My feed
Premium

Please
or
to access all these features

Pedants' corner

I'm going to James' house.

31 replies

LOLisNOTaPunctuationMark · 02/11/2013 13:47

Prepared to admit I'm wrong. Really, I'm just seeking clarification.


Apostrophe and an S still apply when assigning an object to a person whose name ends with an S. Yes?

So why do so many people think otherwise? Is it an optional rule?
I'm honestly not one to get too bothered about grammar and the like.. but this is one thing that bothers me.

I've just received a text from my sister - an English teacher - saying, "I'm going to James' house tonight."

That doesn't make sense to me. It should be, "I'm going to James's house tonight."

You wouldn't say "I'm going to Anne house." You would say, "I'm going to Anne's house."

"I'm going to my mum house for Christmas."
NO!
"I'm going to my mum's house for Christmas."

Can anyone clear this up before my overtired head implodes? Grin

OP posts:
Report
candyflossisevil · 02/11/2013 13:50

Yes you are right. Also wouldn't James' imply there was more than one James?

Report
BrianButterfield · 02/11/2013 13:54

The extra S is optional, I'm afraid. There's nothing wrong with "James' house".

Report
AnnoyingOrange · 02/11/2013 13:55
Report
PacificDogwood · 02/11/2013 13:56

It's optional? Confused

It's not - it should be "James' house'. Disclaimer: English is not my first language, happy to be educated Grin

Report
JoinYourPlayfellows · 02/11/2013 13:58

Either is fine.

James's house is more popular these days with the style guides.

I prefer it - it is clearer.

Report
BrianButterfield · 02/11/2013 13:58

It is optional - it's a stylistic decision. You will find, for example, some newspaper house style guides allow either the omission or the inclusion of the extra S depending on what looks better written down.

Report
PacificDogwood · 02/11/2013 14:00

Oh. Ok, I see.

Thanks for the link too

Report
Moxiegirl · 02/11/2013 14:02

I thought it was James's and same for similar names except Jesus.

Report
mercibucket · 02/11/2013 14:03

I prefer your sister's version. Both are fine though

Report
ThenAgain · 02/11/2013 14:05

Jesus has a house? :D

Report
LovelyMarchHare · 02/11/2013 14:05

I never add the S after the apostrophe. Bit too fussy for my liking. I am aware that either are perfectly acceptable but I'm a bit stripped back when it comes to punctuation!

Report
JoinYourPlayfellows · 02/11/2013 14:08

I think it's far fussier not to add the extra S. It's not like it's too much effort after any other letter.

It's one of those things that people who pride themselves on their pedantry tend to think is the RIGHT way.

Report
BillyBanter · 02/11/2013 14:10

It's optional. And has been for a while or on and off for a long time these would suggest:

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/St_James's_Street


www.sjp.org.uk/historybuilding.html

Report
BillyBanter · 02/11/2013 14:13

When I was going for an interview in St James's Street I thought I'd been told St Jane's street. when I looked at the map at the tube station I realised it must be St James's Street but had been pronounced St James' street despite the spelling. I still don't know how it should be pronounced. I say St. Jamesis street.

Report
TallulahBetty · 02/11/2013 14:14

It's optional, but I always use it. My name ends in S and I've always used 's too. Looks nicer and definitely clearer.

Report
LOLisNOTaPunctuationMark · 02/11/2013 14:16

Thank you all. Smile Can't believe such a big thing is optional. I'll read that link just now.

OP posts:
Report
LOLisNOTaPunctuationMark · 02/11/2013 14:18

Same here, Billy, how should it be pronounced then? If it's written as James' would you still say James's or just say James'? Confused

OP posts:
Report
JoinYourPlayfellows · 02/11/2013 14:21

"If it's written as James' would you still say James's or just say James'?"

People who leave off the second s when writing, also tend to leave it off when speaking.

Which can be confusing.

Report
TheWomanTheyCallJayne · 02/11/2013 14:24

Reading that I thought I like Horry's post that said
'I spell it like I say it. The Smiths' car is older than the Joneses' car. James's car is longer than Laurence's car.'
Then I realised that I have a James and would use James'.
I need a coffee.

Report
TheWomanTheyCallJayne · 02/11/2013 14:25

Join, I would use James' but I would say Jamesis/ziz.

Report
BoundandRebound · 02/11/2013 14:29

Joneses' would never be right if meaning Jones possessive

It could be Jones' or Jones's but not Joneses' unless the name is Joneses of course

Report
BillyBanter · 02/11/2013 14:29

I think spelling and saying James's is less confusing all round although I accept that in some circumstances it's possible it could be cumbersome and awkward to look at spell and say. Can't think of an example though.

Report

Don’t want to miss threads like this?

Weekly

Sign up to our weekly round up and get all the best threads sent straight to your inbox!

Log in to update your newsletter preferences.

You've subscribed!

JoinYourPlayfellows · 02/11/2013 14:30

"Join, I would use James' but I would say Jamesis/ziz."

You FREAK! Wink :o

You can't have it both ways! (You can really. It doesn't matter.)

Report
TheWomanTheyCallJayne · 02/11/2013 14:35

I'm going to go back to calling ds2 Jamie. Grin

Report
BillyBanter · 02/11/2013 14:36

St Jamie's Street. St Jim's Street. St. Jimmy's Street. They could all be confused in the hearing. Best to stick to St. Jocky's Street. No confusion.

Report
Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.