Unusual toastie fillings?

(49 Posts)
AverageGayLad Fri 12-Aug-16 03:00:39

So I know there's standard toasties fillings, I personally eat almost daily Cheese and Red Onion in mine, but I was wondering if anyone had anything you wouldn't normally add?

For example, I've put leftover Bolognese in before which actually came out brilliantly, so anyone have any other ideas? I'll eat most things except the devil's food mushrooms grin

SpuriouserAndSpuriouser Fri 12-Aug-16 03:04:21

Red onion, houmous, and rocket. It's delicious!

AverageGayLad Fri 12-Aug-16 03:22:24

I'll certainly try that!

Blondie1984 Fri 12-Aug-16 03:28:17

Mashed baked bean and guacamole

AverageGayLad Fri 12-Aug-16 03:33:40

I don't think I've ever had guacamole...

MiaowJario Fri 12-Aug-16 04:11:47

Mincemeat, either on it's own or with grated Apple. ( Mince pies at Xmas type mincemeat). Lovely served with ice cream.

MyFriendsCallMeOh Fri 12-Aug-16 04:12:08

Banana and jam. But let it cool before you eat it, the jam will be hotter than the sun.

Someone bought me a subscription to CheesePosties and they do some very strange, but very excellent fillings: https://cheeseposties.com/the-cheeseboard

Forgot to add! A toastie with soft goats cheese, chopped walnuts and a drizzle of honey is probably the greatest thing on earth

THirdEeye Fri 12-Aug-16 09:28:15

Brie and bacon

Goats cheese and red onion chutney (or chilli jam)

1frenchfoodie Fri 12-Aug-16 15:20:19

Chicken tikka. Lovely dipped in some minty yoghurt.

ruby1234 Fri 12-Aug-16 15:21:46

Marshmallows, glace cherries and chocolate buttons. Serve with ice cream.

TroysMammy Fri 12-Aug-16 15:23:11

Ham, cheese, spring onions, scrambled egg.

LadyMonicaBaddingham Fri 12-Aug-16 15:25:36

Sliced pear and blue cheese

Captainkanga Fri 12-Aug-16 15:26:10

Nutella, peanut butter and sliced banana

AmserGwin Fri 12-Aug-16 15:26:25

I once had a mushy peas toastie as a skint student, but I wouldn't recommend it

AtleastitsnotMonday Fri 12-Aug-16 15:26:33

There's a postal order service for toasties?! That's genius!

SwearyInn Fri 12-Aug-16 15:28:17

Haggis and cheddar

Hoppinggreen Fri 12-Aug-16 22:54:24

Mozzarella and anchovy

cdtaylornats Sat 13-Aug-16 12:00:36

If you are doing the toastie in one of those Breville type machines then chocolate or jam - its a bit like pop tarts

Cookingongas Sun 14-Aug-16 18:25:09

Leftover chilli, cheese and avacado. Best toastie on earth.

Beans and cheese

Cheese ham and chutney

Strawberries and Nutella

You can make triangular sponge too. Just make up cake batter and pour in. Far too easy and fattening.

SimplyNigella Sun 14-Aug-16 18:30:25

Ham, cheese and pineapple- a Hawaiian pizza in toastie form.

Vajazzler Sun 14-Aug-16 18:32:24

Hotdogs beans and cheese!

BikeRunSki Sun 14-Aug-16 18:34:24

I had a flat mate once who used to put beans in, name a little hollow and crack an egg into the hollow.

kennycat Sun 14-Aug-16 19:55:53

I have cream cheese in mine and then have the crusty bits of actual cheese from the children's toasties. Sliced mushrooms sometimes go in. Basically anything leftover from the fridge.
I wonder if pate would be nice; anyone tried it.

I'm just thinking of sweeter options and I'm wondering if cream cheese and lemon curd or jam would be nice. Cc and jam is nice on a normal sandwich so I bet it would.

Ooooh you buggers, now I'm hungry!

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now