Mairead or Esme?

(47 Posts)
ilikeyoursleeves Thu 11-Apr-13 12:41:56

What do you think?

TheChaoGoesMu Thu 11-Apr-13 12:45:12

Both lovely names. I like them both the same. <helpful>

BoyMeetsWorld Thu 11-Apr-13 12:47:58

Mairead at the moment just makes me think of that Philpott woman im afraid. Esme is nice though

almapudden Thu 11-Apr-13 12:49:18

I love Esme. Really dislike Mairead, sorry!

BigGiantCowWithAKnockKnockTail Thu 11-Apr-13 12:49:34

I'd say there will be very negative associations to Mairead tbh.

BigGiantCowWithAKnockKnockTail Thu 11-Apr-13 12:49:51

I love Esme btw.

SneezySnatcher Thu 11-Apr-13 12:54:20

As above, Mairead makes me think of Philpott.

Esme is lovely.

CashmereHoodlum Thu 11-Apr-13 12:58:13

Mairead makes me think of Mairead Farrell, but having said that I do know a Mairead and I don't associate the two iyswim.

Esme is very popular at the moment. I prefer Mairead.

AmberSocks Thu 11-Apr-13 12:59:37

Mairead reminds me of philpott too sorry!Esme is lovely but v popular because of twilight x

itsnothingoriginal Thu 11-Apr-13 13:00:10

It's a shame about the Philpott connection as Mairead is a pretty name. How about Merryn?

Like Esme but getting just a little bit weary of it - I know loads now!

everlong Thu 11-Apr-13 16:37:54

Mairead really?

Do you read the news?

FriggFRIGG Thu 11-Apr-13 16:46:21

I agree,I'm afraid Mairead has been ruined for the moment.

Esme is lovely.

TobyLerone Thu 11-Apr-13 16:49:10

Esme is DD's name. I must have got in before the rush -- I don't know any other Esmes and her name is still often commented on because it is unusual and pretty. She's 12.

She's definitely Ez-mee, though. She loathes Ez-may, as do I.

thermalsinapril Thu 11-Apr-13 16:59:29

Mairead.

Not keen on Esme, the "ezz" sound is harsh.

monniemae Thu 11-Apr-13 17:05:08

I love Mairead, it's on my shortlist. Not arsed about woman in the news - you've no control over what might happen post-birth in the news, there may be an Esme to out-horror Mairead.

You're not naming the baby AFTER Mairead Philpott...

everlong Thu 11-Apr-13 17:20:54

No it's not AFTER her but I wouldn't choose the same name as anyone that had murdered their children or anyone's children tbh.

I prefer it spelt Mairi smile

kitsmummy Thu 11-Apr-13 17:41:11

Philpott for me too sad

jellybeans Thu 11-Apr-13 17:52:52

reminds me of the Philpott woman also so Esme.

cozyup Thu 11-Apr-13 17:55:32

Very diffrrent.
Any siblings?

BadSpellersUntie Thu 11-Apr-13 17:58:52

Both pretty dreary but you're mad to even consider mairead

Love Mairead. I know a few of them and have always loved it.

ReluctantlyBeingYoniMassaged Thu 11-Apr-13 18:02:49

Esme is lovely. Mairead is awful, even without recent events.

ilikeyoursleeves Thu 11-Apr-13 18:24:02

It's not for my own child, a friend of mine was asking what I thought of them for her child. I think Philpott too TBH but she loves it!

LondonInHighHeeledBoots Thu 11-Apr-13 19:56:42

Love love love Esme.

I had not at all associated Mairead with the Philpott woman until posters mentioned it, but I just don't like the name at all. Esme is so much nicer!

shellyf Thu 11-Apr-13 19:58:28

Esme

forgetmenots Thu 11-Apr-13 22:59:50

How are you pronouncing Mairead (MOI-rid or Ma-RAID)? Like both actually and would never have thought philpott... Not keen on Esme at all tbh.

ChompieMum Thu 11-Apr-13 23:04:09

Mairead is beautiful. By the time she could say her name, association with Philpott will have long gone

DonDrapersAltrEgoBigglesDraper Fri 12-Apr-13 03:48:32

I like Mairead, and think the Philpott association will be short-lived.

Esme is nice, but getting a little tired now. The pronunciation is an issue too - will never understand the rational behind the pn Es-mee - as far as I can tell, no-one outside the UK goes for this pronunciation? it's akin to pronouncing Renée=Renny and pâté=patty.

Machli Fri 12-Apr-13 03:52:27

Esme. It's my favourite girls name but ex vetoed it for dd angry. Her name now is equally lovely to be fair but I do love Esme.

TobyLerone Fri 12-Apr-13 08:00:33

But Renée and pâté have accents to tell you to pronounce them with an 'ay' sound at the end. Esme does not. Esmé does.

So no, it's nothing like pronouncing Renée 'renny'.

DonDrapersAltrEgoBigglesDraper Fri 12-Apr-13 08:58:07

I hear you, but having only ever heard the Es-may pronunciation until coming onto Mumsnet in my 30s (I'm not in the UK), hearing it pronounced Es-mee is like hearing Renee pronounced Renny.

Sorry, I feel bad maligning someone's chosen name - genuinely - but it was just that the OP asked for opinions, and pronunciation issues can be a real factor when deciding on names. DD's name has three accepted pronunciations which we knew and made our peace with when we agreed on it. People only ever have a 1 in 3 chance of getting it 'right'. Luckily we don't loathe any of the other pronunciations, and so either correct people, or leave it altogether if it's someone we're unlikely to have dealings with ever again. smile

TobyLerone Fri 12-Apr-13 10:47:46

Meh. If someone is too dim to pronounce something phonetically, it doesn't really matter in the big scheme of things, I suppose.

DD has several friends (and a couple of teachers) who insist on calling her Ez-may, despite having been corrected on many occasions. She just sucks it up now.

If you pronounce Renée as Renny, you're an idiot (or ignorant). If you pronounce Esme (no accent) as Ez-may, same applies!

Anyway, I'm allowing myself to be sidetracked. Go for Esme, OP. It's lovely grin

cece Fri 12-Apr-13 10:59:28

I agree with you Toby. My Esme doesn't mind the Es-may pronounciation but it is annoying when you correct people and they still mispronouce it. Still its not the end of the world.

Funnily enough I had never heard of the Es-may pronounication prior to naming my Esme. I only know ones who say Es-mee.

I also like Mairead OP. If I had some Irish in me I might have used it myself.

squoosh Fri 12-Apr-13 12:47:31

Two quite frumpy names. Sorry!

squoosh Fri 12-Apr-13 12:48:23

And if you do decide to go for Esmé/Esme the 'may' pronunciation is significantly nicer.

MoonHare Fri 12-Apr-13 12:51:59

Has to be Esme - but please Ez-may which is defo the correct pn, accent over final e.

SqueakyCleanNameChange Fri 12-Apr-13 12:52:04

Esme to me means Granny Weatherwax from the Discworld books. This is a very good thing in a name.

TobyLerone Fri 12-Apr-13 12:53:25

Ez-may is indeed the correct pronunciation, IF you choose to put the accent over the 'e'.

<headdesk>

ZolaBuddleia Fri 12-Apr-13 12:59:19

Mairead is very lumpen and plain IMO. Esme is lovely.

CruCru Fri 12-Apr-13 21:16:55

Apart from Phillpot, isn't Mairead the equivalent of Barbara or Pauline in Ireland?

MummyBurrows Fri 12-Apr-13 22:37:30

To be honest before the twilight phenomenon I did always read Esme as ez-mee but now every time I see it I read it as ez-may regardless of any accent over the e....got a feeling that will now be the case for most people so I don't think it matters what pronunciation you choose ,ur dd will forever be called ez-may by everyone except family and close friends she makes who will say ez-mee if that's the one you opt for.

As for mairead....it will be associated with the phillpot child killing scum for some time yet but give it a year and it will be completely forgotten,just very unfortunate timing for that name right now.

My personal vote would go to Esme (ez-may) xx

twinklestar2 Sat 13-Apr-13 00:01:50

I like mairead, have always thought it sounds nice.

twinklestar2 Sat 13-Apr-13 00:03:23

I like mairead, have always thought it sounds nice.

mathanxiety Sat 13-Apr-13 05:07:26

Mairead has an accent too, on the E... Gives the second syllable the long A sound instead of sounding like 'red'.

There are thousands of Maireads being startled daily at reading their name in connection with the Philpott case, but that will blow over. Who knows, maybe the next horrible murder will be committed by an Esme (whether 'Esmee' or 'Esmay').

Fwiw, I prefer Mairead but I am biased.
(Sorry can't do accents right now as DD4 spilled something into the number pad a few days ago and it's stuck solid)

dimdommilpot Sat 13-Apr-13 19:12:16

DD id Esmé pronounced Ez-may. I decided on the name 13yr before she was born, she is 2.5 and i still love the name. Not a fan of Ez-mee however it really doesnt bother me if people pronounce it that way, its not the end of the world.

Queazy Sun 14-Apr-13 19:44:45

I think they'll be beautiful 'in the flesh' if that makes sense - the child makes the name etc. Not hugely keen on either though. Esme is my preferred though smile

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now