Going onto a secondary/senior school without knowing any other children. Experiences?(44 Posts)
This is a hypothetical question at this moment in time. If anyone has sent their dc to a senior school without any of their peer group can I ask how you found it? How did your DC settle?
My dd is only at the end of Y3. At the moment she's very bright and doing really well. The primary is a bog standard state - not outstanding, not awful. Always in the middle of says and league tables. The nearest secondary school is literally around the corner from the school and the children are naturally pushed in that direction. The problem, I don't think the school is much good. It has a new shiny building and has just become an academy, teachers are lovely....but the results are bad. I know it may improve. It may not. It's always under subscribed.
Dd has already started making 'plans' to go to that secondary school although I've told her we don't know yet.
This morning I was talking to some mums I know with dcs in y5 who are going to look around the (bad) school today. I asked them if they would look at anywhere else and was shocked to hear they all said no, that they couldn't be bothered. I find this is the attitude of most parents at the primary. That the most important thing is that they're with their friends and not bother with results. It depresses me a bit as I feel abnormal that I want to look elsewhere.
We're in S.Bristol. We have no selective grammar schools. My only (better) option would be going into N.Somerset (as I'm virtually on the border) but this is by no means a given. I'm in a bit of a stress about it actually....and she's only 8!
So after a huge long ramble (this is like therapy!) can I ask anyone's experiences of not choosing a school along with their dcs peers. How was it and was it the better decision? It is most important that the dc have good friends and therefore do well no matter where they go?
My dds 1 and 2 went up to senior school with a couple of girls they were at primary with, I can honestly say that it caused nothing but trouble
year 7 girls are bitches anyway,including mine, but they tend to make other friends and branch off and theres always one that clings on.
dd2 went knowing not a soul. I was worried and did mention it to the school,but she had no trouble at all, talking to other parents in the same situation I think girls do fine going off 'alone'.
My DD was bullied badly in primary school. We looked at three secondary schools, and asked her what her choice would be. She chose the one that was furthest away, because it was the smallest and no one from her school was going there. It was our choice as well as it had an excellent reputation, results and pastoral care.
She was a bit nervous of starting without her friends, but settled in immediately. She is quite shy and quiet, but made friends and has been happy there. She now loves school, and we are very happy with our decision.
My dd went to secondary last year without any of her friends at primary. It wasn't a problem at all. She went to a secondary school where a lot of the girls came up from the junior school so they knew each other. She settled in very well and quickly and now is friends with both girls from the juniors and the new girls like her.
TBH, their friendships change so much at this stage, even if your dd went to a school with all her friends, she would still make new friends and maybe not even see the old ones as much.
Even if primary friendships are good, I think it's healthy to have a fresh start at secondary. Dd has managed to keep in touch with her old primary friends and sees some of them from time to time. It's nice to have some out-of-school friends.
Interesting heronsfly thanks. My dd is good friends with boys and girls (at the moment!). I do have a younger ds though that I would ideally like to follow her to wherever she goes.
I agree with Dancergirl. It's great to have friends in school and out of school.
Thanks dancergirl and primrose. That's sounds positive.
I haven't discounted the local school, I'm just finding the 'cant be arsed' attitude of many parents a bit off putting. I want a really good environment where it's the 'cool' thing to learn. Dd thrives on learning. I get the feeling from the local school, that high aspirations are a bit 'weird'
Dd has many non-school friends at the moment so hopefully that will continue.
I did it. We had two high schools - everyone else from my primary school went to school A, I went to school B. It was fine.
I later went to school A for their 6th form and was very glad I hadn't gone there for the rest
Well don't listen to the other mums, do what YOU think is right. There's no way I would just send my child off to the local school without considering other options. I'm not in your area but look at elevenplusexams.co.uk - they'll be a section for your area, you can get a lot of info about schools.
Woo thanks Dancergirl. I'll have a look. I think I'm worrying really early, but I feel like I'm wondering in the dark. I think I'll just have to keep quiet around other mums
Loads of people came to my secondary school without anyone else from primary, and I myself came with only 3 others who I wasn't really friends with. Everyone was completely settled by the first week or so and made friends really easily. I think parents tend to worry about lack of friends more than the children and at that age friendships change a lot anyway.
DS's year 6 primary class scattered all over the place. He and one other boy - who was quite a good friend of his - ended up at the same school, but in different classes, and really as soon as they started secondary they started drifting apart and making new friends. I think they are still facebook friends now but never really talk to each other. He has drifted apart from most of his other primary school friends too, which I think is completely normal.
I really don't think it should be an issue to go to a different school from the rest of your primary class. If anything, I think it's probably good to be able to make a fresh start and slightly reinvent yourself...
As far as the Bristol school situation goes, you will also have the option of entering the lottery-style entry system for the Cathedral school and Colston's Girls (though that wouldn't have the option of your DS following on). Entry is basically random (you have to take a test, but they accept a fixed proportion from each ability band, so it's not as if doing well will get you a place) except for a few places on musical aptitude at the Cathedral School, and linguistic aptitude at Colston's. I'm presuming you're not religious, or you would also be looking at St Mary Redcliffe or maybe St Bede's.
If you're looking at North Somerset, Backwell is very popular, but you may be too far outside catchment; St Katherine's (Pill) seems to have an improving reputation, and does accept a lot of children from Bristol.
thanks exexpat. Yes, Cathedral School is the holy grail for us aspiring state ed parents. I think the whole of Bristol must apply. My chances would be very very slim but worth a go.
I'm slightly nearer Backwell than St Katherine's, but I still don't think I'd have much of a chance of getting it. My nearer option would be Chew Valley that is rated outstanding and gets good results. However local mums really slag it off (listening to local mums again) for some reason, although this may be because they all blindly go to the local school.
Dh and I are devoted atheists so chance of St Mary Redcliffe.
I don't think I have too many options. Depressing.
Thanks for wise words though everyone.
*no chance of St Mary Redcliffe.
Hereabouts the primary kids go in many different directions are there are selective and non selective schools. It's normal to go to a school on your own or with 1 person (DD2 didn't actually like this person very much LOL).
There is plenty done at all secondaries to settle kids in. If yopu are sending a child out of area/to an unusual school I'd suggest you make sure they attend all the settling in activities ( some may be in the holidays).
I just wish there was at least one grammar school to even try for
Nice to hear thanks Theas18
DD went to the Secondary school without having been in any of the feeder Juniors. She made friends easily but then she is like that.
The school is a bit like the one you described. Most children live on the estate round the school; in the good old days most pupils (i.e. the people who are now parents) went to the mass-employer down the road (now closed down) so there was no imperative to think outside the box. In Year 7, the children thought that we lived on the moon because we were from so far away (oooh, all of a mile and a half!). There was a very clever child who went there because her parents didn't even know that the local superselective existed but they managed to work this out after a while and she got good enough GCSE from the bog-standard to go there for sixth form.
Most families with gumption managed OK in the end. Many reports have shown that the deciding factor is the family, not the school.
Haven't read whole thread but looks like you're getting some good, local advice.
On the general question I think I'd try to find someone who was going up to same secondary to get to know at least a little before DC moved up - but at a push this could hopefully be done in the summer hols.
Both my DC's have gone up/ will go to secondary with a few friends from primary, but many others going to a different (more local) school.
I think you're quite right to think ahead in a pro-active way about which would be the best secondary for your DD. The friendship aspect can be worked on alongside this. But I'm really glad mine are at a good school with others who (mainly) want to do their best.
And I'm impressed with how well DD (14) has kept in touch with good friends who've moved to different schools, and even different cities. As well as developing a lovely friendship group at her new school.
I hope DS will develop some similarly good friendships when he moves up to secondary in September.
Luckily he's moving up with a couple of good friends which should get him off to a good start.
Good luck with it all harry
Senua, our local schools sound very similar. We live a bit away from our primary and people claim we live 'miles' away. Most children live 2 streets away from the school, their parents went there and they live next door to their mum and their sister. I find that really alien to me.
Thanks Juggling. I have a similar mindset to you I think. It's good to know your dd is doing well.
I know it's mainly about the family behind you and their support but I'd like the school environment (and their peers) to just be up for learning and aspiring.
Also nice to know I'm not completely mad for thinking about this at the end of y3. Most people have told me I'm crazy. I really must stop listening to other people so much
I think you just want them to be with other children who have some respect for their teachers and find learning a generally interesting and positive experience, apart from any more fancy considerations, don't you !
Having been a teacher myself I know how shocking and disruptive some children's behaviour can be. Think it's really true that a few can spoil things for all the rest.
Anyway, I hope you can find a really good school for your DD, where she will be very happy, and make some good friends too x
My Y6 DS is the only one going to his secondary school in September. The secondary school has arranged after school activities for the 'singles' who are joining. So far he has been swimming, done a treasure hunt and is due to go for a sports afternoon this week. He is already talking about the other children he has met. I presume these will be put in the same form as him when he starts.
I would imagine many schools do a similar sort of thing.
Ooh, what a nice thoughtful school sunny
No-one from my primary school went to my secondary school It was 24 years ago so my memory is a little hazy but I have no recollection of being worried about it or of it being a problem. I remained friends with some people from my primary school and made new friends. I'm still friends with people from both schools now.
Yes Sunny, that's sounds fantastic. I would feel much better if the school I choose did that. A good question to ask on open days
Thanks LadyMcbeth. The more positive stories people give the better I feel.
I went to school in Wales over 30 years ago. Back then I don't recall any league tables or even a 'choice'. It was quite rural, so it was just a given that all the surrounding villages sent their 11yr olds to that school (which in turn turned out to be a great school because it was so mixed but that's for another thread!). So I ended up going to nursery, primary and secondary with all the same children. I even ended up at the same college as some. I do think this is clouding my judgement a bit, and am beginning to see that this experience is not at all normal
I went to a different secondary from all my friends. There was one other girl from my school who went there, but I really didn't like her!
Honestly? The first day was really tough - I got lost and sobbed my way through art. But on the second day, some nice girls strode up to me on the school path, saying "you looked a bit fed up yesterday", grabbed me cheerfully by the arm and by the time we reached the school building we were giggling together like the best of friends. I never looked back.
In your situation, I definitely wouldn't just go with the flow. Look around and find the right school - she'll cope. And you may well find that you are not the only one, by the time the other parents' children are a bit older.
I started visiting secondary schools when DD1 was in year 3, as I was so worried about the whole thing (I'm in Bristol too). As I have 2 DDs, I put Colston's Girls' first, not really thinking we had much chance. As it turns out we have been lucky, and she is 1 of 7 in her year of 60 with a place - a couple of her close friends are going too. I think only a couple got into Cathedral though, as it is so clogged up with siblings.
Having worried about this for years, I do honestly think things in Bristol are really improving. Less children leave the city now as a result. This may mean that you could be lucky with Backwell too. A friend's DD in Long Ashton got in from the waiting list.
An ex colleague has her daughter at Chew Valley and she is really happy and doing well - from what I have heard it is a good school too.
Good luck - I hope you find a solution.
Thanks Marmite. It's always interesting to hear others local school experiences.
I'm not sure Colston Girls extends its 'catchment' out to us. I know it's a lottery system (isn't it?) but I think they only allow applications from various postcodes. Or is that totally wrong?
I know friends in Southville last year who banked on Backwell but didn't get a place so went to St Katherine's. However, I'm nearer Backwell than Southville so I don't know what to think.
Chew Valley is rated Outstanding and has had consistently good results for years, however hardly anyone I know considers it. Although it is oversubscribed. I'm unsure why about that too.
It's all so confusing. It's hard to get a real view point as many parents will just defend their own choice and tell you awful stories about another school
My DD started secondary school this year (year 7) at a private girls school - she didn't know anyone there at all. She settled in beautifully and hasn't looked back. The school has great pastoral care and put a lot of effort into orientation.
I would just choose the best school that you can for your child and not take peers into consideration. At that age she will make friends quickly.
Hi. I am South Bristol too and have a child in Y8 so have been through the secondary application process.
We did consider Chew Valley school, but rejected this option because there was no school transport to our area. I understand that there is a bus service from Whitchurch though. St Katherines does have a bus service from South Bristol.
You need to check the admissions criteria for Colston Girls for your postcode but I understand that they do take girls from all Bristol postcodes but postcodes nearer the school have a higher priority. For the Cathedral school all Bristol postcodes are treated the same. If your child is awarded one of the specialist places (languages for CGS, Music for Cathedral) this is not dependent on postcode.
The other lottery school that does take some pupils from South Bristol is John Cabot in Kingswood and they do also have a bus service. You need to be within a certain distance from the school to qualify though.
It is only recommended that you apply to one lottery school though.
Schools in South Bristol are improving and they do have rigorous setting or streaming policies so it is worth a look round one of them nearer the time as a 3rd preference.
The faith requirements for Redcliffe do not apply to the sixth form so your child may be able to change schools.
Hope this helps. Please pm me if you would like any further info.
Thank you all so much. It's so great to find a wealth of experience on here. It's really helpful when I'm in worry-fest (which I often am about this!).
Crazymum, thank you so much for that. You are so much more clued up than me I may well pm you in a few weeks for info when I start to get my head around stuff. Nice to have a S.bristol mum who's ahead of me!
I believe there is a bus service to Chew from us. I'm in a nowhere land between the edge of Bishopsworth and Dundry.
I think I'm just going to quietly start going to all the open days I can and never mention it to anyone. The whole thing about the fantastic lottery schools (that people try and put you off applying to!) scholarships, catchments etc is so confusing.
Just noticing that crazymum says (within her excellent informative post) ... "It is only recommended that you apply to one lottery school though"
- well, that seems interesting to me. I think if it's possible why wouldn't you apply to them all (if you like them all) ?
You only have 3 choices in Bristol and the lottery schools are so oversubscribed for a first or only child that the chances of obtaining a place are quite low: about 10:1 for Bristol Cathedral school slightly better for CGS.
You could risk applying for 2 lottery schools, but if you want avoid your catchment school you need a 3rd preference where you stand a much higher chance of being awarded a place.
1. Bristol Cathedral
3. Catchment or other better school you are likely to get offered a place at.
How's that ? And I don't even live there - though I did once (and in Southville at one point)
Also maybe there's time to learn a language for a specialist place at CGS ?
My ds started this year (last Sept) in year 7 at an independent school where he knew no-one at all (though vaguely knew one family with older children).
He has social issues anyway, having Asperger's, but we were sure we were making the right decision on choosing the best school for his needs and not fretting too much about friendships from primary (it helped that his two 'best' primary friends were a) a year younger than him so not moving up anyway and b) a girl, who I assumed would drift away from him at secondary).
He has settled in brilliantly.
OK, the school is renowned for its pastoral care and we have weekly emails from the SENCO and can contact her with social concerns if necessary. It also helped that one of the nicest and most friendly boys in his year had a birthday in early October and wanted to include ds - so he quickly became part of this boy's 'group' who came up together from prep.
It also helped that there's a weekend away for all the year 7s about four weeks in at a PGL type centre so all the children can get to know one another.
At the school where I work we have a sleepover for the new year 7s about two weeks in where they sleep in their form rooms and do activities til late on, etc.
Most schools do excellent settling in programmes now and, as others have said, many children are not friends with the same people they came up from primary with by Christmas anyway.
Choose the best school for her over current friendships anytime.
Thanks Books. Really good to hear. I will heed your advice
Juggling and Crazymum - as I'm on the border of N.somerset is it possible to apply to both Education Authorities? I.e apply
Bristol - 3 choices
BANES - 3 choices.
Or is that just greedy?
Harry It's incorrect not greedy. You apply on the Bristol form and then they pass on the information to the other neighbouring LEAs so no you don't get more than 3 preferences.
PS Cathedral and CGS are Bristol LEA
Chew Valley is BANES
St Katherines is North Somerset
So that's potentially 3 different LEAs.
John Cabot is South Gloucestershire!
It is possible that the Cathedral school may be expanding their intake over the next few years so your chances could improve if this happens.
I was the only one from my primary. It was a bit scary the first day, but fine ever after.
Ah pants. I thought that was too good to be true.
Do the other schools discriminate against you if you put a lottery school first? I.e Would Chew not accept us as we didn't put as first choice?
All preferences are equal and the schools do not know what order you are placed on the LEA form, so no you wouldn't be discriminated against in this way.
Other LEAs have to apply the admissions criteria e.g. distance to all applicants equally too so they don't offer places to people who live in their LEA first either.
You can find out from the schools how many pupils they take from Bristol each year and the distance to weigh up your chances of obtaining a place.
Most schools provide very good information about how they manage the Y6/7 transition too and this is a good question to ask at Open evenings.
Thanks Crazymum (and everyone else). You've been really helpful and I've learned a few things.
I'm sure I will return with more in the future
Join the discussion
Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.Register now
Already registered with Mumsnet? Log in to leave your comment or alternatively, sign in with Facebook or Google.
Please login first.