ZOMBIE THREAD ALERT: This thread hasn't been posted on for a while.
Legal Advice Required re School Admissions(16 Posts)
Wondering if anyone can advise regarding our legal position in a school admissions screw up. Basically, we live within the boundaries of one LEA (let's call it authority A) but our catchment school falls within another LEA (authority B). Story is this:
I completed an online application for DS2 at middle school last November to authority A, as per regulations, 2 months before closing date for applications. Received email from them stating they had received it and I would be notified by 16 April.
Authority A are then obliged to forward the application to Authority B who process it and award places. They inform Authority A of decision who then notify me.
Having not heard anything I chased it up today. Apparently due to a "System Error" at Authority A the application was never sent. The error has now been detected and I am one of 3 parents whose applications were finally sent to Authority B last week!
Authority B will only process the application as a Late Application - despite the error being on the part of Authority A.
Just wondering if anyone can advise where we stand legally if we should fail to be awarded a place at the school? Surely it isn't good enough for Authority A to just shrug their shoulders and say "sorry, it's now a late application" when it clearly wasn't.
It's definitely not good enough. If you're not awarded that place you may have ground to apply for judicial review of the decision. I'm sure that to do that you have to demonstrate the process/procedure wasn't not carried out properly and that this directly led to the detriment.
I'm a solicitor but haven't practiced for some time, and since it's 12 yrs since I did my one and only (successful!) judicial review, you need someone to give you firm advice on this.
Thanks PermaShattered. I am really upset by their incompetence. In fact, Authority A didn't contact me to advise me of the situation - I only found out because other parents at school had all received notification letters and we hadn't.
I have just emailed Authority B explaining the situation and asking for them to take into consideration the failings of Authority A before going ahead and processing our application as "late".
Would it be worth contacting a solicitor? I'm being a bit thick but is there a specialist area of law for this?
Oh and Authority A emailed me (after I requested it) to say that
"...xxxx application was not processed on-time was due to a system error with this authority".
is that proof enough?
It's public law. You'd need an expert solicitor with successful experience in judicial review applications. They are usually a straightforward and not too lengthy process. Keep records as much as you can of all correspondence/emails and telephone calls (taking names when you can).
Then if you don't get the place you want you can take legal advice. Feel free to ask me for specific recommendation of a solicitor.
Thanks for the advice. Much appreciated. Is there any point in contacting someone now? I think it is despicable that I had to chase this and Authority A clearly had no intention of informing me of the situation. The women I spoke with was distinctly cagey about exactly when they had finally sent the application through too.
"2.3 Regardless of which schools parents express preferences for, the CAF is required to be returned to the local authority in the area that they live (the home authority). The home authority must then pass information on applications to other local (maintaining) authorities about applications to schools in their area. The maintaining authority must determine the application and inform the home local authority if a place is available. The offer to parents must be made by the home local authority." Schools Admissions Code 2012
I would think that the error lies entirely with Authority A. Authority B has made no error.
I'll have a google in a bit...
I don't think there's any need for lawyers or judicial reviews!!!
It's fairly straightforward and I'm sure the MN admission gurus will be along soon, but an error being made is one of the clear cut circumstances where you should be awarded a place (assuming you'd have got one if the error hadn't occured). You may have to appeal, though technically you shouldn't, but an appeal panel should rectify the situation in any case.
And yes your email is proof enough!
You should not need a judicial review and yes you should act now.
This is covered by the Admissions Code 2012. If you would have been allocated the school in area B had it not been for this error, you write formally to your home LA (area A) to request a place in school B, give them a one week deadline to reply and they should offer the place immediately.
Under 2.15 of the code, children can be admitted to an Infant Class even if it is already full as there is provision for "children admitted, after initial allocation of places, because of a procedural error made by the admission authority or local authority in the original application process" to take the class in breach of class size regulations
If they won't, it will force the issue to go to appeal. You take all the evidence with you (written proof that an systems error cost you a school place) and then you win at appeal.
The only complication is if you haven't directly lost a place due to this error. If you were too far away / did not qualify for school B anyway (even if area A had forwarded your application as they were supposed to) then this error has not directly cost you to lose that school place. Even then though an appeal would be worthwhile because of lack of faith in the way admissions have been handled and potential knock on disadvantages to not have been included in the on-time applications for all schools.
I think this is middle school isn't it - so not even class size prejudice!
Wow - I love MN
tiggytape - we would definitely have got a place. I called the school today to discuss and was advised that there was absolutely no barrier to our having a place other than this ridiculous cock-up.
The code you quote - does that cover transfer to middle school? DS is currently at lower school in Y4 and should be starting Y5 in September.
Can you look at both the home LA and the Maintaining LA admisssions criteria/statements? For example, Haringay say:
"24.Where Haringey LA has not received an outcome for a school within another maintaining LA which is a higher preference than the school offered, Haringey, as Home LA, will case manage that application until an outcome can be sent in respect of each higher preference school named on Haringeys School Admission Application Form."
That'll teach me for leaving the window open when I go out
Yes the Admissions Code applies to all admissions including transfers to middle school. No need for solicitors or recourse to the law. This is a very straightforward case. In theory they should admit you without any need for an appeal. In practise they will probably insist on an appeal.
Your case is that your LA failed to comply with the Admissions Code by failing to pass on your application contrary to paragraph 2.3 of the Code and that your child would have gained a place but for that omission. The fact that the mistake was by your LA rather than the school's LA is irrelevant. The panel is required to consider whether the admission arrangements were correctly applied. They do not have to consider who got it wrong.
Assuming you would have got a place (do get confirmation of that in writing), a correctly trained appeal panel should award your child a place unless there were a lot of children affected and the school could not cope with all of them. In the unlikely event that the appeal panel gets it wrong you can refer the matter to the Local Government Ombudsman who will definitely get it right.
Just logged back in and THAT TOLD ME You can tell i have no education admission procedure knowledge!
I didn't think about the appeals process dope me. OP - good luck and all that, and keep us posted!
Join the discussion
Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.Register now
Already registered with Mumsnet? Log in to leave your comment or alternatively, sign in with Facebook or Google.
Please login first.