ZOMBIE THREAD ALERT: This thread hasn't been posted on for a while.
Reading Tests(93 Posts)
I am trying to decipher what we were told at my daughter's parents evening. Her reading ability had been tested and she is beyond the reading scheme, despite bringing home turquoise level books. She needs to work on her expression (very true) but finds the books terribly boring. In fact she is a reluctant reader.
Apparently in the test she only got 10 words wrong which gave her a score of 30. Does anybody know which test this might be?
she would pick one or the other based on the rest of the sentence if it was in one. like whether you say tear or tear, you have to make a judgement based on the information you have, you don't think about it you just do it.
if it was just in a list of words then depends on her mood probably if I am honest. she would know both words and could read either but is a child more likely to make a careless mistake with that due to speed
I administered the test Periwinkle and the instructions were very clear
The following text provides an example of how you could introduce the check.
In this activity, I am going to ask you to read some words aloud.
You may have seen some of the words before and others will be new to you.
You should try to read each word but dont worry if you cant. If it helps you, you may sound out the letters before trying to say the word.
This practice sheet shows you what the words will look like.
Have a go at reading out loud these four words which you should have come across before [at, in, beg and sum].
The words on this side [turn over practice sheet] are not real words. They are names for types of imaginary creatures. You can see a picture of the creature next to each word.
Can you read out the words on this page for me [ot, vap, osk and ect]?
Ok, now we are going to start reading out the words in this booklet and Im going to write down what you say on my sheet.
In this booklet there are four words on each page. I will tell you at the start of each page whether they are real words that you may have seen before or words for imaginary creatures.
The first page has words for imaginary creatures and you can see their pictures.
Can you start reading the words to me?
She doesn't have to be quick and she can make as many attempts as she wants.
and for the pseudo words phonically plausible attempts are acceptable
I agree with periwinkle. My dd is in year 2 and in the top reading set in her class and didnt pass the phonic test in y1 dispute reading much harder books than her friends with much more confidence. She also being submitted for the higher sats papers for reading etc so I'm pleased with her progress.
Her teacher at the time said it was a waste of time and none of the results showed any relation to the way they work in class. So much so they have decided to completely change the way they do it this year. (Last year the teacher said they we not allowed to give instructions etc so not sure if it had more to do with how they handled the test?)
Looking at those instructions, they sound pretty clear so I'm wandering if our school didnt even explain them....? My dd can read words out like that fine so I think may be our school recognised they did something wrong if they now say they'll do something different next time.
yes with those instructions there shouldn't be any problem (assuming a child can follow instructions of course...)
without the instructions or with them not being properly explained to each child at the time then I can imagine all sorts of problems.
mind you will always get a child (often a bright one) who will decide that it is a pointless exercise and not play along. I have always tried to tell my daughter that she just has to humour the teacher (when she refuses to read a book they have sent home or something because she says it is rubbish, it doesn't have punctuation - well she was right - it didn't, when it was grammatically incorrect -yep right again) and do what they ask her even if she doesn't agree with it.
The instructions are repeated every 4 words Periwinkle
ah well in that case you are just hoping for non stroppiness then
how have so many failed it in the past then? it doesn't make sense
If the child isn't cooperating you can give them a break or try again another day
it really doesn't make sense then that so many schools haven't done well. I have no idea how my daughters school have done and I am not very bothered, so long as she cooperates next year when they want her to do it as I don't want her to be stroppy and difficult (I apparently went through a patch of pointing out to my teacher she was wrong when I was 6, sadly for her I was correct and she did admit that to my parents but she didn't appreciate me telling her obviously and I really don't want my daughter to be difficult)
no it doesn't make sense ... but then lots of schools thought the children were good readers when really they were just good guessers
did anyone correlate the results of the decoding with say just a reading test type activity. one with just a list of real words, not sentences. I mean yes you could still get some guessing with it but it would be interesting to know.
You repeat all those instructions every 4 words?
It must take longer repeating those instructions than doing the test.
I think by the third time you said all that ds's reply to the question at the end ("Can you start reading the words to me?") would be "no" because he'd be bored and want to finish it, and would see that as being the quickest way.
No you repeat the words on this page are real words you may have seen before or alternatively the words on this page are the names of imaginary creatures
DD did the practice test at the end of nursery (although over 4 days - 10 words per day as she was only 3) and got 30/40.
She did last years test in one go at the very beginning of reception ( to assess her phonics knowledge as its hard to work out as she does not sound words out aloud any more) and got them all right.
She was told that some Alice's wanted to communicate with her but some of the words would not make sense iyswim.
However, she seems to follow instructions well and school ( saves the bad behaviour for a home!!)
Ahhh aliens iPad predicting words!!!
My yr1 dd came home at the end of term talking about "pseudo words". Now I know what she was on about! The teacher has clearly been explaining it to the class, and showing them examples in advance. Is that not just "teaching to the test"?
In the reception class I help in (not in my DC school) they use RWI and are already learning "real" words and "silly" words.
its like everything else isn't it, they will inevitably teach to the test from the point of view of wanting the children to be well prepared. If children are going to do an 11+ and have never done verbal reasoning before then they would teach to the test with something like that, GCSE coursework requires a certain style which students must learn to work to in order to do well so I guess it is all teaching to a test in a way.
Is it teaching to the test to teach a child the skills they need to be efficient readers?
no because that is the whole point but if schools are making the children practice them and focusing on silly words then it becomes debatable whether that is teaching them the skills or not. Ok yes the skills include being able to read silly words but still I can see it is a fine line.
Join the discussion
Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.Register now
Already registered with Mumsnet? Log in to leave your comment or alternatively, sign in with Facebook or Google.
Please login first.