ZOMBIE THREAD ALERT: This thread hasn't been posted on for a while.
scottish education system particularly edinburgh(31 Posts)
Hello I'm Jane and I'm unashamedly trying to make my son's school experience as easy as I can! We live in england and he attends a lovely primary which he enjoys. However, his birthday is in august and he is the youngest and smallest in the class by far! He's not short of friends but i feel that they have many advantages over him. For example, he's keen on football but physically he's no match for his peers! He's often been a little behind developmentally: nothing major, just potty training, writing etc- he gets there in the end but i think he sees himself as being not as clever/fast etc as others. He is friendly but naturally quiet. I just feel he has no "buffer" in his current school year- at nursery he played with kids his own age and younger and i would love for him to have that opportunity at school and not just be the young, cute one (no boy wants to be labelled "cute"!) He's about to turn 7.
So, the above was rather a long intro to my actual question! Sorry! I'm wondering where my son would be agewise in the scottish classroom. I understand that the eldest is march and youngest end feb but then i have read that parents with kids born between sept and end feb have option of dropping a year and if this is a common practice then once again, an august born child is the youngest in his class, ha! is this what happens in reality or do very few parents actually hold kids back for a year?
i'm very interested in edinburgh- there are massive draws besides the feb cut-off for school so going to ask another cheeky question- do many families live in tenements nearer the city?
i note that there is a steiner school and strongly considered steiner education as believe the kids might be able to mix more easily with different aged kids but overall not convinced it wouldn't be a big risk in other ways.
Thanks for reading this!
Hi there from Edinburgh. Both my DC are July birthdays and in the Scottish system they were bang in the middle of their year groups. In reality although the cut off is Feb, there are very few children with Dec/ Jan birthdays who are not kept back for exactly the reasons you have concerns about your son.
Whilst I applaud your wish to do your best by him, are you seriously considering moving house/job etc to relocate to Edinburgh for this reason? Access to state schools in the Scottish system is strictly done by catchment area, although you can make out of catchment placing requests if you want to apply to a different school, but these are considered only if there is space in that school and against a strict set of criteria. There is a significant issue aruond school places in the city at the moment in the better schoools and neighbourhoods due to increased population , and you cannot even apply to any school until you have a permanent address in the city.
See here for full details of the process. School places Edinburgh
The fact that your son is now 7 he would go in to Primary 3, so it will depend on what schools have places available in that year group.
There are lots of families who live in the city centre, but overall Edinburgh is an expensive place to live so do have a quick look at property prices / rents as part of your decision. Edinburgh Property Centre
My son is an end feb birthday and we have decided to keep him back a year for the reasons you've listed. There were 5 in his nursery class with jan/feb birthdays and 3 are staying back, 2 are going to school this year.
Just to add, the parents of jan/feb birthdays can make their own decision to keep kids back. Those with oct - dec birthdays had to have a 'reason' and have a meeting with someone from the council to agree it, eg SN.
it tends to be only children with January and February birthdays that defer with the odd December one thrown in (you have to fight a bit more for extra nursery funding if they dont have Jan/Feb birthdays). Even then they dont always defer as dd and ds both have younger Jan/Feb birthday children in their classes. DD and ds are November and October birthdays so are among the youngest in their year groups.
Thank you all very much- that's given me a lot to chew over! and cheers for all the links.
Edinburgh does have other charms for me besides the relative ages of school kids but i'll hold my hand up that having my son in the middle of a class agewise is a massive incentive! Ironically, his 4 yr old sister's b'day is 30th November so she'd be among the young 'uns but i know this wouldn't phase her!
My son is 5.5 and will be starting P1 in a couple of weeks. He's a mid February birthday and we had the debate about whether he should go into P1 last August or this year? What tipped it for us was the thought of him always struggling to keep up with others in the class but more the thought that he would be starting University (according to my DH he's going!) at 17 and for me that was too young. I would rather he was that bit older.
Don't blame you, RVP- exactly what i'd do in same position.
That's exactly why we have decided to keep DS in nursery for an extra year as well. Also didn't like the thought of him going to high school at such a young age.
Yes the thought of high school definitely figures! Just as an aside, my son started school ten days after his fourth birthday- he had no clue as to what was happening! I just remember thinking he looked like a toddler in his uniform. So they essentially start six months earlier in england- crazy! I've never felt comfortable with situation and i do believe- in his case- a few months grace would make a big difference. It's not even the academic side of things it's social side, sport, physicality, confidence etc
Be aware though that all the "popular" schools in Edinburgh as currently suffering from massive overcrowding. .have heard of 60 pupil composite classes. .
I have 2 January kids, my son was assessed as being suitable for school at 4.7yrs and we were refused further nursery funding. He didn't cope well with school and we moved areas and put him into a new school in P1 again. He was much more ready, and now at 16 he is doing very well educationally.
I had no intention of sending my daughter at 4.7yrs, but her nursery said she was more than ready and she went into P1 on time. She is now 14 and does wonderfully academically, but it wasn't always easy socially as she was always smaller and bit emotionally younger than most of the others. In hindsight I wish I had kept her back, it would have more good than harm.
If you do move, then your Ds is a great age to go into P1 in Scotland.
I can't comment much on schools but there are plenty of families that live near the centre in tenements or flats within town houses.
thanks for the input, ladies- all very useful.
Fanjo if there is a composite class with 60 children, my understanding is that it would also have to have 3 teachers. Class size limit for a composite is 25. DD3 (late Jan birthday, deferred entry)has spent the last three years in a composite class, and it was absolutely the making of her.
Deferred entry for my Jan dd as well. She was considered fine to go on but the decision was ours alone (may have changed since your experience Preferdogs, as now is definitely the parents' decision.) My ds is also a Jan birthday and despite being tall and confident, I aim to defer him too.
I don't think it sounds mad to move for the reasons you give. It does make a difference not to always be the youngest.
Yes it was a class with several teachers, at South Morningside I think.
South morningside and Sciennes are the only two in the city that are really bursting at the seams. Don't avoid a whole city due to two primary schools, there are loads of other good primaries.
I finished school at 17 and turned 18 around fresher's week at uni but I could have easily taken a gap year instead and been the same age as the English students (went to a scottish uni dominated by english students).
All my family are september/october birthdays and the school year suited us well.
Re. the steiner school... well.. that's your choice really, i live near it and it's a nice area but i wouldn't go for it myself.. it's a big decision to basically pursue a completely different route to mainstream schooling, and probably quite unusual at your ds's age to swap into steiner.
Legally, anyone can defer if their child has not turned 5 by the start of the school year. But you are unlikely to get a funded preschool place, unless their birthday is Jan/Feb or there are specific issues.
So - it is relatively common for Jan/Feb birthdays to defer (maybe around half of them do?) and much, much less common for earlier birthdays to defer.
In practice, as an August birthday your DS wll be around the middle of the intake year.
As to Steiner - well, I'd just say you really, really need to look into that whole can of worms before making a decision, as there are a lot of people with strong opinions about their experiences with that system.
We looked into moving to Edinburgh quite seriously last year (but I can't get a job so we can't move ) and we were looking at flats and "double uppers" (part of a converted house) on the south side of the city centre. In that area your state secondaries look pretty good with James Gillespies and Boroughmuir schools regularly coming top in the state area stats. I agree with the earlier poster who said be careful about the available places in Primary. The most reliable information is via the school secretary when they schools re-start again this month. Sciennes and South Morningside are full, but they are quite big so can cope with extra numbers easier than the small places like James Gillespie's Primary School which teaches in a single open plan space for all age groups and therefore has little flexibility on accommodating extra classes etc. We found it useful to speak to all the schools and visit all of those in the catchments that we were looking in. Given that the gaelic school is/was leaving Tollcross Primary we reckoned that it might be the place to get a space while all the others were struggling. Good luck - and don't leave the job search until the end of your investigations like I did!
Oh - forgot to say that you can download all of the catchment maps from the Edinburgh City website. Although be aware that most of the south side schools were not able to offer all their catchment pupils places last year so (as the defined catchments can be quite enormous compared to English schools) consider making sure that you are searching for houses much closer to the school than the catchment boundary implies.
We moved to Scotland when dd1 had completed KS1/SATs/year 2 in the English system. She went into P3, which covered very similar work to Y2 (although as she is born in March, the school was able to offer her the flexibility of moving to P4, but we all agreed that P3 would suit her better socially). The school is fantastic, with around 25 kids in her class, a 10 minute walk away with no problems in getting a space as we are in catchment. She has been able to progress at her own rate, rather than being taught at the rate that will get her to pass SATs - she had got level 3 in all her SATs, but the school was still able to stretch her. Can't rate the Scottish system highly enough, especially compared to the inflexibility of the English system. Although I hear it can be difficult getting school spaces in Edinburgh......
I'm in the process of moving to central Edinburgh and have been told by 5 primary schools that while they can give me a place for my 8 yr old they have no places for my 5 yr old - just going into primary 2 in the Scottish system. My catchment school is Bruntsfield Primary and my youngest is going to be 4th on the waiting list - and that's the list for those in catchment area with a sibling in the school, so the highest priority level. Be aware as well that you can't apply to join school till you actually move and have proof of address. I'm told by the schools I've spoken to that the youngest 3 years are all heavily over subscribed just now. I'm moving in October and have no idea where my youngest child will be going to school - stressful!
Stiff - have you looked at Tollcross PS and considered an out of school catchment application? It is not too far from Bruntsfield although the school building and surrounds is not as nice as BPS. But one of the management team had come from Sciennes so we liked their ethos.
Tricot - thanks, I hadn't considered Tollcross but I will now look into it.
Join the discussion
Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.Register now
Already registered with Mumsnet? Log in to leave your comment or alternatively, sign in with Facebook or Google.
Please login first.