Note: Mumsnetters don't necessarily have the qualifications or experience to offer relationships counselling or to provide help in cases of domestic violence. Mumsnet can't be held responsible for any advice given on the site. If you need help urgently, please see our domestic violence webguide and/or relationships webguide, which can point you to expert advice and support.

Relationship advice sought

(23 Posts)
JoeMof Sat 27-Apr-13 18:26:59

Hi mums,

I'm a guy looking for a spot of relationship advice and thought this might be a good place.

I bought a really nice diamond ring for my gf. But we broke up before I gave it to her. Now I want my new gf to have it. It's probably too soon to be giving her such a nice present but as it wasn't meant for her, does that matter?

Should I tell her the truth? That I didn't buy it for her but now I want her to have it? Or should I pretend I did buy it for her and give it to her later as a big surprise? Or maybe somebody has a better idea?

The only reason I would lie is to make it more special for her.

Thanks in advance.

I would go with the truth

TurnipCake Sat 27-Apr-13 18:31:14

I'd hold onto it for now and if you want to give to her at a later time when it's more appropriate in your relationship, then do so

DuchessFanny Sat 27-Apr-13 19:24:03

Can you return the ring and buy something else for her ?

There's a chance she would always think it was originally meant for her predecessor and it would take the shine off of it (see what i did there ?)

Concentrateonthegood Sat 27-Apr-13 19:38:26

Whilst I'd appreciate the thought behind the gift, I'm not sure i would want something bought for someone else. Particularly a token of commitment tied up with love for your ex.

LemonPeculiarJones Sat 27-Apr-13 19:41:03

I really wouldn't want a ring that DH had bought for another woman.

Sell it and take your gf to Paris or Prague instead smile

TippiShagpile Sat 27-Apr-13 19:45:33

Please don't give it to her. Can you take it back/sell it? If you do give it to her please don't tell her the truth. "Here's a ring I bought for my ex. I can't take it back so here you go, you have it". She'll think of your ex every time she looks at it and you'll be pissed off if she doesn't wear it.

No brainer I'm afraid.

Fairylea Sat 27-Apr-13 19:48:29

Sell it. Use the money for a nice weekend away.

I wouldn't want a ring you'd brought for someone else. And unless you're planning to propose I wouldn't want a ring either!

JoeMof Sat 27-Apr-13 19:59:18

Scoose - That's what my head is saying.
Turnip - That's what my heart is saying.
Fanny - Dior won't accept it back. I bought it about a year ago. Nice pun. ;)

Best case scenario is I pretend it was for her all along and she never finds out.

Worst case is she does find out! That's unlikely though unless I let it slip.

TippiShagpile Sat 27-Apr-13 20:02:46

But every time you look at it you'll think of your ex. Hardly the best start to your relationship. confused

JoeMof Sat 27-Apr-13 20:04:26

Concentrate, Lemon, Tippi - you've convinced me.

Fairy, I think I've got to sell it, haven't I?

Anybody want a cut-price diamond ring that was meant for my ex? LOL.

TippiShagpile Sat 27-Apr-13 20:05:50

Good decision Joe.

Hope your relationship goes well.

smile

Moanranger Sat 27-Apr-13 20:39:22

Just because Dior won't take it back, doesn't mean you can"t sell - try eBay, etc.
Also a ring as a gift only means one thing; get rid of, find something more appropriate.

JoeMof Sat 27-Apr-13 21:24:34

Thanks Tippi.

Moanranger - My ex had a thing for rings which is why I bought it. But good point - a ring is a bad gift idea unless I'm down on one knee.

garlicyoni Sat 27-Apr-13 21:54:54

Okaaaay ... I totally would accept it, in the spirit in which it was - honestly - given. However, I have a massive weakness for rings and would have no qualms about feeling 'obliged' to you for your generosity. Most women, I suspect, are more delicate of feeling than me grin so you're on dodgy ground.

Did you really get it from Dior? Still got the certificate or receipt? Ebay it! You should be able to take her for a slap-up weekend on the proceeds.

You sound nice. Hope things work out for you.

WafflyVersatile Sun 28-Apr-13 00:19:29

I will give you five new pounds for it. smile

If someone gave me a diamond ring, I would think one thing. That one thing would not be, 'what a lovely ring. Never mind that it was for his ex'. Sell it and take her somewhere nice.

Put a picture on your profile of it so I can be horribly jealous.

ToothGah Sun 28-Apr-13 00:39:02

You sound very sweet smile

My ex called me a couple of years ago and said "you remember that engagement ring I gave you....?"

Basically he wanted to propose to his GF (four years after we'd split up) and as we're still good friends and he was skint, he wondered if he could have it back.

I had to point out that I'd actually paid for the ring myself, not him grin

But we had a laugh about it, I was more than happy for him to have it and sell it - but told him that he couldn't give the ring to his new GF as it wouldn't be right.

So he sold it (it was sitting in my jewellery box doing nothing, he remains a very good friend and I wanted to help him out) and he bought another ring for his GF with the cash.

Sadly they split up sad But it wouldn't have been right for him to give her the ring I had worn.

Your situation is a bit different in that you didn't give the ring, but I do think you should flog it and buy a new one smile

JoeMof Sun 28-Apr-13 01:26:01

Thanks for your input and insight everyone.

Garlic - I do still have the certificate so that will help.
MrsPratchett - It's this "oui" one:

2.bp.blogspot.com/-pquC2Dluqm8/USQHNv4L_EI/AAAAAAAADzY/KEf7wnWOjQw/s1600/oui.jpg

garlicyoni Sun 28-Apr-13 15:32:41

Ooh! It's lovely! <starts saving> smile

That's lovely would be nicer in platinum. I think a ring with the word "yes" on it sends an even more weddingy message!

Why won't Dior take it back? if you actually bought it from them and you have the receipt, of course they will.

Lavenderhoney Sun 28-Apr-13 16:54:20

It's lovelysmile

Did your ex actually see it? If not, I suggest you tell your new gf you have a ring you bought and you are going to change it. Unless she loves itsmile

Go to Dior before you eBay. Let them value it properly. If its from last years collection, it may be worth more now, someone may love it but be unable to find one and be on Dior wait list. ( eBay - hmm, fakes etc)

It could be seen as a funky engagement ring with " Oui" on it. Wish I'd thought of that! My dh is French so it would have been nice. Pm me a price if you likesmile

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now