This topic is for users to discuss eBay, not for advertising eBay items. If you are a small business you can advertise here

Broken toy

(20 Posts)
ToothlessAndPointless Fri 25-Dec-15 11:04:18

I bought a new in package WWE figure on Nov 2 for my son for Xmas. He opened it today, moved the leg (it is poseable) and it snapped off.

Contacted the seller who has told me I need to take this up with the manufacturer. Is this right? It was £20 if that matters. Thanks. There is no option on ebay to open a case. It was as described, it just broke immediately!

FeelingSmurfy Fri 25-Dec-15 11:17:10

If it was new in packet then I would say take it up with manufacturer, but just be aware that it could be a fake (in which case go back to eBay)

AnchorDownDeepBreath Fri 25-Dec-15 11:18:40

Was it a business seller on eBay, or a personal one?

Not that it makes much of a difference, in law your rights are with the seller, but it might be easier to go via the manufacturer if it's a private seller.

ToothlessAndPointless Fri 25-Dec-15 12:16:13

A personal seller. She seems to sell on genuine items at inflated prices and high postage which I was happy enough to pay as no one else had this particular wrestler in stock at the time.

I'll take it up with the manufacturer thanks.

19lottie82 Fri 25-Dec-15 13:39:03

Nonsense.no need to take it up with the manufacturer. They most likely won't take anything to do with it anyway, as you essentially bought it "second hand".

Open an item not as described case with eBay and return it for a refund. If the seller doesn't proviso de you with a pre paid returns label, call eBay and ask for one.

karalime Fri 25-Dec-15 13:49:22

No, she needs to take it up with the manufacturer as she is the seller.

When you sell things to people, you accept the risk that some of them may be a bit crap and break. Open return request but state the reason. If she does not comply you will get refunded automatically.

ToothlessAndPointless Fri 25-Dec-15 15:30:49

It doesn't give me an option in the resolution centre to open a case for that item though. Other purchases are showing but not that one.

19lottie82 Fri 25-Dec-15 16:57:37

You might have to wait until after the latest delivery estimate date until you can open a SNAD case? (That's a guess btw)

ToothlessAndPointless Fri 25-Dec-15 17:31:04

It's OK. I managed to open a case by going into the website instead of using the app. I'll see how it goes. I saw I paid £24.50 in total... a lot of money for one minutes "playing".

ToothlessAndPointless Fri 25-Dec-15 18:53:34

Right, her reply is that I return it to her at my cost and she sends it to the manufacturer to see if there is a fault or if force caused the leg to break. If I accept that course of action she says I would have to agree to stop the action for a refund until investigations are completed.
She's also reminded me of her no returns policy.

Advice anyone?

19lottie82 Fri 25-Dec-15 21:09:03

No returns policy is worthless. It only covers a change of mind. NOT faulty / misdescribed goods.

Her offer is also non sense.

Repeat that you wish to return the item at HER cost (ie she provides a pre paid label), for a full refund upon delivery. Then if she ignores / refuses, simply wait another 7 days and escalate the case (an option will appear after this time frame). eBay will adjudicate and force the seller to refund upon return. They should send you a pre paid returns label too, but if they don't, get in touch with them and request one.

DON'T get involved with any long winded arguments / string of messages with the seller. Simply send one final message reminding her of her obligations as a seller, and provide one final request.

Once you have your refund, leave appropriate feedback. Keep it factual and don't get emotional, to avoid any possibility of it being removed.

ToothlessAndPointless Fri 25-Dec-15 21:30:40

Thank you lottie

19lottie82 Fri 25-Dec-15 22:43:44

No problem T+P. Again, don't get drawn into fruitless arguments with the seller. If she doesn't play ball, simply escalate after the fixed time period provided by eBay. If you need any further advice, just post on the thread.

nauticant Sun 27-Dec-15 21:06:37

19lottie82 has this exactly right OP. Follow what she says and you should get shot of the item and your money back.

ToothlessAndPointless Mon 28-Dec-15 09:15:48

I'm just waiting to escalate it now. I sent the message as per lottie, seller stuck to her guns so I said I will escalate it when possible as we can't agree. Both very polite so it'll be in Ebays hands when the time comes.

summerwinterton Mon 28-Dec-15 12:03:38

btw if she is buying to sell on then she is a business and should be registered as such with eBay and HMRC.

ToothlessAndPointless Sun 03-Jan-16 12:40:39

Great. EBay won't refund as it's outside their 30 day money back guarantee policy. Been referred to PayPal.

Sigh.

19lottie82 Sun 03-Jan-16 12:49:04

Sorry OP I totally missed the part that you bought it at the beginning of November, I apologise. TBH I'm not sure you will get anywhere with PayPal either at this point in time either, as I think you're only allowed to make one claim (eBay or PayPal)

ToothlessAndPointless Sun 03-Jan-16 12:49:39

Ohhhhhhhh. Good result actually. PayPal refunded in full. grin

19lottie82 Sun 03-Jan-16 16:29:51

Glad to hear it!

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now