My feed
Premium

Please
or
to access all these features

Talk to others about child development and behaviour stages here. You can find more information on our development calendar.

Behaviour/development

Are security 'blankets' bad for little one?

35 replies

mumofwun · 14/06/2006 23:06

Sorry to ask a really stupid question but my ds1 is 15 months old and has a wooden spoon for a 'security blanket'. He looks for it as soon as he wakes up, carries it everywhere even in the bath, and I can only take it from him once he falls asleep.
I have to admit it looks kind of cute when he toddles around town with this spoon in hand and he gets lots of 'aws' from passersby.
Only problem is that he will not use his left hand for anything. If he is pulling his chair or toy box he will do it with the right hand only even if it means that he falls over. And of course whenever he falls over his scrapes his knucles on the left hand as it is always tightly gripping the spoon.
I wouldnt mind if he swapped hands occasionally but am worried that this may be interfering with his development (he was showing a preference for using his left hand before he discovered the spoon). Am I just being silly? And what does it say about me, that my son needs a spoon to comfort himself (mad woman!)?

OP posts:
Report
KommandantColditz · 14/06/2006 23:19

Aw!

Oh, let him. You can reason him out of it when he is older. Give him things to do that require two hands - noisy thinks that bang together.

PS Take lots of photos.

Report
squarer · 14/06/2006 23:20

Barking, absolutely barking.
No other mum on this forum has worried about anything. Ever.
Hope you are feeling suitably chastised/silly now
Wink Grin
PS under no circumstances did my 18 month old throw himself (completely uncontrolled) out of the bath tonight in an effort to get to his comforter. Oh no sirreee. Not mine.
PPS as the most inexperienced mum ever, I tend to ask myself in such circumstances "in all honesty, what are my realistic options right now". I find it gives me the best answer in all circumtances.
Smile

Report
mrsbluesky · 15/06/2006 11:13

I think it's lovely when children have a treasured object they cart around all the time. No harm at all. Let him have his spoony friend - he'll work out in the end that sometimes he needs to put it down to do something with both hands. My littlest got attached to a wooden spoon as well, didn't last that long. right now his love object is a green bead in the shape of a dog. He also got attached to his swimming trunks and would wear them endlessly (had to wash them on the sly overnight) and found them under the sofa once with a cry of "Trunks I love you!"

Report
Carmenere · 15/06/2006 11:17

I had the silk bit of my blanky until it fell to bits about 4 years ago, I loved it and miss itSad And if I ever find a blanket with the right consistancy and texture again I'll buy it immediately. I don't think there is any harm in comforters at all.

Report
EmmyLou · 15/06/2006 11:33

I still have my snuggly.

DD1 used to bring me a particular nightie of mine all the time when she was about 9 months, so i cut it up for her and it became her snuggly. She has tiny fragments still age (nearly) 11.

DD2 used the muslin squares and still has her favoutite shreds stuffed up the rear of a hedgehog glove puppet.

DD3 has 2 fleece blankets for her snugglies and takes them out most of the time, but is not so insistent any more except at bedtime or in a new situation.

Long live your DS's wooden spoon Grin
I agree with Colditz - get lots of photos and things to do that need 2 hands.

Do you think its a sustitute for holding your finger?

Report
wannaBe1974 · 15/06/2006 12:34

(I should be changing my name for this), when I was little my best friend was ... ... a sink plunger! (there, confession over), I didn't take it to bed with me though but I did apparently keep it with me constantly during the day, along with my favourite stuffed rabbit, but the plunger apparently even had a name and represented my imaginary friend. And imo I didn't have any development problems and think I am a well balanced individual.

My DS has a bear, who although doesn't go everywhere now, does come out if tired/upset and ddoes sleep with him every night. and oh the catastrophe when he was sick on him and I couldn't wash him. MN came to my rescue that day ... :)

Report
FlameBoo · 15/06/2006 12:39

I didn't think I did have a security blanket... until I took the falling apart pink blanket with me when I left home Grin
I have actually manage to put it away in a cupboard now, but I can't throw it out.

DD doesn't have anything, but DS is only 15 weeks and has already adopted a blanket.

Nothjing wrong with them in the slightest

Report
FrannyandZooey · 15/06/2006 12:42

I am very taken with the idea of a wooden spoon comforter. In fact I am quite jealous.

If I was you I would make great play of it "Oh yes, ds is so original, such an individual you know..."

:o

Report
ilovecaboose · 15/06/2006 19:10

I was reading something that Dr Tanya had written about comforters and she said they were good as it tended to make the child more confident as they didn't need mummy all the time. Those children who have the are the most confident (apparently) and it shows that they are confident and do not need their mum always around.

MY ds has a full sized cot blanket that he won't go to sleep without. He also has attached himself to my carkey (that he carries round all the time when I am not driving) but will give that up at night for the blanket! At least its better than when he used to constantly carry around a jar of marmite with him!

Report
archiesmummy · 15/06/2006 21:08

Absolutely brilliant! So much better than always having a dummy.

Report
Novacane · 15/06/2006 21:15

As I type I am rubbing my feet on my cudgy. I first started off when I was little on silky pillowcases.. since then ive gone through 2 sets of sofa cushions/ other various cudgies of desired consistency..

carmenere... I soo know what you mean about the right consistency etc.. I was panicking as my last cudgy was running thread bare and maybe I was going to have to say byebye.. when I went to my friends new rented house and their dining room table cushions were perfect! I had to sly it out of my friends in the bottom of the buggy...

mumofwun... i think its lovely.. I tried and tried to get my DS into cudgeys and he wasnt interested... hes a dummy boy and wont go anywhere without one plugged in... but thats a whole new thread!

happy cudgying everyone!

Report
Novacane · 15/06/2006 21:16

lol i sound like a crack addict!

At least my addiction is harmless! did I tell you I still suck my thumb?? SHHHH!

Report
threebob · 15/06/2006 21:30

He is using his left hand all the time - to carry the spoon.

He will put the spoon down as he goes through his unscrewing lids phase, and his getting something down from a high place phase.

Just be pleased that he has chosen something washable, durable and replaceable.

Report
EmmyLou · 16/06/2006 09:38

LOL at jar of Marmite, caboose Grin

Nova - I only gave up sucking my fingers (middle two, right hand)when I was about 26. I used to do it without thinking about it which was v embarrasing. Blush. Remember feeling miffed that it was always my right hand as doing homework when tired became a real battle of wills - couldn't hold a pen AND such fingers...Blush Blush

Report
nailpolish · 16/06/2006 09:42

mumofwun, i have never read such a gorgeous post. your ds sounds adorable

my 2 dd's have a comforter, its disgusting and filthy and gets washed about every 6 mths

dd2's is an old rag, when i put it in the washing machine she sits at the side of it, pawing the door saying "its ok Bada, youll be ok"

dont worry about the woooden spoon or the scraped knuckles, its nice he has a comforter

Smile

Report
SecurMummy · 16/06/2006 09:50

Well for my part, I think anything that makes them feel happy is good, we all want nice happy secur children and if he wants a wooden spoon to help then so be it.

As for scrapes, give it another 3 or 4 months and he will hit the "trying to run away from you" stage and thAT is it then he will be covered with scrapes and bruises so often you wonder if Social Services are going to swoop in Grin

He sounds lovely, a real credit to you Smile

Oh yes and his left/right hand is not set for quite a while yet children up to about 3 or more swap between the two all the time so it will not interfere in that sense.

Report
nailpolish · 16/06/2006 09:52

i am reminded that my little brother had a sort of formula 1 racing helmet that he wore constantly - we have old photos of him wearing it in the bath and bed

Grin

Report
hunkermunker · 16/06/2006 09:55

DS1 has a bear he adores (cue frantic search for another one when he lost him, MN to the rescue!).

Novacane...you pinched a dining room cushion?! Shock Grin

Report
FioFio · 16/06/2006 09:56

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted

hunkermunker · 16/06/2006 09:57

Perhaps he's a Button Moon fan in the making? Grin He does sound very sweet. DS1's first "companion" was a yellow rubber ball that had a red flashing light inside - he held it in his hand all day once and still loves it.

Report
JanH · 16/06/2006 09:59

ROFL at all these cute comforters, esp wannabe's sink plunger!

caboose, DS2 had a cot blankie too - we cut it in half so there would be 2 - in fact we had identical white and yellow blankets and cut them both in half, to cope with middle-of-the-night-vomit emergencies (the colour didn't matter at night) and so we could keep one at grandma's.

He's 13 now - it's still in his bed...Grin

Report
nailpolish · 16/06/2006 10:00

at least a wooden spoon is large and visible - dd1 has on occasions taken her tiny little yellow bead out on days out - cue lost bead, once we had almost every member of staff of Glamis Castle teashop searching for it (it was in her pocket)

Report

Don’t want to miss threads like this?

Weekly

Sign up to our weekly round up and get all the best threads sent straight to your inbox!

Log in to update your newsletter preferences.

You've subscribed!

threebob · 16/06/2006 10:39

Ds has just taken his "special teddy", wrapped it up with bubble wrap and sellotape and given it to the 1 year old girl next door. I explained that once he had given it away he couldn't have it any more, and he was fine with that. I thought he might wobble at the last minute - but again he was fine. i do hope he doesn't start wanting to give away all his toys though.

So at some point the wooden spoon may either fall out of favour or be given to a child your ds thinks needs it more.

Report
hunkermunker · 16/06/2006 10:52

Threebob, your DS is SO sweet! I'm stil besotted with him - that's a bit strange, right?!

Report
sandradee · 16/06/2006 10:57

Bless his little cottons - he sounds a real cutie.

I don't mean to laugh but it is funny. Yes I agree about giving him things to use both hands - why not get him a sacepan to bang the spoon with

I would not worry about it - My DS is 14 months and has funny nuances. How sad is it that he loves our hoover so much that he will stand crying outside the cupboard where it is kept shout hoooher, hooooher.

Hoooher is his first and only word.

Report
Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.