www.theguardian.com/education/2016/mar/21/nicky-morgan-under-fire-over-mumsnet-post-on-academisation
The education secretary, Nicky Morgan, has come under fire from furious parents on Mumsnet following a guest post in which she defended government plans to force all schools to become academies.
Hundreds of parents responded to the post which went up on Friday after the publication of the education white paper and has continued to attract comments since.
Reaction from contributors was almost uniformly hostile, condemning the plans as “horrifying” and Morgan’s post as “patronising”. Many said they had signed a petition calling on the government to scrap its plans to turn all schools into academies.
There are now two separate petitions challenging the government’s policy for all schools to become academies. Both have attracted more than 100,000 signatures and a mass rally is planned for this Wednesday.
The Guardian view on the education white paper: too important to rush
Editorial: School administration is a mess. It needs sorting out. But all successful policy has been built on consensus
Read more
While the majority of Mumsnet contributors opposed forced academisation, others criticised government plans to scrap mandatory parent-governors; some raised concerns about children with special education needs, while the proposal for “a parent portal” as a means of giving parents a voice in the education of their child was ridiculed.
Morgan has previously done two webchats with the high-profile parenting website, one as minister for women and more recently in her capacity as education secretary in the run-up to the general election, both of which passed without incident.
Justine Roberts, Mumsnet CEO, said on Monday: “I knew that there were mixed feelings about academies on Mumsnet, but we were quite surprised by the strength of the reaction to Nicky Morgan’s guest post.”
The education secretary wrote in her post that she wanted to explain what academisation meant and why she thought it was the best way forward. “We need to put our trust into the hands of the people that know best how to run our schools – the teachers – and the academy system does just that.
“It gives schools greater autonomy to make the decisions that are right for their community and pupils. After all, we have the finest generation of teachers ever and being part of an academy helps put the power back in their hands.”
School academy plan ‘doomed to fail’, warns Blunkett
Read more
“What a load of absolute crap,” responded one contributor known as mercifulTehlu. “If I were even considering voting Tory next time, this above all else would stop me. Paying big bosses of academy chains hundreds of thousands of pounds while being unwilling or unable to recruit, pay and retain qualified and experienced teachers? No thanks.”
“Complete and utter rubbish,” said GingerIvy. “You ought to be ashamed of yourself for peddling this as an improvement for children’s educations.”
“I am struggling to write something that wouldn’t earn me a deletion,” said yesterdayoncemore. “There is so much wrong with the white paper, I don’t even know where to start. Gove, Morgan and the Conservatives have ruined my children’s futures.”
There were many teachers among the commentators. “As a KS1 teacher and a parent to a three-year-old I’m seriously depressed with how our education system has changed over the years and this is the final nail in the coffin,” said ILoveMyMonkey.
“Nicky, you should be ashamed of what you are doing to our schools and for ruining thousands of children, and future children’s, education!”
Another wrote: “I am an experienced teacher of a core subject. I have moved overseas with my three children. You have put us in a position where emigration is a far superior option for my family than working or learning in the UK education system,” said ravenAK.
And from BettyBusStop: “Nobody believes you, Nicky. Do you even believe this nonsense yourself? Nobody thinks schools are perfect as they are, but forcing academisation on them is not going to improve matters.”
While the tone of the Mumsnet thread was predominantly hostile to the government’s academisation plans, there was at least one contributor who repeatedly challenged some of the negative responses.
The stories you need to read, in one handy email
Read more
PrettyBrightFireflies defended multiple academy trusts, saying they were not all remote, faceless corporations. “I’ve worked with schools with failing MATs, successful first-wave converter MATs, free schools, federations, foundations and community schools. Not all MATs have been successful. But neither have LAs and they’ve had a lot longer to get it right.”
In another post, PrettyBrightFireflies, whose job is to provide strategic training and development in schools, said there were more wasteful failing local authorities than effective, good-value ones.
Asked by another contributor whether the plan to force all schools to become academies was a good idea that would improve the education of children, PrettyBrightFireflies said: “It might be. We just don’t know. But something has to change. It can’t stay as it is.”
Asked to respond to the Mumsnet discussion, a Department for Education spokesperson said:
“Every parent deserves to know their child is getting an excellent education, and they rightly want information about what these changes mean for them. We are determined to make sure every child has access to the best opportunities and to help them grow into well-rounded adults.
“Too many children are not getting the education they deserve and for too long parents have been an afterthought in our education system. Pupils are already benefiting hugely from the academies programme and thanks to our reforms more of them than ever before are going to good or outstanding schools.”
Join our Primary Education forum to discuss starting school and helping your child get the most out of it.
Primary education
Mumsnet made the news again!!!
shazzarooney99 · 21/03/2016 20:27
This reply has been deleted
Message withdrawn at poster's request.
This reply has been deleted
Message withdrawn at poster's request.
This reply has been deleted
Message withdrawn at poster's request.
This reply has been deleted
Message withdrawn at poster's request.
This reply has been deleted
Message withdrawn at poster's request.
Don’t want to miss threads like this?
Weekly
Sign up to our weekly round up and get all the best threads sent straight to your inbox!
Log in to update your newsletter preferences.
You've subscribed!
To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.