This topic is for discussing car seats. If you want to buy and sell car seats, please use our For Sale/Wanted boards.

Buying a car seat based on weight?

(19 Posts)
Myszko Sun 27-Mar-16 14:01:41

Hi,

I've narrowed down my choice of car seats to 2. One is 2.5kg and the other is 5kg. Will the weight of the car seat make a huge difference? I do prefer the 5kg one as it has extra useful features (i.e. in-car lie-flat) but because it's heavier it is putting me off slightly.

I'm pregnant for the first time that's why I am clueless...

TIA

smile

cranberryx Sun 27-Mar-16 16:00:11

For me, weight was a factor but so was pushchair compatibility. weight doesn't matter so much IMO if you can attach it to a pushchair and push it.

Have you looked at the safety ratings? That would be my deciding factor in such a close decision.

Nicesunnytuesday Sun 27-Mar-16 20:36:41

I ended up carrying baby car seat about quite a lot, and they're really bloody awkward to carry so feel a lot heavier than they are.

I also made my decision based on travel system compatibility and safety. 5kg sounds a heck of a lot. Dunno what mine weighed though.

KP86 Sun 27-Mar-16 20:48:14

In car lie flat?! Which one is that? Sounds fascinating

Nightfall1983 Sun 27-Mar-16 21:00:30

I have a lie-flat car seat and it's very heavy so I never take it out of the car. However it is FANTASTIC and my babies have been very safe and comfy in it with none of the usual car seat worries on long journeys (we travel a lot). I've never, literally never, wished I could take it out of the car so it's really not an issue imo.

shutthebackdoor Sun 27-Mar-16 21:11:47

Get the lighter one! Providing the safety aspects are all the same/similar. My car seat is so heavy, I've had hip problems since giving birth and carrying it hasn't helped at all. When the baby gets bigger will be harder and harder to carry.

Artandco Sun 27-Mar-16 21:16:43

Get heavier one with lie flat feature and keep in the car.
Lie flat for any journeys over 30 mins really is keep for newborns as they can easily lose oxygen desaturation due to neck position in regular shaped car seats. Leave in the car

The kiddy evo lunafix is one of the only ones that fit in one car seat space, get high safety ratings and can be laid flat whilst driving. I would recommend looking at if you were considering another

Artandco Sun 27-Mar-16 21:17:37

Oh and babies really shouldn't be left more than 20-30 mins in a regular car seat. So if not driving is safer to lift them out and put in a sling or lie flat pram

unimaginativename13 Sun 27-Mar-16 21:19:03

Get the light one. It's my biggest regret. I couldn't even carry DS in his from about 3 months!

poocatcherchampion Sun 27-Mar-16 21:20:35

Carrying babies in car seats is bonkers. The shape is terrible for it.

I'd only go on the basis of safety

poocatcherchampion Sun 27-Mar-16 21:21:33

Pressed too soon.

I think the lie flat ones get poor safety reviews. Although I am willing to be corrected.

Artandco Sun 27-Mar-16 21:25:08

Poo - they are the old style ones that laid flat across two back seats. The newer style ones rate highly on which tests.

New ones are like this
www.johnlewis.com/kiddy-evo-lunafix-group-0-baby-car-seat-and-base-stone/p1797248?sku=234144336&kpid=234144336&s_kenid=048f3b28-4d6c-4464-b81a-2186c7582173&s_kwcid=403x1395937&tmad=c&tmcampid=73

BikeRunSki Sun 27-Mar-16 21:27:51

If you have lots of long car journeys to do, get the lie flat. My mum lives 250 miles away. Lie flat car seats didn't exist when my babies were babies, and stopping every 1.5 to 2 hours for a wriggle added a long time to the journey.

Onsera3 Sun 27-Mar-16 21:28:37

As I understand it the Stokke lie flat car seat is only to be used flat OUTSIDE the car. (This is what it says on their website description) You can't use it like that when driving along can you?

poocatcherchampion Sun 27-Mar-16 21:29:08

Ooh that looks lovely! Thanks art

Artandco Sun 27-Mar-16 21:29:28

Onsera- the Stokke and Cybex ones can only lie flat outside of the car

Onsera3 Sun 27-Mar-16 21:31:48

Ooh that Kiddy one does look good. I always worry when they are bent up in seats when they are so little. Glad there are more options now.

tryingtocatchthewind Sun 27-Mar-16 21:38:47

I had a "Jane Matix light" which was bloody awesome but it weighed a tonne. There's no way you could carry it round even with only a newborn in. But you easily get it onto the pram and just about managed to get it from the car to the house. I had a standard car seat with my second child and it was much lighter but I still didn't really carry a baby in it. They could be as light as a feather but they are still an awful shape to carry

Myszko Sun 27-Mar-16 23:09:22

All,

I'm looking at getting the brand new kiddy evo. It is lie flat in-car. We regularly drive over 800 miles so stopping every 2 hours isn't an option!

This new car seat is only 5kg, so looks like it wins.

Thanks for all your comments, much appreciated.

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now