My feed
Premium

Please
or
to access all these features

Join our Philosophy forum to discuss religion and spirituality.

Philosophy/religion

ettiquette question on religious service .. to sing/mouth words or not ?

7 replies

yaddayah · 22/03/2007 12:53

My FIL sadly died last week, i didn't think his family were religious, but MIL has said there will be a "proper" ceremony at the crematorium, with hymns and prayers, i've always been an athiest, and have no idea, what i should do with regard to prayers/singing, do i mumble,sing/say the words or stay silent with head bowed (my prefered option) or is that rude ?

The last thing i want to do is cause offence to anyone at what will be a difficult enough occasion as it is

Please help mn'ers !

TIA

OP posts:
Report
ceolas · 22/03/2007 12:55

So sorry for your loss, yaddayah.

I really don't think anyone will notice and you should do what you feel comfortable with. Even at church, there are 'regulars' who don't sing or join in.

Report
Tortington · 22/03/2007 12:57

no one sings hymns at funerals dont worry. a few people give it a go - but mostly people are too stunned or havent been to church in dogs.

Report
Marina · 22/03/2007 12:59

I think it is perfectly OK for you to keep silent during prayers and hymns if you are an atheist. Just keep your head bowed if you think it is possible someone might make a remark about it, but as a Christian I'd never expect an atheist or someone from a different faith to say prayers they don't believe
Am very sorry you lost your FIL

Report
yaddayah · 22/03/2007 13:06

thanks, feel less panicky now !

OP posts:
Report
frances5 · 22/03/2007 13:32

yaddayah, I'm sorry about your loss.

Don't worry if you don't want to say the prayers or join in. Quiet comtemplation at a funeral is very normal even among christians.

Report
Iklboo · 22/03/2007 13:36

yaddayah - DH & I both atheists. He recently lost 2 uncles and both his grandparents within the space of a fews months. We didn't sing hymns or say prayers.
One BIL tried to 'pull' us about it saying it was disrespectful. I told him it would be hypocritical of use to do something we didn't believe in just fo rthe sake of it - and hypocrisy was FAR more disrespectful than not joining in with religious things

(other BIL told him to shut the F up and stop being such a TW** and since when was he so religiuos)

Report
madmarchhare · 22/03/2007 13:41

Yadda, we never join in with these things, we try not to make it obvious though by slightly bowing head as we have respect for the 'believers'.

I agree with hypocritical angle on it all.

Report
Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.