(40 Posts)
xXjunebugXx Fri 10-Jan-14 18:14:04

What are your opinions on this name? Do you think Annie would work for short?

Annie is beautiful (and on my list for this DC) but I really dislike Antonia. I just don't think it sounds very nice.

Plus I have an irrational dislike of feminised male names.

Annie on it's own gets my vote.

Withknobson Fri 10-Jan-14 18:16:00

Love it, beautiful under used name. Can't say I'm over keen on nn Annie though. Why not just use the full name?

OhCaptainDarling Fri 10-Jan-14 18:16:20

Like the name, but I don't think Annie would work for short at all.

What about Toni?

The girls I know with this name has nn which have nothing to do with real name. Like Coco or Sissy etc.

salvadory Fri 10-Jan-14 18:17:36

Lovely name and I really like Annie. Not keen on Toni just because it feels more 80's and therefore a little dated.

mumbaisapphirebluespruce Fri 10-Jan-14 18:17:37

Antonia is nice. Don't think you need to shorten it at all. Annie seems more of a nickname for someone called Anne.

juneybean Fri 10-Jan-14 18:18:01

I have a friend called Antonia and she gets called Toni.

Withknobson Fri 10-Jan-14 18:18:40

With mine and Bunny's completely opposing views, we're not much help to you.

ThursdayLast Fri 10-Jan-14 18:21:00

Love it,
Use Annie while you get to choose, give your DD scope for something different as she gets older

xXjunebugXx Fri 10-Jan-14 18:25:16

I really dislike Toni. Of course I would call them Antonia but I know I'd end up shortening it like I did with my sons name. I think Antonia is beautiful but dislike Tonia, Tonia Nia and so on. I thought Annie sounded OK with it and sweet for a baby.

I am team yellow! Just love this name smile

harryhausen Fri 10-Jan-14 18:29:59

Love Antonia. Love Annie too.

I have a good friend called Antonia so I only have good feelings about the name. She's very clever and loyal.

procrastinatingagain Fri 10-Jan-14 18:33:24

Really like Antonia. Annie would work as a nickname too, I think smile

SecretWitch Fri 10-Jan-14 18:35:49

Love Antonia! What a pretty name.

Bigbrassband Fri 10-Jan-14 18:36:39

It's lovely. Anna would work for short, I think.

HoratiaDrelincourt Fri 10-Jan-14 18:38:04

I like it; I think it would work; I know one known as Anty though. She's ace.

hoppinghare Fri 10-Jan-14 18:39:59

I like antonia. It doesn't need shortened but annie works. Annie is lovely as well.

starlight1234 Fri 10-Jan-14 18:40:21

My friend has a daughter Antonia now grown ..she was called Toni for the name

walkdowntheavenue Fri 10-Jan-14 18:42:11

Not a big fan, know a few and they're shorted to Toni or anto

Pinkandwhite Fri 10-Jan-14 18:45:06

I love the name - so pretty and elegant. You could definitely shorten it to Annie - another fab name.

mathanxiety Sat 11-Jan-14 06:00:27

Lovely, and Annie works as a nn.

ZingChoirsOfAngels Sat 11-Jan-14 06:49:10

wonderful name and I knew a wonderful person named
she was my after school teacher when I was ten.
she was just amazing, treated us as friends and installed in me a love for sewing and crafts - she taught me how to cross-stitch etc.

she was perfectly lovely and the only reason I didn't choose Antonia for DD as it is pronounced differently in English (from Hungarian) which I don't like, plus I'd hate her to be nickamed Toni by otherssad

but Annie is a great nickname, so go for it!smile

chickydoo Sat 11-Jan-14 07:26:39

My favourite person in the world is called Antonia.
Lovely, elegant name.

greeneyes1978 Sat 11-Jan-14 07:33:56

Both the Antonias I know both lovely people but they are both known as Toni.

BuntyPenfold Sat 11-Jan-14 09:10:27

I know one, never called anything for short.

It's a lovely elegant name.

hawkmcqueen Sat 11-Jan-14 09:16:06

Antonia is lovely but I REALLY dislike Toni, it's one of those names that provokes irrational anger! I don't know if you could wholly avoid her peers using it.

IsabellaRockerfeller Sat 11-Jan-14 09:17:13

Antonia is lovely but the Antonias I know are all known as Toni which I don't like!

YouGrateMyCheese Sat 11-Jan-14 17:42:43

Antonia is a stunning name. I think Annie would work just fine - they share the same first syllable after all. My first thought is Willa Cather's My Antonia. It's a top 10 name in Chile.

FatAmy Sat 11-Jan-14 17:43:49

I like Annie but really don't like Antonia, I think it sounds too masculine.

BlueMoonRiver Sat 11-Jan-14 18:02:22

Antonia is beautiful. The only downside is the shortening to Toni.

xXjunebugXx Sat 11-Jan-14 20:59:07

I dislike Toni too, Annie I think is cute for a baby. Obviously if she (possible girl in my tummy) wants to be Toni when she's older that is up to her but to us she would be Annie. And if she went by Annie all her life I guess people would be corrected buy her if they called her Toni and she didn't like it!

mrsgumpy Sat 11-Jan-14 21:28:53

I love it.

Read My Antonia by Willa Cather and you will love it even more.

Wandastartup Sun 12-Jan-14 00:06:08

My sister is Antonia. Has never been shortened. Wondering if some of the comments up thread may be about her!

I am one! (Should probably namechange now?) I like it, for the record!

I agree about the awfulness of Toni. My mum used to call me it, I hated it, it took a really long time (30 years!) to get her to stop. Since I was about 18 I've gone by a shortened version she hates, but I don't expect her to use it and I wouldn't write it on her birthday card or anything!

BTW I had to choose a shortening because everyone, everyone feels the need to shorten it! I couldn't cope with all the different hideous nns!

Oh and Wanda I don't think I'm your sister, unless my sister's 'MN is a waste of time' line is a very clever act grin

Grumblelion Sun 12-Jan-14 00:29:40

Love Antonia, much more than all the nn's.

pinkyredrose Sun 12-Jan-14 00:33:53

Do you have Italian connections in your family?

lemonmuffin Sun 12-Jan-14 00:58:19

gorgeous name

catinboots Sun 12-Jan-14 01:23:43

Ugly IMHO sorry.

I hate feminised versions of men's names.

ie - Antonia, Bryoni, Roberta


But hey if you love it go for it! Lots of people probably can't stand my DCs names grin

JapaneseMargaret Sun 12-Jan-14 07:22:08

Classic, elegant, timeless name. You don't have to be Italian to use it, any more than you need to be Greek to use Helen/a. It is mainstream enough.

Go for it!

xXjunebugXx Sun 12-Jan-14 14:01:37

No, no Italian connections.

I have read My Antonia and it is a lovely story.

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now