My feed
Premium

Please
or
to access all these features

Pedants' corner

Please teach me how to use the apostrophe correctly!

14 replies

notnowbernard · 23/06/2008 21:26

Is there a special way of remembering?

I always get stuck with whether it's (for example)

brother's girlfriend

brothers girlfriend

or

girls' clothes

girls clothes

If you get what I mean (probably not)

GCSE English feels a long time ago now

OP posts:
Report
stuffitllama · 23/06/2008 21:34

someone will be along but in the meantime

it's
hasn't

are examples of an apostrophe instead of a missing letter

Susan's
Peter's
women's
horses' tails

are examples of the apostrophe used as possessive

Report
stuffitllama · 23/06/2008 21:35

in your examples:
my brother's girlfriend
my twin brothers' girlfriends

clothes for girls = girls' clothes

Report
Walnutshell · 23/06/2008 21:41

childrens ('s, s') gets me every time, I realise I am being thick. Cannot believe this stupid bit of pen-fluff deludes me.

Report
stuffitllama · 23/06/2008 21:45

children's
a child's

not being thick I think at all!

Report
notnowbernard · 23/06/2008 21:46

I know!

I consider myself a person with reasonable literacy skills, but the apostrophe gets me every time

Stuffitllama - thankyou. I think I generally get the 'apostrophe as missing letter' thing.

Apostrophe as possesive has and will continue to cause confusion!

OP posts:
Report
jangly · 23/06/2008 21:47

The apostrophe was put there in early times to show that something has been left out. ie, John's bike is short for 'John his bike'. Also, Joan's cat would have been short for' Joan her cat'. The children's dog would have been short for 'the children their dog'.

Report
ShowOfHands · 23/06/2008 21:51

All you need to remember with the possessive use is that the apostrophe goes after whoever owns what you happen to be talking about.

So if the ball belongs to Jack, the apostrophe goes after 'Jack' and you get Jack's ball.

If the children own the dog, the apostrophe goes after 'children' and you get the children's dog.

If the clothes belong to the ladies, the apostrophe goes after 'ladies' and you get the ladies' clothes.

Report
notnowbernard · 23/06/2008 22:01

Showofhands - Thankyou! That's what I was after!

A simple method for a simpleton

OP posts:
Report
onebatmother · 23/06/2008 22:12

Well bloody done ShowOf. Perfect.

notnowbernard, if you're ebaying for example, you can say either 'girl's clothes' or 'girls' clothes', since they could be described as having belonged to a particular (singular) girl, or as having been made for (plural) girls.

and Run credits

Report
notnowbernard · 23/06/2008 22:15

Cheers

The fog is lifting

OP posts:
Report
Walnutshell · 24/06/2008 10:46

Ahh, sort of geddit. thanks stuffit etc

childrens' - ever a word??

Report
Walnutshell · 24/06/2008 10:47

or not because it is already plural. ie children.

the days of pena dn paper were easier - you could just ambigously float an apostrophe over the s!

Report
Walnutshell · 24/06/2008 10:48

(and of course you didn't write things like "pena dn paper")

Report
hf128219 · 24/06/2008 10:49

Reverse the sentence to work out where it goes.

EG Simon's Tie - the tie of Simon
EG Girls' dresses - the dresses of Girls

So the apostrophe goes at the end of the reversed sentence.

Report
Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.