disappointed weigh in after 4 weeks of 5.2 and 30 day shred

(20 Posts)
blurredlines Wed 18-Sep-13 09:23:57

Trying so hard! even making sure i am sticking to 1400 on non fast days. Also doing 30 day shred. Lost 5lb in first week 1lb the second and have maintained ever since. Where am I going wrong! Im still far to heavy for my height 5.4 weight 10st 12lb. Help please!

RippingYarns Wed 18-Sep-13 09:31:39

After 2 weeks you will be building muscle, which weighs more than fat. Also, I think your non-fast day calorie intake is too low. Your metabolism will slow down too much and you will not lose weight fasting like that. I might be wrong, but thought the fasting plan was effective because it shocks your metabolism into working more efficiently. 1400 cals is very low.

blurredlines Wed 18-Sep-13 09:37:10

Thanks Ripping I stuck to 1400 as i thought it was my right BMR. Im not very active through the day (desk job) you see.

IsThatTrue Wed 18-Sep-13 09:38:15

Have you worked out your TDEE? I'll see if I can find a link.

I think you're not consuming enough calories. 5:2 means you can basically eat normally on your non fast days. Under eating by around 600-800 (based on your exercise level I'm guessing) 5 days and 1500 ish 2 days you are under eating by 6000-7000 calories a week. Plus what you earn back by exercising.

Also while I am eating well/exercising for weight loss I may have a few weeks where I stay the same but my shapes changing and then further down the line I'll lose around 7lbs in a week. Have you tried measuring yourself as well to see shape changes?

You need to eat more on your non-fast days. I am a similar size to you, and my BMR is 1400. Remember BMR is what you need if you are lying comatose in bed. Eat to hunger on non-fast days!

RippingYarns Wed 18-Sep-13 09:40:56

How are you finding the Shred? Have you taken measurements at all?

Lots of us on the Shred threads had no actual weight loss but are dropping inches.

blurredlines Wed 18-Sep-13 09:46:50

Just looked at a TDEE calculator and it looks like im not eating enough calories on non fast days.
I am actually really enjoying the shred. I havent taken any measurements but some of my clothes do feel looser around my legs.

ErrolTheDragon Wed 18-Sep-13 09:54:41

Your BMI is 26.1 - that's not 'far too heavy', its a little bit overweight. Its harder to lose weight when you're not much over! The important thing isn't so much weight as fat - do you feel firmer? I've been doing 5:2 and shred and have similar experience to you - lost about half a stone and now seem plateaued, but I'm way stronger, more muscle and less flab and feel healthier and I'm thoroughly enjoying being able to eat chocolate without actually gaining weight! I think if I was really interested in losing weight I'd not calorie count on NF days but I'd try to limit carbs/eat low GI.

ErrolTheDragon Wed 18-Sep-13 10:00:14

Oops sorry typo in the BMI calc - 27.8 but that's still not way over 'normal' range.

Also, you must look overall and not week by week - 6lbs in a month is fantastic given that you're only a tiny bit overweight.

You must do a proper TDEE - 1400 sounds really low confused

Pagwatch Wed 18-Sep-13 10:10:05

Also, building muscle will make you leaner but may stall your weight loss. Your clothes should be the motivator when the scales are not.
I have stalled olds of times while I have been working out but I definately get more slender.

Are you drinking gallons of water because you really really must.

blurredlines Wed 18-Sep-13 10:49:01

I have quite a small build with narrow shoulders but have a large 34F chest so weight extra weight shows on me quite alot. I will increase calorie intake on non fast days but i always assumed weight loss is simply burning off more than you eat. Guess i was wrong!

Thanks for all your help. smile

ErrolTheDragon Wed 18-Sep-13 11:08:16

I'm an idiot - I was right first time with that BMI!smile

I'm not sure its necessary to drink gallons of water (the '8 glasses a day' is a myth) but it is important to drink before and after the shred, and do drink that 8 glasses or so on FDs when you're not getting the normal amount of water from food and probably limiting normal drinks like tea.

ErrolTheDragon Wed 18-Sep-13 11:11:50

Weight loss is burning off more than you eat, but constant calorie restriction turns down your 'oven'. Exercising and building muscles raise it.

frenchfancy Wed 18-Sep-13 11:56:16

You really should have taken measurements, the tape measure is your friend; 4 weeks of shred will have built up some muscle, but I guarantee you have lost inches, especially round your waist.

coveredinweetabix Wed 18-Sep-13 14:06:45

Are your clothes looking any different? Have people commented on your weight loss? I ask this having had two months of a weight plateau during which I completely changed shape (my boobs & part of my bum disappearing; cheek bones appearing and there being a hint of ribs & hip bones). I have had so many compliments and yet get really frustrated when people say "oooh, you've lost weight" as I haven't! Suddenly I've lost 3lbs this week. My "history" is that I'd been calorie counting since August 2012, had lost 1.5stone by Xmas, lost another 0.5 stone until May (well, it was more than that as I put on a bit over Xmas and then again over Easter) and then just stuck at 11st4. I started writing down everything I was eating as I thought maybe things were slipping in without me noticing, started doing zumba twice a week, then added the shred and then, three weeks ago, started 5:2 but, after two weeks of that (during which I'd actually done 4:3), I'm suddenly 11st after a fast day and 11st1 after a non-fast day. So hang in there. It is so frustrating but your weight will go down again. I'm also 5'4" so am desperate to shift a few more pounds and finally get to healthy BMI.

blurredlines Wed 25-Sep-13 09:26:58

Well I followed all your advice and up my calorie intake (even enjoyed and lovely curry and and beef Sunday roast over the weekend) and I lost a pound this week!! Finally!
Thank you for all your help ladies !

ErrolTheDragon Wed 25-Sep-13 09:38:48

Win-win! excellent.

BsshBossh Thu 26-Sep-13 20:06:21

Excellent news!

RippingYarns Thu 26-Sep-13 21:00:53

well done grin

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now