Mmm, the problem with the "leave because we want more independence and to be able to rule ourselves argument" is (as demonstrated by the recent global economic crisis) that our small country is subject to global, economic and political forces very much outside of our control! We are able to combat those more effectively aligned in a group with other broadly similar-thinking nations.
To classify these as "marxist/maoist" as a poster did below is imo frankly ludicrous! The majority of Member States are run on broad Christian social democratic values.
We won't be able to make our own terms when we trade because we will still be subject to EU norms and standards, but without any power to influence policy.
Posters here say our currency is stronger than the euro but some of this strength is due to the UK being part of Europe. The UK has outwardly "recovered" (controversial given recent cuts) from the recent recession more quickly than other EU countries because we have a boom and bust economy which benefits some in society (ie those who are wealthy enough to invest and ride the waves) but is not compatible with countering social inequality (which has declined in UK recently ). Many other of the main players in Europe: have more stable core economies which although cannot described as scintillating, nonetheless provide a very stable platform for their economies.
Yes, we want to trade competitively - absolutely - but don't believe many of these right wing Tories who are very anxious to get rid of the basic protection that EU legislation affords workers. They dress their arguments up in some pseudo "proud to be British" arguments but they are looking to their own interests.
Yes competitiveness is essential -remember that the productivity of many European nations is above our own too.
To say that the fate of our nation was being decided >"in a meeting with leaders of different countries in a humiliating horsetrade deal to determine whether we are allowed to control our own borders or anything else we may want to do and to have to get the permission of other coutries before we are allowed to do so shows how powerless we as a people are because our political class has given our power away" is a mahoosive mis- representation frankly. We are already in the EU. We have as much say as an other Member State. We are (currently) part of the decision making process. But the press manipulates its language as if this is something "being done to us" instead of our own doing. Our potential leaving/opting out of this or that/cherry picking has weakened our position, not strengthened it.
Another poster says "The EU loathes the nation state and actively seeks its destruction." This is nonsense. The Member States have made sure, as the events of this week have shown" that it is the Member States who decide. The Council of Ministers (who made the decisions yesterday) is made up of the governments of the Member States. Nothing was imposed upon us. It was decided by negotiation and consensus.
Re: 20th v 21st century probs? Which problems do we have today that we did not have in 1999? Surely, global migration, global pollution, global security issues, can only be helped by cooperation and coordinated action.
The EU cannily brought in smaller, Easter european countries in to the fold for the purpose of ironing out the economic playing field and therefore enhancing economic and social stability. (Surely it is a given - or it is by anyone who has read a history book - that economic disparity ultimately leads to unrest and war.) If the smaller Easter european nations had been left to their own devices outside of the EU, what exactly do you think Russia would be doing now??
Yes, the EU is bureaucratic and huge improvements can be made but think about the actual practical difficulties of getting 28 nations together to form a consensus. If anyone has been involved in a running a parents committee or parish council, then think of the difficulties and piles of minutes that arise. Multiply this by 28 countries operating with approx 15 or so different languages; of course its going to be bureaucratic!
Lastly, having lived abroad for over 15 yrs, I believe there is a distinct cultural difference between people who live in mainland Europe and those who live in the UK. Generally, there is a huge wish in personal and professional society in mainland Europe for a solution to be found which benefits the majority. In the UK, we are more inclined for a solution which benefits the individual. Imo, in the long run, I believe that together we are stronger!