choice. We are all bilingual which helps, but.... I am still Janey foreigner.
Cogito - it would all come to light when the next social services report would happen. If anyone asked them, they would be incapable of lying about it. For what its worth I have written the letter - but they are not ready to copy it out for themselves. They are resistant to being forced into what they see (correctly) as a conflictual situation. They will have to continue to go to their dads all the time this is being prepared and this will take between a year and two to come to court.
They're kids. They have no idea how much danger they are in. Just tell them what to do and don't give them the choice.
wally I feel very sorry for your situation, it must be deeply distressing to pack you little kids to a drunk. I have lived abroad and I think unless you have witnessed these type of thing first hand it is hard to believe this sort of thing happens. I am surprised that France is like this, an eye opener for me.
I'm about to move to Paris Blossom, my husbands' French.
France is a lot more sexist (& racist) and women have a long way to go...
French women really need to stand up for themselves more & build up the kind of networks that women have here.
There are great things about it, but I wouldn't want to be there for the rest of my life.
OP can you not just insist your children write that letter? I think it would be difficult if you wrote it yourself & got found out, the judge may not look kindly on that. But they are still of an age when you can tell them to do something & expect it to be done.
The fact is he is dangerous, as kids they don't know that. But if they kick up a fuss about writing the letter I think they're not too young to tell them.
Hanging - he is in conflict with everyone in his family, every single person. He took his mum to court to stop her having them to stay, and then she took both of us in return match and now has huge visitation rights - she get's a month a year of their holiday time.
How worrying and stressful.
If the children are known to social services, would an option be to update them on the ongoing risks of their being in his sole care?
And/Or challenge the agencies on why they don't provide support for at risk younger children, through the complaints procedures or regulators?
Shocked at the french system, it's well known that children of alcoholics an be protective, guilty about the alcoholic, so requiring DC of that age and in that situation to write to a judge is !
Bloody hell my almost 7yo can barely write.
That is shocking. France seems so backward.
It's worth contacting SOS Femmes, I think. It certainly can't hurt.
I don't know that the French really believe in alcoholism Loopy, they just see it as the freedom to appreciate fine wines. (My FiL has a close relationship with the bottle, but he is seen as a 'connoisseur' rather than a soak). The AA programme & philosophy doesn't seem to be as well established there as here. And they have a completely different attitude to drink driving too, it's acceptable & many people do it. There are 4 times as many road deaths in France, partly, I suspect, as a consequence.
In short the whole approach to alcohol abuse is missing key factors.
I agree dreaming. Afaik SOS Femme & Solidarité are similar to Women's Aid.
They definitely help women & child victims of abusive men OP. Even if they can't help you directly, they may be able to direct you to organisations that can.
I'm sorry you and your girls are going through this Wally.
Obviously you need to work within the law of the country to prevent your DDs ending up in an even worse situation.
I'm sorry but in my opinion you are going to have to have some very honest, serious and unpleasant conversations with your DDs.
Explain to them the effect that alcohol can have on people and behaviour and the very real danger this poses.
Tell them about how an addict needs to be at rock bottom before they can change (and rock bottom for their Dad would be to stop seeing them, this is his best chance to change).
Tell them about support that addicts can receive and how this could help their Dad if he had an inventive to get it.
Tell them how precious they are to you and how you are frightened thy might be hurt.
Tell them this often and remind them they have the power (with your full support) to write this letter, talk to the police and keep themselves safe.
Obviously I want to tell you to keep your DDs home with you and away from this selfish and frightening man. I wish you had more power to protect them. But if you really, really don't then you can't protect them from the true danger of the situation either. They need to know how serious this is and be encouraged to write that letter.
Gosh Killer - thank you for that advice. It's the reality of the situation beautifully put. I was talking to a friend about this in RL yesterday, and he mentioned smell, and thinking about it, that is probably the easiest one for my girls to spot.
I'm going to print out what you wrote and go through it with my girls. I spoke to one of them yesterday about having an adult friend pop over from the village if they made an sos call - but she said that Daddy no longer has any friends in the village! Not surprised, but a bit of a downer frankly.
I'm sorry you are in this situation, it must be tough for you.
One thing I learnt growing up with an alcoholic father was to stay out of arms reach, if he was going to get nasty I could always out run him.
Make sure they can unlock a door or window to get out and have first, second and third choice of neighbours to go to.
I think you may find this situation changes as they get older and begin to see him for what he is, hopefully then they will be ready to write that letter.
Other things to try in your circs: first aid classes for children, some sort of martial arts class, teaching them about their rights in general; helping them develop the confidence to say that they don't like something and want something else instead - starting with stuff much less emotionally difficult than this.
Practically, do they know where the nearest telephone box [assuming they exist in France] is from their father's house or where the nearest shop is [and the opening times]? How about the nearest pharmacy/chemist? These would be useful places to go in an emergency if the immediate neighbours aren't useful.
Do you think there is the slightest possibility that he will physically harm them or harm them to hurt you?
Did he physically abuse you?
If there is the slightest chance then you need to come back to Britain and bring your children with you immediately - I assume you have passports? And that without your ex being suspicious in any way it is actually possible to just leave?
If you believe that he won't physically harm them then try to minimise the impact of his drinking on them by being as frank as their age allows.
He was never physically abusive but he did a major mental job on me. EA in extremis. He is incredibly manipulative and my DDs spot that and talking about it has helped them both to understand what his aim is when he does it. i.e to control them. They just seem to have a total blind spot about the drinking. They both said they couldn't spot the smell - but that is probably cos they stay out of his way. We have made a bit of progress on how little wine is legal and they were surprised that it's just 2 glasses. I've explained about the breathalyzer that he has to have in the car but they are not buying that they can get him to blow in it.
In all honesty they are getting on with him better now than ever before. Which is weird. I don't quiz them about it but they've gone from wanting out of going to being unstressed about going. He will blow it with them because he screws up every relationship. This week he plans to get them to do an autumn clean which they definitely won't appreciate! I will talk to them about the window and I'll talk to him about the phone and see if we can sort out an agreement.
What an awful situation for you and your DDs.
I think elder DD needs to be persuaded to write to the judge. Could you perhaps frame it that her father is unwell, and part of the illness is that he's unable to recognise it?
I was going to say I'm glad that they do not seem too badly affected but, tbh, I don't believe they are not being psychologically harmed - children are more than able to conceal their distress, particularly when trying to protect a parent or parents, in this case both their father and you. Sorry if that's the wrong thing to say, but I don't think it's wise to assume they are coping as well as it might appear.
No Something I'm sure you are right. And I'm sure that this isn't the only thing that is damaging to them - I have just started a second business and teach 2.5 days a week too. So I am uncomfortably busy at the moment. They have also just started at a new school.
But, they do know that they come first with everyone - and we have a big family - they live with two other adults as well as me. But you are right they do try to protect me and one has to assume their Dad too. But also they do know that I will always fight their corner all the way to the line, and they've seen me do it again and again. They also know I wont take any more bullying bullshit from their Dad - not one single fucking sentence of it. And I truly believe that the best I can do for them in the long term with their relationship with their Dad is by setting an example and boundaries.
It is really interesting though what they can and cannot spot. The manipulation just pisses them off - yet he did such a total job on me!! It took me ages to really believe that he was an alcoholic or alcohol abuser - only when we were separated and divorced to I really get it, and understand how he manipulated situations so that he could get wasted.
He doesn't drink daily - only in "social situations" so he will manufacture those so he can drink. One drink and he cannot stop.
Hmm, not that it makes much difference to the matter at hand, but how do you know he doesn't drink daily?
It concerns me that one thing they are learning is how to accommodate, and to some extent excuse, alcoholism and manipulative behaviour, which by necessity is what they have to do in order to live with him.
I'm not trying to give you a hard time, OP, but please, if it's the only way to get something done, do everything you can to get that letter to the judge written.
And I truly believe that the best I can do for them in the long term with their relationship with their Dad is by setting an example and boundaries
Honestly, I truly believe the best you can do for them is to get them away from their father asap.
I could be wrong, and I don't mean to judge you unfairly OP, but I get the sense that you're kidding yourself about how much danger they're in, emotionally as much as physically.
And they don't come first with their father.
Even if they come first with everybody else, it is not good for them to be in a relationship with a parent who puts their wellbeing (physical, emotional) second to alcohol.
Cross-post there with Twinkle.
No I know that them being there doesn't stop him drinking. But I really do know that he doesn't drink every day. If he did then he couldn't pretend that he doesn't have a problem.
I'm not minimising this at all, and when they were younger it was even more bloody terrifying, and I get that it is difficult for people in the UK (or anywhere more enlightened than France) to understand/believe how rubbish it is here in regards alcohol abuse and kids.
This has to go through the courts for there to be any change - and that will take an absolute minimum of a year. If social services are involved it is likely to take considerably longer - probably a further 6 months. If I "take them away" without going through the courts, I will loose custody to him permanently. That is a fact. And believe me when I say that if I magic them away he will hunt us all down and I will loose them for ever and go to prison. I have looked into it, but it would be impossible to do. Court is the only way. Being in the UK certainly wouldn't keep them safe from him.
This is why I am asking for advice on how to help them be safe and a bit more savvy about the drinking. What can I tell them, how can I explain to them in a way that makes sense to them? I am trying everything that any one here says. But none of them are really hitting home. Actually if anything I feel like I'm loosing ground, but maybe that's just my frustration.
But I really do know that he doesn't drink every day. If he did then he couldn't pretend that he doesn't have a problem.
Unless you're with him 24/7 how can you possibly know that? And yes he could - denial is a defining feature of the illness.
While I'm disappointed to hear it, if you say that's how it is in France then I have no reason to disbelieve you. But, regardless of how long the process will take, I think you owe it to your DDs to get it underway.
Have you consulted a UK family lawyer? There must be specialists in the area of international family law.
I'm afraid I'm at a loss as to how to help such young children become more savvy.
I hope others with experience will post, but agree that it's likely that there'll be a reluctance to advise anything other that getting them away from their father's dysfunction.
Yes, I did consult a top British guy before I consulted a French lawyer when we were getting divorced. I'm unclear why anyone thinks that anything in the UK is going to help here. I am under French jurisdiction, we live here, work here, go to school here, have a French divorce and 2 French custody agreements, which would be valid under European law.
I actually have a completely kick ass lawyer here. One of the reasons I cannot do anything is I cannot get anyone, but anyone, to testify against him about being drunk in charge of the kids. And as I am not an actual witness to his current drinking when he is with the kids I can't testify to anything at all. I try to record his phone conversations with me when he is drunk. If he got caught drunk driving, with or without them then that would play into our hands, but my main aim is to keep them out of his car if he has been drinking. And to do that they need to recognise when he has been drinking - thus my original question.
I guess you can choose to take my word for it or not, but he doesn't drink every day. I'm not sure that that actually changes anything anyway. The fact is he abuses alcohol, and when he chooses to drink everything else is secondary at best.
The French family courts currently believe that it is in the best of interests of children to have continuing contact with both parents until such time as the children choose otherwise. And this pretty much goes for much worse situations than this.
I agree that the best way forward is to get the kids, or one of them to write a letter, but that only gets us as far as them getting a lawyer, and then it'll be out of my hands pretty much entirely. And if they say to the lawyer that they don't want to pursue it then we are nearly back to square one again. But, at least they will then have a lawyer.
I'll hold my hands up to not understanding how French law, UK law and European law may or may not work together. I suppose I wondered (because European citizens can move between countries with relative ease) if French law may not necessarily be the last word. I didn't mean to sound like it doubted what you said.
Join the discussion
Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.Register now
Already registered with Mumsnet? Log in to leave your comment or alternatively, sign in with Facebook or Google.
Please login first.