As briefly as I can: My niece has just moved into the house she is renting next term with a group of 8 friends. On their first night they went out and came back at 2.00 am.
Two people were smoking in the garden, when the neighbour?s daughter asked them to stop whispering. She was angry and she got a hostile reply. The rest of the students were in the house, but the windows were open and they had music on.
Her dad then pushed his way into the house and started shouting at the students for making a noise. They were quite shocked, and tried to calm him down, but after challenging some of the young men to come outside for a fight ? which they declined ? the neighbour grabbed my niece on the shoulder, hurting her collar bone. She fell back and injured her ankle. He also pushed and hit out at two of her friends.
One of the students then said he was going to call the police. The neighbour had already done so before he came round, and as he was speaking the police arrived. The neighbour accused my niece of assaulting him by kicking him in the neck. (She is not very athletic, btw, and this would be physically impossible for her).
The police asked them what had happened, but they did not interview them separately and did not seem to be writing down what they told them. They got the impression that the police were quite hostile towards them.
Later in the day, the three people who had been assaulted by the neighbour told the police that they wanted to press charges and were given a crime number, but were not asked to sign a statement.
That's what my niece told me. Obviously, I haven't heard the neighbour's side of things.
What should we do? My niece is now very scared of the neighbour, and worried that he might come round and threaten them again, or wait until she is alone. His reaction to the noise they were making was so extreme, and so immediate, that there feels as if there is something obsessive about it. She does not feel secure in the house and is extremely upset by this incident.
Should they ask for the neighbour to be cautioned by the police against coming near them in the future?
Should she and the others press charges against him, for trespass and assault?
What happens if the neighbour does accuse my niece of assault? Does it matter that the police haven't taken any statements from them?
Finally, my niece has been warned that this will go down on her academic record and could harm her future career. (She was told by the person in charge of student discipline to 'eat a slice of humble pie' and go round and apologise to the man - for him hitting her, presumably. ) Do you know of any way of preventing this going into her records? Does she have the right to see her records at Uni?
Btw, this all happened in the Midlands.
Thank you for ploughing through all this. We are all very anxious about it, and would be very grateful if you could answer some of our questions.
Please or to access all these features
Please
or
to access all these features
Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you have any legal concerns we suggest you consult a solicitor.
Legal matters
Please can anyone give us some advice on a student v neighbour dispute? (long)
14 replies
Solopower · 04/08/2011 10:07
OP posts:
Please create an account
To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.