This topic is for discussing childcare options. If you want to advertise, please use your Local site.
ZOMBIE THREAD ALERT: This thread hasn't been posted on for a while.
Nanny abusing children - DESPERATELY NEED ADVICE(58 Posts)
My eldest 9 year old child has just revealed our nanny has been mistreating her - smacking on legs and face and threatening to get her in trouble if she reveals anything.
She went on to say she did the same thing with her baby sister (18 months) Perhaps even treating her worse - ignoring the baby when she falls and hurts herself, shouting at her, smacking her thigh. Apparently the nanny even threw a ball at the baby and when it hit her head which hurt her and made her cry the nanny just put the volume up on the TV so the crying didn't disturb her TV watching.
It seems the nanny behaves in a completely different way when I and my husband are not around.
As you can imagine, this news is most distressing. Made worse by the fact I could see the baby changed towards the nanny. Wouldn't want to go to her, would suddenly stand still staring away from her in her presence, clinging on to me if I would pass her to the nanny.
I dread to think what the nanny could have done to the baby when my eldest daughter isn't around.
Needless to say the nanny is gone - on our next meeting I will be firing her evil butt without pay.
My question is how can she be disciplined for such poor and potentially illegal actions?
Though she smacked my children, she did not leave any marks. We also have no proof, no video.... It will just be my daughters word against the nanny's.
As a Filipina, I also don't think she is registered with Ofsted nor has any records for CRB.
However - I am aware she has just been legally made a British citizen. I don't know if there is anything I can do about that.
Also I have details of a family she still babysits for - I don't know if it might be worth finding out how the nanny behaves with them and perhaps warning them about her.
Yes - I am angry, fuming even about this revelation. But more than that, I actually would like to protect other families and other children from going through this experience. There must be some way other parents can be warned and make sure she never works with children again.
I haven't let the nanny know I know yet - I want to handle this as delicately and wisely as possible. The baby is with grand father and I am always around when she is with my daughter - when she behaves well.
Pls forgive the length of this post. It has all been quite frightful really
Hmm, difficult. What a horrible situation. My first thoughts are to run it by the police and see what they think. It may not get anywhere, but it will be on record. I think that would be a good place to start.
Yes I think I would mention it to the other family as well.
Umm, you will have to be v careful to avoid slander.
If I were you I would enquire of CAB and also SS what the position is.
She should be CRBd. Anyone who works with children should be.
You had better also be clear about what reference you give, if any, as you don't want to either to be done for libel nor not provide due warnings to higher employers. Hence suggestion of CAB and SS.
why would you employ some one as a nanny without crb checks or being offsted registered? is that not just madness? also please make absolutely sure your 9 yr old is being wholly truthful before involving police etc. I wouldnt have employed someone to look after children who wasnt registered.
Thanks kindly for all your responses!
Anciientbuchanan - what is CAB and SS??
And yes - my husband and I have spoken to my daughter at length. Even if there is a possibility she might not be telling the truth, we wouldn't be any kind of parents to ignore. Also - some of the words she uses to describe what the nanny says to her aren't words from her every day vocabulary
Besides - my husband and I were growing suspicious of the baby's reaction to her. The baby was clearly scared to be with her
Citizens advice bureau and social services. Although I work for social services, and apart from checking to see if she is known on the system we would generally say to contact the police.
CAB is Citizen's Advice Bureau
SS is Social Services
I would definitely contact the other family.
Did the nanny come through an agency or was it a private arrangement?
I'd also say definitely contact the Police - how terrible for you all. Good luck.
Really surprised at you hiring someone whose background you haven't checked When is she due back to work?
I thought u might have meant Citizens Advice - but I wasn't aware they deal with this sort of thing
And yes - I was introduced through an agency who informed me those checks had been carried out
Have you spoken to the agency?
I would also speak to the agency that matched you too then, as they would rehire her to another family if you do not inform them of her behaviour.
If she was introduced through an agency they may be registered with ofsted, you could check on the website via the agency name.
I would ring the 101 police number to ask for advice.
Yes you need to talk to the agency as well then.
How did you manage to find out she wasn't CRB checked after all?
Which agency did you use?
How horrible! Really tricky situation if you have no physical proof.
Easy to say this in hindsight, but It's always essential to document everything if you had niggling doubts. You say the baby was scared of her? This should have rung big alarm bells. Babies don't react that way for no good reason. All good nannies should be able to account for their day/actions through documentation too. This at least would give you firm times and dates for where/when she was with your children and what she was doing and also how your children were disciplined/ played/ate/slept/behaved, which can also be very telling.
I would contact the police or social services and take their advice.
Contact your agency and request they investigate her.
How old was your nanny? Nothing excuses the abuse of children, but it's never wise to leave children with someone young and inexperienced who can't cope with the heavy demands of childcare.
This was one of the reasons I didn't return to work and stayed home after my son was born. Just can't trust anyone.
Confront her, ask her straight out if she smacked your 9 year olds legs. She may admit it and if so dismissal will be a lot easier. If they deny it, then it will be trickier but you can dismiss them with notice and insist they do not work that notice - but means you would still pay the notice period.
I would seek advice from social services - there should be a central number, sometimes called a contact centre, run by your local authority/county council. They may not be able to do anything but they may log it.
Certainly let the agency know. However unless your nanny admits it, then there is no evidence, just a suspicion.
Your 9 year old is probably telling the truth, you know when they are and when they are making something up. So the nanny needs to leave immediately, though you must follow the correct procedure. ACAS.org.uk can advise on employment law, dismissal procedures. They may also be able to tell you about what you can and can not say in a reference.
Good luck, not a nice situation. What will you do about childcare, as presumably you still need a nanny?
What an awful situation. As you are sacking her for harming a child you must report to the DBS
You should also tell the agency she came through and ask them for confirmation of all the checks. Do be aware that it is your responsibility as an employer, not theirs as a placement service, to ensure an employee's suitability, but if they explicitly stated everything was in order and didn't do a DBS check they lied. In that case check to see whether they are a member of the ANA or the REC and complain to them (and I'd be inclined to go public with it too).
CAB, and your employers liability insurance to see whether you have legal advice with them, to get information about dismissing her properly.
Do NOT let her back near your children. It will weaken your case irreparably.
Contact the police to investigate bringing charges so this goes properly on record.
Just because she's Filipina doesn't mean she's not registered with OFSTED. It's worth calling them to check and if she is than lodge your concerns with them too.
When did she start working for you and is she your employee or through an agency?
Police and report as a Safeguarding matter to your Local Children's Safeguarding Board whose number will be under the Children and Families section of your Local Authority's website.
How horrible for you all. You know your child, and are in the best position to judge the truth in what she's saying. I would not mention anything to the nanny for the time being. If she's due to work soon, I'd make some excuse as to why you don't need her for a couple of days (grandparents visiting, your ill, going away etc) I'd then use those days to contain all of the agencies/police to get as much advice as possible. Literally ring everyone and get informed about the best course of action. I would worry that having her back to work as usual would harm your case.
One word of warning; I would take what your child is saying with a pinch of salt. A 9 year old may be clever enough to know that saying these things will result in getting the nanny to leave; just a thought. Not suggesting your child is making this up, but I'd have the thought in the back of your mind. Like I said you know your child; I'd know if my child was telling the truth! So follow your gut instinct. If you believe this had happened I'd do everything in my power to endure the nanny never worked with children again.
I saw a programme on tv about something similar, and family set up secret camera to catch nanny. Left children and sure enough she started the abusive behaviour. This provided proof and nanny was prosecuted. Obviously not sure I'd recommend
this as it means leaving your child to be abused!!! But the nanny got caught and it saved other children going through the same. Bit controversial, but thought id mention it. Don't think I could do it, but others may think this at least gives you justice. Cause sadly, without proof, this nanny is likely to move on very easily and continue in childcare.
I really feel for you and your children, and want to wish you the very best of luck in whatever course of action you take. Xx
Don't set up a hidden camera!!! It might seem very tempting and give you proof but it will ruin any case because there are laws against filming people without notifying them about it first - hence all the signs about CCTV you see. Get advice from the police about what you can do.
Join the discussion
Please login first.