Boots Feel Good Forum: body confidence – Matt Roberts and Vicky Pennington answer MNers' Qs - please read!(13 Posts)
Shapers meals - shit food - seriously, is the nutritionalist suggesting ready meals for healthy eating?!!! , men do lose weight quicker....starvation mode is a myth - until you are actually starving - can the expert give us some proof of it's existence rather than trailing out a load of cliches. What a load of crap this expert seem to peddle.
Ok I probably shouldn't comment on this but I found this sentence really strange: "Womens bodys have a naturally higher proportion of fat as they are programmed to carry a child, while men are built to be hunter gatherers and even though our roles today have changed, our genes havent."
Yes women have more body fat so we have some in reserve if we get pregnant.
1- Women in the past gathered, and sometimes hunted, AND gave birth. Just not at the same time.
2 - Women of today carry babies too.
Is it true true that women, rather than men, find it more difficult to lose fat?
Frustratingly not! People put on weight when their calorie intake gets out of synch with their calorie output.its a balancing act and iIf you're taking in more calories than your body needs, you gain weight because the body is designed to store excess calories as fat.
When it comes to exercise the more lean tissue - or muscle - you have in your body, the more calories you will burn and men do have a higher amount of lean tissue in their bodies. Added to that differences in hormones, body shape and fat percentage can all make it harder for women to lose weight if compared to men. Womens bodys have a naturally higher proportion of fat as they are programmed to carry a child, while men are built to be hunter gatherers and even though our roles today have changed, our genes havent. Ultimately however, it is up to individual willpower both women and men can lose fat if they commit to a healthy diet and exercise regime.
There is so much conflicting advice out there about the best way to lose weight. I've been advised by a fitness instructor at my local gym that seriously low-carbing is the way to go but then I've read a lot online saying it can be dangerous to have a seriously high protein diet (which this effectively is). What's your advice?
Again, like Carovioletfizz, the key here is moderation. A healthy diet is made up of a mixture of all food groups, including carbohydrate and protein. Carbohydrates are an essential source of energy and are important to maintaining blood sugar levels. Even fats and sugars are essential for general body function and play an important role in keeping us going. It is not healthy to remove one of these food groups from your diet, and you will undoubtedly start to crave whatever it is that you cut out. However, it is important to make sure that you moderate your intake of each food group - using GDAs is a good way to help you manage this and to make sure that you do not consume more or less of one food group than is recommended as healthy.
Carbohydrates - or carbs - are the body's preferred energy source. They are readily broken down into glucose - the sugar in our blood. After carbohydrates, the body will draw its energy from fat. After that, it will draw on protein from our muscles. So it's important to make sure there are enough carbohydrates and some fat in your diet to protect that muscle.
And your weight loss efforts will go even further if you make a few changes to your usual routine. Look at your current eating habits - do you snack, do you eat 'ready-made' food on the go, do you feel you're always 'on a diet'? If so, shake up your regime with these proactive measures:
~ Empty your cupboards of sugary snacks and re-stock them with unsalted nuts, seeds and dried/fresh fruits so when you are feeling peckish you have something healthy to snack on
~ If you're short on time and usually opt for a 'ready meal' during the week, check the labels and choose one that is lower in saturated fat, salt and calories using the traffic light colours to guide you. You could try the new Shapers evening meals can choose a great-tasting main meal and accompaniment or dessert for 500 calories or less. . And with Shapers you'll have the added benefit of knowing that the levels of saturated fat, salt and sugars have been carefully controlled. Plus Shapers do not contain hydrogenated fats, artificial flavours or artificial colours.
~ Prepare healthy home-cooked food at the weekend and freeze it so it's easy to re-heat after work.
Just as important as this physical preparation is mental preparation - set yourself a realistic goal. Rather than pledging to 'lose weight', set yourself a target and a deadline based on what your BMI should be for your height and weight. When you know your numbers, why not stick your target on your fridge to help keep you on track and then tell your friends and colleagues about your goal so they can support you along the way.
A question about dieting: Do you agree that if you eat too few calories your body goes into 'starvation mode' and you stop losing weight? Does this happen to most/all people?
Guideline Daily Amounts (or GDAs) are set at 2,000 calories for women and 2,500 calories for men. (GDAs are a guide to how many calories and nutrients people can consume each day for a healthy balanced diet). Our bodies need a certain amount of calories to maintain daily function, and therefore it is not recommended to severely restrict your intake.
Crash dieting can slow your metabolic rate, as your body goes into starvation mode when it is deprived of food or fuel. Your body will fight to conserve what little energy it has and may even draw its energy from the lean tissue that burns fat. Which, if maintained for a long period time, could also lead to long-terms health conditions. One way to manage your diet if youre not sure about the amount of calories youre taking in is to try a weight management aid. These can help you quickly feel full keeping hunger at bay, cut out the snacks and help prevent yo-yo dieting. It is an effective way to achieving a healthier lifestyle without the need to constantly diet or the inconvenience of restrictive diets.
I have always maintained, after seeing friends on diets who think they can eat whatever they want as long as they spend an hour at the gym, that actually unless you are working out like an Olympic athlete every day you need to reduce the amount of food you eat to lose weight. Am I right?
The key to success is ‘everything in moderation’ – the combination of healthy eating and regular exercise is the best way to maintain a healthy weight. If you increase the amount of energy (calories) you consume then you will need to increase your energy expenditure to maintain this balance, and even more so if you want to lose weight. If you moderate what you eat and maintain an active routine, you will find it easier to manage your weight.
The best way to lose weight is a two-pronged attack:
1) Reduce your calorie intake
2) Increase the calories you burn by being as active as you can be in your day-to-day life
You can lose weight just by cutting calories but you won't lose weight as quickly if you don't combine it with activity. You need a deficit of 500 calories a day to lose one pound of weight a week which can be very difficult to sustain. If you exercise regularly, it helps you burn more calories and keep your weight in check. So think about how you can increase your activity – it doesn’t have to be running marathons, simple steps like parking further away from the office or using the stairs can all be a good place to start!
As well as keeping active, keeping a food diary can really help. With an online food diary-based approach, such as bootsdiets.com, you simply record everything that you and drink each day. You'll soon see where the excess calories and fat are coming from and will be able to use 'the healthy food swap' tool to make changes.
When there is a birth of a new child, Dad's also end up with less sleep and eating less healthily with less time to exercise. Any tips for Dad's wanting to shed a few pounds?
Spend just 20 minutes, every other day doing interval training, using a routine of 1 minute high intensity and 1 minute low. For example, walk and run, or hill run and walk down recovery. Follow this up by spending 10 minutes doing a simple routine that goes Arms, Legs, Abs, repeated 4-5 times. Half an hour workout, works the key parts of the body, strengthens the heart and burns the fat!
Having suffered from arthritis since I was a child, I am very limited in what I can do in the way of excercise so it makes it extra tricky to stay fit and lose weight. Are there any ideas / tips you can give for someone with limited mobility to stay healthy?
I would suggest non-weight bearing exercise such as swimming would possibly help you. It has less strain to your joints and works in a very big range of motion that will help your mobility and strengthen the muscles around each joint.
Having lost nearly 6 stone I am finding it a struggle to shift the final few pounds. What should I do?
Change your programme. Are you genuinely overloading? Make sure in every workout you reach 5-6 moments where you can't carry on any more without resting. The peaks raise metabolism and will help you shift the last bit of weight.
I've got back to my pre-pregnancy weight through eating a healthy diet and breastfeeding. However, my tummy is still a little rounder than it was before I had a baby. As I hope to have another child is it really worthwhile doing lots of exercise to flatten it when another pregnancy will undo all of the work?
If so, what would be the best exercises to do please?
It is definitely worth it. You need to get your abs and body back in full condition to be ready for it to withstand, and come out on the other side, in as good shape as you can possibly be, YES!
How do you find a sport/exercise you enjoy?
It's really a matter of trial and error. Make a list of the four or five things you might like to try and give them a go. Go into them with an open mind, but also try to think of a goal that you might want to achieve with it. The motivation comes from the goal and the enjoyment comes from reaching it.
The latest Boots Feel Good Forum is about body confidence, exercise and diet, featuring experts personal trainer Matt Roberts, Psychologist Dr Linda Papadopoulos and Nutritionist Vicky Pennington.
MNers have been posting their Qs for the experts here - some of them were answered on the show (listen to the best bits here) and some have been answered on this thread by Matt and Vicky - see below.
Please listen to the podcast and read the answers below then let us know what you think of the advice given on this thread.
You can find more info about the show here. Coming up next - looking after your skin and fighting the signs of ageing. Post your question for the experts here.
Please note that your comments may be used by the Feel Good Forum in advertising but your MN nickname won't appear.
The views/content expressed within this forum are those of the participants and not those of Boots UK Limited or its agents
Join the discussion
Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.Register now
Already registered with Mumsnet? Log in to leave your comment or alternatively, sign in with Facebook or Google.
Please login first.