The Silver Sword

(15 Posts)
sittinginthesun Tue 11-Sep-12 18:27:34

I have vivid memories of this book - just wondered if it's still being read and, if so, what age it's aimed at?

Thanks.

SheelaNeGoldGig Tue 11-Sep-12 18:29:46

Iust have been about 10 or 11.

That grey kitten has always worried me.

jeee Tue 11-Sep-12 18:38:00

my kids loved it - but when I was reading it to them I struggled with the last couple of chapters because I found myself welling up.

DD1 and DS then read it at school in year 5.

CakeBump Tue 11-Sep-12 18:39:43

A fantastic book.

I would say its aimed at children reading at aged 10 to 11 too. The themes would be a little bit disturbing to a younger child I think.

sittinginthesun Tue 11-Sep-12 18:40:37

Thanks. DS is year 4, and a strong reader who loves history, but I'm just wondering if it'll be a bit much for him. It still makes me feel a bit teary just thinking about it, and it's been 20 years since I read it!

sassytheFIRST Tue 11-Sep-12 18:43:25

Fab book - no younger than 9 IMO tho because of the subject matter.

Grey kitten? What was that? Can't remember that detail...<wibble>

SecretSpi Tue 11-Sep-12 21:05:07

I read it to my son a couple of years ago when he was 10. He also read "The Boy in the Striped Pyjamas" around the same time and found "the Silver Sword" a far better book as it has more of a sense of a real story about it - he identified with the children in "The Silver Sword" whereas he found the boy Bruno in TBITSP rather dim!

DeWe Wed 12-Sep-12 18:23:08

Dh read it at about age 6-7. He said it was his first long chapter book and he was determined to read it. He found it a slog, but enjoyed it at the same time if that makes sense. But he has a lot of determination if he decides to do something.

derekthehamster Wed 12-Sep-12 18:24:44

My son enjoyed it. He would have been 10 or 11

StormGlass Sun 16-Sep-12 20:06:33

We did it in school in year 7.

ScatterChasse Sun 16-Sep-12 21:26:45

I read it when I was about 8 I think (just on my own). My DBro did it at school in Year 5, so 9-10 as part of a topic.

Ds (who is now 11) read it in year 4. As they did a project about WWII that year, it tied in quite well.

Colyngbourne Tue 18-Sep-12 00:36:30

It's usually read in Year 5 or 6 alongside studing WW2. I agree it is pretty much one of the best stories set in that period.

DisorderlyNights Thu 20-Sep-12 15:26:33

My DS read it in year 3, when he was studying the wars and had been asked to read a novel set then during Easter holidays. I had good memories of enjoying it and we read it together.

He isn't sensitive though, some children wouldn't cope with it at that age.

Hanorah Sat 29-Sep-12 22:12:47

I adored this book as a kid, and I read it to my DTSs a few months ago when they were 10 going on 11. They handled it fine at that age but I wouldn't have tried it much younger. I struggled to keep it together reading the last few pages !

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now