My feed
Premium

Please
or
to access all these features

Pedants' corner

Is this a double negative please?

12 replies

CathsKidStan · 14/03/2014 17:56

If someone asks you "was they (people) of any help?" And the reply is "not much, I don't think" is that a kind of double negative?

Thanks

OP posts:
Report
BikeRunSki · 14/03/2014 17:58

That is technically a double negative, but I think most people would take it to be a negative.

Report
NickNacks · 14/03/2014 17:58

No it's not a double negative.

Report
CathsKidStan · 14/03/2014 18:12

Thank you. Should it have been "were they" rather than "was they"?

OP posts:
Report
BikeRunSki · 14/03/2014 18:19

Were they

But it seems I was wrong last time!

Report
coffeewithcreamm · 14/03/2014 18:27

Yes, it should be 'Were they' & no, that's not a double neg, it seems a definite neg, to me, but I see your point.

Report
CathsKidStan · 14/03/2014 18:35

Thank you again. I very rarely post on FB but when I do I'm very critical of myself. I just need to chillax. Now I'm going to stress about the use of that word in pedants corner Wink

OP posts:
Report
CathsKidStan · 14/03/2014 19:25

Pedants' corner. Aaaah! Step away from the ipad.

OP posts:
Report
Floggingmolly · 14/03/2014 19:30

"Was they" is bad grammar, obviously. The reply is not a double negative Confused. Is Pedants' Corner the place for you, op? Wink

Report
EyelinerQueen · 14/03/2014 19:33

Negative schmegative, you seriously had to ask if 'Was they' was correct English???

Jesus H Christ on a bendy bus.

Report
AnnoyingOrange · 14/03/2014 19:53

OP, that weren't no double negative


Wink

Report
CatWithKittens · 15/03/2014 11:09

Does anybody else share my view that we should be kind to those who come here with a genuine enquiry and reserve any harshness for those who come to mock our pedantry - and, of course, those who claim to know but are actually wrong?

Report
chateauferret · 17/03/2014 22:24

I'd figure 'was' was a typo.

It isn't a double negative because you wouldn't say 'not much, I think'. So the second 'not' isn't superfluous. And you can't say 'I don't think much' by analogy with 'I don't think so' because that means something else.

Report
Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.