Does ebf baby need water in this heat?

(20 Posts)
Iheartcustardcreams Sat 13-Jul-13 10:30:09

Basically, as the title says. Dm keeps telling me 9 week old son needs cooled boiled water in this heat. I don't think he does but am giving extra feeds as he demands. Thought I would just double check! Thanks

KateBeckett Sat 13-Jul-13 10:31:59

From what I've read on here I don't think bf babes need water as well.

I'm sure someone who knows for sure will be along soon!

Absolutely not, unless you want him to have diarrhoea, thereby losing more fluids.

BM contains electrolytes to help fluid absorption. Cooled boiled water can't come close to its rehydrating properties. Keep up with the boob! smile

FattyMcChubster Sat 13-Jul-13 10:33:53

No, just offer boob more often

MultipleMama Sat 13-Jul-13 10:34:47

My sons are 9mo and have never had water. Not in this warm weather either. I just make sure they're cool.

I breastfeed on demand so just feed them extra while we're out.

Janek Sat 13-Jul-13 10:35:56

You are doing it right already. Feed him more if he wants it, offer more often to be sure. No need for extra water.

I don't think ff babies need water either, but i'm not so sure of this fact!

TantrumsandBananas Sat 13-Jul-13 10:38:40

Agree completely with Elphaba

My MIL (and the rest of husbands family) went on and on about this, also trying to convince me DD needed the bottle. Convinced she was dying of thirst.

I stuck to my boobs guns, got fed of trying to explain the science.

Iheartcustardcreams Sat 13-Jul-13 10:52:44

Thank u. Will keep doing what I am. I will try and explain it to dm and then ignore her when she still keeps going on!

I have a vague recollection that the 0-5 Book which should have been given to you by your HV makes specific mention of not giving cooled boiled water to an under-6 month old. Find that and wave it under MIL's nose. And it is correct that FF babies don't need it either.

AidanTheRevengeNinja Sat 13-Jul-13 17:48:17

No, though likely more boob.

My parents' generation have a bizarre obsession with giving cooled boiled water to babies, I have noticed. It must have been The Thing back in the day grin

sleepyhead Sat 13-Jul-13 17:58:33

No, but like Aidan says the previous generation appear to have had it hammered into them that babies must have "cooled boiled water". The phrase seems to be trotted out for all occasions:

Newborn slightly jaundiced? Cooled boiled water is just the thing.
Feeding too frequently? Try some cooled boiled water instead.
Not pooed recently? Cooled boiled water!
Feeding too often through the night? See if the baby will take some cooled boiled water instead.
Hot day? You get the picture.

What a bloody faff, potentially disruptive of bf, not great for the baby etc.

Helspopje Tue 16-Jul-13 11:09:35

i undestand that these are the current rules re cooled boiled water, but it is soooo hot.

I ebf my 10 week old on demand as often as he likes and look for all signs that he wants to feed. Despite this, he has a sunken fontanelle. Still alert, sleeping as usual, wet and dirty nappies, but I'm worried ++.

I am now going to offer even when he doesnt look hungry too, but are we sure that there is never a casefor water for a BF baby when it is >30 degrees. What do they advise in other hot countries?

Janek Tue 16-Jul-13 12:26:48

I don't wish to alarm you, but are you sure his fontanelle is sunken? I've been led to believe that this is very serious ie major dehydration not just 'oh, he might need a drink'.

I think the consistency of your milk changes when it's hot so it's less filling and more like a 'drink', rather than 'food', hence no need to give water.

Helspopje Tue 16-Jul-13 12:29:47

am sure - am a consultant in a diff specialty.
will take him in I think as this is to much to sit and watch

Murtette Tue 16-Jul-13 12:30:37

I agree that a sunken fontanelle should get checked out asap.

As for your situation, OP, just bm should be sufficient but it will involve you feeding a lot and it will mean that your DS will have lots of little snacky feeds as well as some longer, proper feeds (or at least that's what DS did in the one very hot week last summer when he was 1w old and then on the holiday we went on at 8w and the next at 12w). Do make sure that you're drinking and eating plenty yourself so that you can keep up with his demands.

I'm from Australia - advice there is exactly the same with regards to not giving CBW.

Fontanelles will often look a bit sunken in perfectly healthy babies (DS's certainly did) but never any harm in getting it checked out if you're worried.

CrackersandCheese Tue 16-Jul-13 13:07:00

Just to add that yes, the composition of your milk will change with the heat and become more thirst quenching. Your body is so clever like that and I wish people trusted it more wink

iamfizzy Tue 16-Jul-13 23:09:07

I had this problem with 'the older generation' banging on about giving baby water. Someone on here suggested I show them some expressed milk that had seperated to shown them how watery breast milk actually is. I did. They don't mention it now. If you can express, leave a small amount in the fridge for a day and shown them!

CluelessNewbie1 Tue 16-Jul-13 23:53:19

My health visitor advised me yesterday to give my 6 week old cold boiled water if she appeared thirsty. I have ignored her advice as every other healthcare professional I have come across during pregnancy advised that you shouldn't give ebf babies anything other than breast milk.

Caterpillar0 Wed 17-Jul-13 06:02:56

I lived in the tropics for first year of my first born's life and gave him cooled water in the afternoons once he was on formula and, to a lesser extent before that, when bf. The baby books aren't written for babies in those climates and I never found it affected his appetite or weight or made him in the slightest bit dehydrated. He would gulp it down sometimes, other times not. I'm not saying its advisable, just that the current literature seems OTT in its fear of cooled water. It's a question of moderation surely.

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now