Depressing to see that 3 more Labour councillors have been suspended.
Though these seem to be largely old comments, presumably dredged up by the press, and only one, in my view, meriting suspension. Salim Mulla, a former mayor of Blackburn, who tweeted that Israel was to blame for the Sandy Hook school shooting, call for Israel to be 're-located' to the US - using the same graphic shared by Shah, and an Israeli conspiracy was funding ISIS, clearly deserves the suspension.
But councillor Ilyas Aziz, who posted on Facebook: 'Jews and Muslims lived together in the Middle East, in peace pre 1948. Perhaps it would have been wiser to create Israel in America it's big enough. They could relocate even now'.' and in another post dating back to 2014, linking to an article about Nazi Germany, said: 'A reminder of the treatment and suffering of Jews in Nazi Germany. Are there are any similarities to how Israel is treating Palestinians.' - to me, this is not anti-Semitic, it's very close to what Shah put, but the other side of a (admittedly very fine) line. He seems to be suggesting Israelis voluntarily moving rather than being (forcibly) relocated, and avoids her hideous turn of phrase 'Problem solved'.
As for the last one, Burnley councillor Shah Hussein - who tweeted at an Israeli footballer that 'your country doing the same thing that hitler did to ur race'. - he definitely shouldn't be suspended, IMO, though Godwin might want to have some strong words with him about breaking his Law. Which is really the main lesson that ought to be taken away about all these Hitler references. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Godwin's_law Plus a quick lesson in politeness and tact wouldn't go amiss. But we can't suspend everyone who mistakenly compares anything (including Israel and Jews) to Nazis or Hitler - we'd break the internet. And it's not necessary. People who say things which are hyperbole deserves ridicule, yes, but not banning.
Again, a bit of me wonders if the Labour hierarchy are now going over the top specifically so that they can get the free speech crowd frothing at the mouth, on their side.