Mumsnet Talk

Need to get a new car as both of ours have only 4 doors, but we're not sure what to get. It needs to have a big boot obviously, but not one of those 7 seater jobs.

What car do you have and would you recommend it??

Sorry I meant both of ours have only 2 doors! We need something with 4 doors!

renault scenic

We have a Skoda Octavia. It has a hatchback boot the size of Belgium and four doors. It is basically a Volkswagen Golf with an Audi engine (really good quality) but is far cheaper to buy than either of those. I sold my beloved Audi Coupe (2 door V6 2.6) for this car. Ours is the 200bhp VRS which goes like whatsit off a shovel but they do more sedate versions. Would seriously recommend. Will also satisfy any latent boyracer tendencies that you may have.

Hi BPB

We got a renault scenic to replace my 3 door Vauxhall Corsa and its great. The steering is very light so it doesn't feel as big somehow and there's loads of space (I think! Haven't tried that out yet but my Dad's wheel chair fits no problem as did a huge TV!!)

L, x.

We have a Nissan Qashqai. It doesn't feel like a bus but has the height off the ground to prevent you from having to bend to pt lo in. We did have a PIcasso before, which comfortably fits three in the back but it felt quite bus like to me.

Assuming your looking at hatchback - Ford models - CMAX (People Carriers - SMAX & Galaxy)is larger option to standard models. Focus & Fiesta are both great easy cars plus Ford's come with extra's such as cup holders etc as standard. BMW 1 series is the worst car I have EVER had & so expensive, Audi A3 great but guzzles fuel (and I always got boy raced?!). VW Golf always good & have Golf Plus for extra space.

I've just changed to VW Passat comes with all extras plus HUGE boot - but finding saloon bit of a nightmare to park!

Try looking at 'Honest John' website for info on reliability & build condition, autotrader website is great for comapring models. FWIW I wouldn't buy French (I work in auto manuafacturing engineering), normally stick to German design or build.

Message withdrawn

we have zafira, which does have 7 seats but the extra 2 fold completely flat under the seat back seat and its has enormous boot and extra seats do sometimes come in useful for ferrying other peoples children around.

one thing to look out for - if there is any chance of having a 3 kids before you'd want to change the make sure 3 car seats or at least 2 car seats and a booster fit in the back. one of my friends bought a mercedes estate thing which you'd think was family friendly but she has 2 kids and can never do lifts for parties as can't fit even a booster in the middle, possibly as her 2 car seats are so huge.

Cool! Thanks everyone!

definately recommend the citroen xsara picasso diesel - we have the 2litre diesel and it is has 3 proper seats across the back + a massive boot and also if you need to fold seats down for extra space they fold individually or you can take them out really easily

The old Zafira used to have a terrible resale value - I remember Top Gear doing something about it ages ago which involved manure. May have changed since then. Would agree with Shiregirl about avoiding French cars. And BMW 1 series are truly horrid. Our other car is a 1998 BMW 325i which is v. good though. But am also a bit sniffy about Fords. Wasn't hugely keen on the Qashqai when my husband had the CVT gearbox model on roadtest.

I'm not a huge fan of French cars either, having had no end of problems with Clio that I had until 6 years ago.

Has anyone got an opinion on the Merc A Class, Honda Civic and more opinions on the Nissan Qashqai. We test drove a Qashqai at the weekend. It was OK but had some minor irritations (which will eventually probably drive me nuts).

Depends how many kids you plan on having, and how long you plan to keep the car. If you are sticking at one or two for the time being then there are endless choices, but best to go for an estate because you really will need the space for carting all the stuff about. If you are a car "snob" (which my husband is, so no shame there) then the Audi a4 estate, the volvo estate and the BMW 3 series estate are all good cars. If you are less concerned about the badge, a good choice is a honda (the estate - can't remember what it's called) or the skoda estate (don't laugh - they are built on the same platform as a golf so they are essentially the same car, but at half the price. If you are planning lots of sprogs and want to be the type of mummy who can always take an extra kid home for playdates without using the front seat, then you can't really go wrong with an XC90 (diesel). Cheap to run for a 4 x 4, very very safe and loads of space. One of the only cars (bar 7 seater type vans) that can fit 3 child seats across the back PLUS it has an additional row of 2 seats, so you could actually fit 5 very comfortably. We have gone through loads of cars, including most that I have mentioned, but the XC90 really is my favourite.

I'd advise against a qashqai. Its a big car on the outside but small on the inside (well the front seats are ok, but the rear has very little room and the boot is a rubbish size for such a big car) We have a Nissan tino (the qashqai was a company car) and its so much more spacious boot-wise and in the rear. (tis a petrol guzzler though)

We were always running out of oil with the quashqai too - probably cos it was a new car? (dont know much about these things)

Whilst the safety aspect is great, it feels mega secure when you're in it - I always felt like I was driving a tank - I couldnt see anything around me so always worried about knocking over small children (bit over the top maybe but its true) The back window is very small. Too small in my opinion to get good vision.

I've forgotten other niggles but there were some...

I'm very pleased with my diesel Toyota Corolla Verso, or just Verso as I think the newer models are.

Ford Mondeo, is a good option and has a good boot size as does the old style Vauxhall Vectra.

Skoda Octavia has fab reviews if you're not a badge snob

I'd get an estate rather than an MPV - lots of space but feels like driving a normal car not a Scenic-style mum-mobile

I have a diesel Focus and it is fab

Subaru Legacy. Good sized boot, great fun to drive. Diesel not petrol though (petrol one is very fuel inefficient and doesn't handle as well).

The Honda Civic is great if you only have two or three kids. It's like driving a normal car in terms of length, but someone has done some very clever things with the inside so it's got really good legroom and a massive boot. It's a Honda so doesn't break, fuel economy and emissions are pretty good, doesn't cost a fortune to insure, and goes like the clappers (well, ours does!).

That's the newer Civic (since 07, I think). The only downside is that for some reason there's a spoiler across the back windscreen, so visibility can be a bit tricky, but you soon get used to it.

Thanks. Definitely only have 2 kids maximum. Will probably keep the car long term too, but we don't do much mileage.

Interesting comments about the Qashqai. But I haven't heard of a Nissan Tino.