Rose or Phoebe?

(32 Posts)
Dinocat Sun 17-Apr-16 12:59:50

Hello!

DD1 is due in a couple of weeks and DH and I can't quite decide on a name for her! We both love Phoebe and Rose (would probably end up being 'Rosie') but I'm just not sure! I also really like Margot but DH has vetoed, likewise I vetoed his suggestion of Emily.

Also can anyone suggest similar names that we may have overlooked? Middle name will be Emilia after DH grandmother, surname is 2 syllables.

Thankyou smile

KoalaDownUnder Sun 17-Apr-16 13:03:00

Phoebe.

I find Rose a bit dull, tbh.

BoboBunnyH0p Sun 17-Apr-16 13:03:28

I like phoebe.
I suggest: Imogen, Iris, Marcella, Mabel.

Dinocat Sun 17-Apr-16 13:04:44

Ooh Mabel is nice. Have a feeling DH won't agree though!

Iliveinalighthousewiththeghost Sun 17-Apr-16 13:06:21

Well you could hardly have had Emily Emilia or was Emily instead of using Emilia as a MN.
I was going to say Rose, but Rose Emilia doesn't really flow. Emilia Rose does though. If you're up for turning the name around.
Phoebe Rose goes lovely though even though. I do prefer Rose.
I think it's because. Rose is gorgeous and fits with most names as a MN but not a lot of fns go with Rose as MN. IYSWIM.

Dinocat Sun 17-Apr-16 13:10:16

Haha, yes that's exactly why I vetoed it! Don't think he actually says the full name to himself, just more like 'ooh this name is pretty' haha.

Spottyladybird Sun 17-Apr-16 14:03:08

My DD is Phoebe Rose. I think it's pretty, slightly unusual but not out there!!

Nibbl3s Sun 17-Apr-16 14:08:55

I LOVE phoebe, it's pretty but also quite cute/ quirky.

Sophronia Sun 17-Apr-16 14:34:23

Definitely Rose. Not keen on Phoebe at all, it makes me think of the word 'feeble'.

Dinocat Sun 17-Apr-16 15:01:44

Thankyou for your thoughts everyone, definitely helping!

cosmicglittergirl Sun 17-Apr-16 15:06:02

Phoebe definitely. Will be DD3's name if she happens!

Juniper4004 Sun 17-Apr-16 15:18:15

What about Rosa?

WanderingTrolley1 Sun 17-Apr-16 15:25:52

Rose. Pretty. Classic.

JSarah Sun 17-Apr-16 17:35:32

Rose is such a lovely name and I love Rosie too! DH vetoed sad but it's so nice.

Rose Emilia is perfect!

crapfatbanana Sun 17-Apr-16 17:36:52

Phoebe Emilia is an excellent name.

nectarini1983 Sun 17-Apr-16 20:50:14

Phoebe - really hate the look of it! Not sure if it's the 'Ph' or the 'oe'!? Makes me think of amoeba for some strange reason!

Rose is a bit too safe imo. Rosie or Rosa cute though.

Dinocat Sun 17-Apr-16 21:04:09

Thankyou everyone! I think we are leaning towards phoebe now... That is of course unless she looks likes a Rosie when she arrives wink

KatOnATinRo0f Sun 17-Apr-16 21:16:13

I love phoebe!
Rose is pretty but does also seem to be a go-to middle name at the moment. It sounds really nice as a middle name so I guess that's why... But I would go for something a little less common.
Plus phoebe from "friends" was my favourite.

JSarah Sun 17-Apr-16 21:20:11

NO! Please don't lean towards Phoebe! Rose is lovely and not common for a first name!

KoalaDownUnder Sun 17-Apr-16 21:29:11

Love Rosa, btw. Just not Rose (staid, dated) or Rosie (twee).

Naicecuppatea Sun 17-Apr-16 21:31:32

Rose definitely over Phoebe which I also find sounds like feeble.

rainbowstardrops Sun 17-Apr-16 21:33:09

Rose.
Like a pp said, Phoebe reminds me of amoeba. Don't know why!

ozymandiusking Sun 17-Apr-16 21:34:50

Have them both, Phoebe Rose, this is lovely.

Paddletonio Sun 17-Apr-16 21:48:31

Rose

Nospringflower Sun 17-Apr-16 22:14:12

Not keen on Rose so Phoebe!

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now