Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you need help urgently, please see our domestic violence webguide and/or relationships webguide, which can point you to expert advice and support.
Girlfriend careless with mini pill(345 Posts)
I would greatly appreciate some input into my situation so I can try and work out whether or not I'm over thinking things.
My girlfriend is taking Cerelle. I have done a lot of reading about this and understand that it should be taken at the same time every day in order to be ~99% effective at preventing pregnancy.
However, my girlfriend is adamant that the '12 hour window' means she can take it any time within a 12 hour period. She has chosen 7am to 7pm. She therefore takes it whenever she remembers between these hours.
I have explained to her my understanding of how it should be used, but she is insistent that she has been using it for a long time and has been assured by a doctor that her use of the mini pill is fine.
We have had a number of conversations about this, which always end in hard feelings. What should be a discussion turns into an argument.
We have only been using the mini-pill for contraception as I trusted she was using it correctly. However, over the past few weeks as I have got to know more about her attitude towards and practice of contraception, I am concerned that we should be using a second method.
I feel as though I have no control over the situation and am placing all my trust in her. I am nowhere near in a position to have a child at the moment - either financially, or in terms of maturity. Additionally, we have not been dating for long. I would appreciate your opinions on the situation.
I went to a Jesuit boys grammar school in the 70s. In the 3rd year we were given a book about how fish 'do it'.
It was very informative, and I now know more than I ever need to know. About fish.
"The context was (unrealistically! ) that you wouldn't be having sex unless you trusted your partner and were adult enough to talk about contraception."
Quite apart from that context being ridiculously unrealistic (they didn't even try to pretend that in the convent school I went to), it's also bullshit.
Even if you do trust your partner and are adult enough to talk about contraception, it is STILL not a JOINT decision.
Controlling your fertility is an INDIVIDUAL decision.
At all times, always.
There might be times when a couple (in a committed relationship where trust has been established) decides that their interests are aligned and that it makes sense to figure out contraception between them.
But it is still up to each of them individually to agree to this and there should NEVER be any complaint or emotional blackmail if either decides they would prefer to resume using something that protects them on an individual basis.
The idea that you get to strop and accuse your partner of not "trusting" you because of their preferred method of preventing conception is so appalling to me. I can't believe anyone would pull that kind of crap with someone they were meant to love and were not trying to control.
Teaching teenagers, who are years (if not decades) off the kind of relationship where it makes sense to trust someone else with this kind of thing, it is totally insane to be teaching them to take JOINT responsibility for contraception.
Girls need to understand what THEIR OWN interests are and how they go about protecting them. Not yet another lesson about compromising themselves to keep some bloke happy.
And boys need to understand that the last time they get any say in what happens to their sperm is the moment they spurt them into a girl while not wearing a condom.
Well, said, JoinYourplayfellows!
I agree Joinyourplayfellows. But you make this sound ridiculously obvious, and I don't believe it is necessarily obvious to everyone that they are individually in control of their own fertility. Unfortunately.
"I don't believe it is necessarily obvious to everyone that they are individually in control of their own fertility."
I agree with me that it is obvious but I also agree with you that it is not obvious
I think it SHOULD be obvious, because it is self-evident.
But there are a lot of cultural factors at play that seem to obscure the obvious for many of us.
And one of them appears to be atrocious sex education that is giving terrible messages to you young people that serve neither boys nor girls, but seem particularly risky for young girls.
Matilda, it's obvious from this thread that the very idea is somehow offensive or ridiculous to many people. The very suggestion is enough to bring accusations of man hating and aggression.
there should NEVER be any complaint or emotional blackmail if either decides they would prefer to resume using something that protects them on an individual basis.
No, there shouldn't. But there are. So the OP should be prepared for it - I hope he's readying his "I'm taking control of my fertility because it's the right thing to do" speech as we write!
I guess it's nice in a way to hear that a guy is concerned for a change rather than just blindly trusting us women, BUT yes, sorry protect yourself is the answer here.......
Have I missed why it's so out of the question for the OP's girlfriend to try and take the pill at a similar time each day? I manage it and I can barely remember to wash my own socks.
It isn't. If she is concerned or minded to do that. It is out of order for the op to tell her she must take it at the same time of the day because of his concerns, him having treated contraception as an afterthought (but like I said originally if not pg no harm done) despite her not sharing them.
I wouldn't use the mini pill because of the user error, I wouldn't feel comfortable taking it within the 12 hour period like she does but I'm not sure she is being careless either and I think it is her body, her medication and her relationship and up to her how she deals with contraception.
If she hadn't thought about it at all that would be a different matter, but she clearly has and further to that has sought advice to inform her decision which she is personally happy with in the context of her life.
The only person who can accurately be described as careless in that relationship is the op really...
Why are you so desperate to make the OP out to be bad?
I think he's made himself out to be bad. Not sure why some people are so keen to absolve him of his responsibility.
Why are you so desperate to make the OP out to be bad?
This will be because she is in dreary radfem 'goon' mode, where all you have is a hammer so everything must look like a nail. Prob. the best explanation.
Still waiting for one of you to come up with a relevant point related to what the op actually said.... Must be a reason why you've not done that but have invested so much time and effort in insulting people.
I know it's going back through the thread a bit but there was some posters that said the GF would think it odd if the BF started using condoms after going bareback and all the issues that may ensue from that (perceived lack of trust etc,)
Am I looking at this too simply but could the BF in this case say he wanted to try some of the more, erm, shall we say 'exotic' types of knobby, ribbed, shaped like a guinea pig etc. types of condom available to the market, in order to get using them and start a new habit that way or would that be perceived as being dishonest. He could later say that he enjoyed the extra protection and this added to the whole experience blah blah to address why he wishes to keep using them. It might cover all bases (for want of a better term!) OR would the GF be upset to think her fanjo not exciting enough and it cause further problems?
Possibly Dinnae. A few of us suggested differing possibilities.
Offred, there's been lots of relevant points made by lots of posters here. You just don't appear to wish to see them as they don't fit into your 'ideology' so you bang on ad nauseum about a 'lack of responsibility', which has already been examined .
I can only see one point at which he made himself look bad and that was when he flounced, due to getting some "unhelpful" answers.
Trying to make him out as controlling when all he seemed to want to do was ask about contraception just seems off as it has been twisted to suit your own opinion.
"The idea that you get to strop and accuse your partner of not "trusting" you because of their preferred method of preventing conception is so appalling to me. I can't believe anyone would pull that kind of crap with someone they were meant to love and were not trying to control"
Or they were not as interested in preventing pregnancy as they professed to be.
Always a good plan to watch what people do, not say.
Bloody Hell - dog with a bone much?
Join the discussion
Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.Register now
Already registered with Mumsnet? Log in to leave your comment or alternatively, sign in with Facebook or Google.
Please login first.