Sophia, Charlotte or Amy?

(19 Posts)
UptownFunk00 Tue 09-Feb-16 22:29:03

Whilst waiting for labour to progress even further at 39+4 just looking for thoughts.

We have:
Charlotte
Sophia
Amy ( or Aimee)

Our first DD is Hollie. Our surname begins with Y.

Which do you prefer and any other suggestions welcome. smile

Monkeymonstermum Tue 09-Feb-16 23:21:01

Charlotte (and love Lottie as nn)

manicinsomniac Wed 10-Feb-16 00:57:41

Love them all

My favourite is Amy

Charlotte probably gets 2nd place but really do like Sophia too.

Fridgedooropen Wed 10-Feb-16 01:08:44

Amy and Charlotte are both lovely. Charlotte might go better with a Y surname. I'd avoid Sophia as it's massively popular now. Hope labour goes smoothly.

HolsW Wed 10-Feb-16 05:40:33

I like them all smile

1. Sophia
2. Amy
3. Charlotte (the Charlottes I know are shortened to 'Char', which I really don't like!)

LeLeFox Wed 10-Feb-16 23:14:28

Sophia smile

SquareStarfish Wed 10-Feb-16 23:23:12

Sophia
Amy
Charlotte

DramaAlpaca Wed 10-Feb-16 23:24:15

Amy is nicest with Hollie, IMO.

MrsOlaf78 Sun 14-Feb-16 07:13:53

Charlotte is beautiful with Sophia a close second!

Wardrobespierre Sun 14-Feb-16 07:29:41

I don't think you'll get a majority opinion as the names are so similar in feel. Classic, recognisable, traditional names. It's all just preference and how they sound with your surname. In fact, have a couple of middle names and you could just use them all.

Interestingly, every Hollie I've met in rl has sisters called Poppy or Sophie.

Snazarooney Sun 14-Feb-16 07:35:27

All 3 are nice!

Effiethemonster Sun 14-Feb-16 07:50:11

I love Sophia, would've chosen it myself but gave a few Sophies in the family.

CoffeeCoffeeAndLotsOfIt Sun 14-Feb-16 08:14:24

I love Amy. I'd name her Amelia and call her Amy though.

Charlotte is lovely, especially shortened to Charlie or Lottie (but not char or worst still chaz!)

Sophia is beautiful - but too overused

daisydalrymple Sun 14-Feb-16 08:41:29

Charlotte Sophia grin
Beautiful names op, and hope the wait isn't too long and all goes quickly and pain free!

WhyCantIuseTheNameIWant Sun 14-Feb-16 08:51:13

Amy Megan Y....

Initials will spell Amy.

Amy is cute, easy to spell.
Sophia is elegant. Not sure i like "soph"
Charlotte is ok, but quite popular here.

IoraRua Sun 14-Feb-16 11:42:40

Charlotte is lovely. It has a bit more to it than the other names iyswim.

Sophia and Amy, meh, we have quite a few of them in my school. If popularity bothers you then avoid.

WinterWinnie Sun 14-Feb-16 20:04:27

1. Sophia
2. Amy
3. Charlotte
smile

LeonoraFlorence Wed 17-Feb-16 11:46:57

I like Sophia (though I have one so I'm biased). Also love Charlotte, one of my DDs middle names.

ABitAsleep Wed 17-Feb-16 16:22:11

I like Aimee the best, and i think it goes well with Hollie.

Charlotte is nice, but i prefer it shortened to Lottie.

I think Sophia is a bit over popular at the moment, so it depends if that bothers you. I prefer Sophie over Sophia.

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now