We are having a bit of a difficult time with DS1, almost 3 y.o. He's always been a very compliant child, and easy to reason with. However, he's now often refusing to do what we ask him. An example might be, "Stand up so I can get you undressed" (rather than him lying in a huddle on the floor).
When we give an instruction he almost always asks, "Why?" or, more often, "What if I don't do x?" If I say I'll take away a toy he's playing with, he wants to know where I'll put it, how long for, what would happen if I didn't take it or if he could get it again himself.
This gets into a negative cycle. I've tried turning it around and talking about what will happen if he does co-operate, or telling him I'm confident he will co-operate but he just goes back to asking what will happen if he doesn't do it, and often not doing it.
We phrase instructions in a positive way (what we do want him to do, rather than what we don't want him to do).
I try to use How to Talk strategies but they don't seem to work. He takes no notice or gets crosser when I acknowledge his feelings. Praising or thanking him for co-operation just gets him asking what would have happened if he hadn't co-operated.
I can 'make' him follow instructions by e.g. dragging him upright and hauling his clothes off, but that's difficult and it doesn't seem to help.
Our parenting philosophy is that we are in charge (and have taught him explicitly so) but we would fall broadly into the UP/AP/not much use of punishments or rewards camp rather than a more Supernanny approach.
This behaviour is the same with DH and me. He has been adjusting to a new brother nearly 3 months ago, but this is new behaviour in the last few weeks. He adores DS2 and struggled to adjust at first but now seems fine in other ways.
I struggle to give him much one-on-one time, but when I do try, (eg whenever I bf DS2) he doesn't seem very interested and often keeps on playing with his toys rather than reading with me (he loves reading). He gets good quality time with DH every day. He gets a reasonable amount of sleep / exercise.
Ideas?
Please or to access all these features
Please
or
to access all these features
For free parenting resources please check out the Early Years Alliance's Family Corner.
Parenting
Disobedience / non-cooperation at nearly 3 y.o.
22 replies
AngelDog · 01/01/2013 21:21
OP posts:
TravelinColour ·
01/01/2013 21:24
This reply has been deleted
Message withdrawn at poster's request.
Don’t want to miss threads like this?
Weekly
Sign up to our weekly round up and get all the best threads sent straight to your inbox!
Log in to update your newsletter preferences.
You've subscribed!
Please create an account
To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.