Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you need help urgently, please see our domestic violence webguide and/or relationships webguide, which can point you to expert advice and support.

What do you think is worse: EA or a one night stand?

(28 Posts)
Uppatreecuppatea Tue 05-Mar-13 20:32:00

Saw an interesting debate on some morning tv programme when I was
skiving working from home about what was worse: your DH having a long and involved EA or a one night stand.

I would think the EA would be worse. A one night stand (for example, a deeply regretted drunken fumble) to me would be far preferable to a sustained email, text and meeting-for-coffee relationship in which a deep bond was formed.

What do you think?

racingheart Tue 05-Mar-13 20:39:57

What does EA mean?

Emotional Affair.

Both are the same to me and would mean the end of my relationship

rhondajean Tue 05-Mar-13 20:51:06

EA. I can almost understand a one night stand. It's a moment of stupidity.

But an EA is a prolonged period of taking your time and attention away from the relationship you should concentrate on, with the added side of probably saying things about your partner and betraying their secrets.

Dahlen Tue 05-Mar-13 21:28:10

Isn't that a bit like saying "broken arm, left or right. Which is worse?" Depends on whether you're left-handed or not.

I wouldn't tolerate either. And even if one was less bad than the other, that doesn't make the less worse one ok or somehow worth putting up with because it's not as bad as the other.

Lueji Tue 05-Mar-13 21:30:41

EA, no doubt.

Lueji Tue 05-Mar-13 21:32:58

If he confessed immediately.
Deal breaker if he lied.

But EA has far worst consequences.
Unless he caught HIV or something.

scaevola Tue 05-Mar-13 21:37:20

The actual sex isn't necessarily the worst bit of an affair. It's the lies and the deliberate sustained dishonesty and deception, and the putting of someone else in first place.

More characteristic of EA than ONS.

MySpecialistSubjectIsMN Tue 05-Mar-13 21:40:16

EA is worse, but only if there was no connection to the one night stand, and it was a genuine stupid drunk mistake.

If I'm completely honest both would be a deal breaker, but if I wanted to work back from either of these it would be a ONS. I don't think it's worth the heartache to even try from an EA.

BumgrapesofWrath Tue 05-Mar-13 21:43:25

ONS I think is worse. Mainly because I think even the most sensible person can have their head turned by a "friend", whereas a ONS seems a bit "mucky" to me.

voddiekeepsmesane Tue 05-Mar-13 22:14:15

Having just found out 5 weeks ago that DP had 18 month EA culminating to physical 4 months ago, have to say the EA bit hurts the most. The connection that they had that we used to have but lost because he was giving it to her is worse than the physical ending of it.

Viviennemary Tue 05-Mar-13 22:22:03

EA sounds worse I suppose. But one night stand not great either. I don't think I could choose one or the other.

badinage Tue 05-Mar-13 22:47:31

Agree that this is like asking whether syphilis is better than gonorrhea, but it all depends on the context. I think a lot of women still think deep down that men are a slave to their sex drives and so meaningless sex is more forgiveable than actually liking a woman and valuing her. It must be really hard if you're on the receiving end of this to separate out your judgement of a bloke as your partner or as a man. In some contexts, a bloke who just dropped his pants at the first opportunity is much worse than a man who found himself getting too deeply involved in a friendship but still had some boundaries.

skaboy Tue 05-Mar-13 23:12:21

From a mans point of view the EA is the worst. Its the lies and covering up which have hurt the most.

tawse57 Tue 05-Mar-13 23:13:59

For a moment I thought this was about having a sexual relationship with an estate agent! Yegads! No! Just no!!!

muddyboots Tue 05-Mar-13 23:28:44

My DH keeps trying to reassure me that his affair wasn't just about the sex! Apparently they sometimes used to meet just for a coffee and chat. That's ok then.

Shodan Tue 05-Mar-13 23:41:53

EA, without a doubt, from my point of view.

Continued, prolonged lying, deception and the taking away of the connection I have with DH- that would be the end for me. A ONS would hurt, badly, if I knew about it, but I wouldn't necessarily expect him to own up about it unless there were a real danger of me a) finding out from someone else and b) contracting some unpleasant disease. I am not in the camp that believes that 'honesty is all', in this respect- I believe that if either one of us had a ONS the guilt is ours to bear and bear alone- as punishment, I suppose.

My sister's husband had an EA when my sister was heavily pregnant with their second, much-planned child. He kept bleating to her about how he couldn't understand why she was so upset- it wasn't like he slept with her or anything!

badinage Tue 05-Mar-13 23:51:03

That might be his cack-handed way of saying that he didn't break his vows just for an orgasm muddyboots. As I said, it must be so bloody hard to see it like that when you're in the thick of it, but I think I'd have more respect for a man who actually liked the woman he was having sex with and hadn't just done it with the first woman who'd asked. I'm always a bit more hmm when men tell their wives that they were 'just using the OW for sex' as though that's acceptable, especially if the OW was told this was lurve....

muddyboots Wed 06-Mar-13 01:04:02

Good point badinage! I do agree when you put it like that - I think it was the pathetic tone he said it in.

Daughteroughter Wed 06-Mar-13 01:19:32

I had an EA with a man for several years before I met DH, he would justify himself by saying we had not had sex, my retort was if you feel the need to justify then you know it's wrong. If I thought DH was doing that now I would be v hurt, marriage or long term relationships are about trust, partnership and hinesty

toothfairymummy Wed 06-Mar-13 01:23:48

Message deleted by Mumsnet for breaking our Talk Guidelines. Replies may also be deleted.

EA.

Just sex would have been better.

BelaLugosisShed Wed 06-Mar-13 16:04:43

I could come to terms with him crossing friendship boundaries and forgive that eventually I think, but risking our family for sex with some random woman, not ever and especially if a drunken dalliance, I would lose every ounce of respect for someone so weak and it would kill my feelings faster than a grenade going off.
As badinage says, at least feelings are involved in an EA.
I don't think one is "worse" than the other in terms of how much it would hurt though but for me personally I could never forgive physical infidelity because neither of us have had sex with anyone else so it would ruin what makes us special to me. It would be the total lack of respect, for me and for himself.

MechanicalTheatre Wed 06-Mar-13 16:07:50

An emotional affair would destroy me. The thought of him being that close to another person, sharing things, telling him he loved them...just thinking about it makes me cry. We are SO close emotionally, even though we're having problems at the moment, and we have been right from the beginning.

I would have forgiven a one night stand when I was younger, but not now. It would still be awful, but I wouldn't feel as betrayed. I would just lose a lot of respect for him because I know he would only do it because he was really drunk. And I'd be pissed off that he'd got to that stage of drunkenness where he wasn't thinking straight.

LongingForLamu Wed 06-Mar-13 16:07:53

The EA would make me feel that perhaps he would have been happier married to the OW and insecure (maybe he wouldn't have cheated on her). A ONS, I would only expect to be told if he wanted me to do something about it i.e. throw him out. Other than that, it definitely wouldn't upset me as much as an EA.

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now