Samuel definitely the best and nicest of those, i think it goes v well with Finn and is lovely

Samuel!

George

Thanks for the input.
im still preggers 41+1 today
Edward is my lead name but Edward is also DS1s middle name which makes me feel slightly bad....
DP is vouching for Samuel George
DS1 (4) is vouching for Georgie porgie or Maxie?! George
Joe needs more thought
And I need to have a baby soon I feel like i've been horseriding

They're all gorgeous but I like Edward (Teddy) best

DS2 was going to be Edward/Eddie/Ed but when he was born it didn't suit him so we went with a name we hadn't even considered.

IME it is best to wait and meet your baby before making the final decision on a name. We did that with all 3 of ours and it worked out fine.

BTW I like all your choices

I have a Joe and he is just Joe.. No other Joe's in entire infant school (120 pupils) so not too common here.. About number 60 or so in Top 100. I think its the least common of the 4 you suggest. Goes best with Finn too. I expect number 4 this week and am considering Finn!

Edward (Teddy/Ted/Ed nn - all fab)

George

Samuel