Are Anna and Emma too similar?

(43 Posts)
RockCrushesLizard Tue 12-Jan-16 10:13:25

So, I already have an Anna, and both DH and I like Emma for the DD we're expecting, but I think it may be too similar?

I like classic names - Emily, Alice, Kate, Elizabeth, Isabel - but worry that many of them are too popular, and there'll be three in every school class...

Any inspiration or opinions welcome!

KoalaDownUnder Tue 12-Jan-16 10:18:19

It's much too similar. As is Alice, imho.

I'd go for Kate, out of that lot.

Hamsolo Tue 12-Jan-16 10:19:29

I don't think they're that similar at all. I like all you choices though.

whatdoIget Tue 12-Jan-16 10:21:00

I knew sisters called Anna and Emma when I was at school. It does seem a bit matchy to me

nextusername Tue 12-Jan-16 10:24:11

I think they are quite similar.

NadiaWadia Tue 12-Jan-16 10:47:28

They are both nice names (especially Anna) but I think they are too similar. Other people will get them mixed up.

You already mentioned Emily, which is a beautiful name, quite similar to Emma, but different enough from Anna, so what about that? Personally I actually find Emily more interesting than Emma, somehow.

RockCrushesLizard Tue 12-Jan-16 11:25:41

I'm glad it's not just me then (DH thinks they aren't similar!)

Back to the drawing board...

FunkyPeacock Tue 12-Jan-16 11:27:10

I know sisters called Anna & Emma and not aware it has caused them any problems

I think the names would end up getting elided into one name - Anneranemma. And I am afraid I do think they are too similar.

wigglesrock Tue 12-Jan-16 11:47:01

Yes they are, sorry. I'm speaking from experience grin. I have one and the other is her cousin and I find them very samey.

We have an Anna.
Other names that were on our "long" list and her sisters names are :
Stella
Olivia
Sadie
Tess
Cara
Mary
Frances
Sofia
Nina
Elizabeth
Elena
Claudia
Meg

Absolutelyfabulously Tue 12-Jan-16 12:08:35

I think Kate is a name you could use and not find too many about.

Pteranodon Tue 12-Jan-16 12:11:58

I am an Anna and people do sometimes hear 'Emma'. At my wedding the staff put up a big banner saying 'Congratulations Emma and Bernard!' It made me laugh, but I don't have a sister called Emma.

TheCatsMeow Tue 12-Jan-16 12:16:03

I don't think they're too similar. Elizabeth is nice and has lots of nicknames I'd use that from your list if you don't want to use Emma!

LuciaInFurs Tue 12-Jan-16 12:17:47

I don't think they are similar and both are beautiful names, I also love classic names. But if it really worries you Kate is lovely and wigglesrock has a good list. Esme would work well if you are set on a 'e' name.

Duckdeamon Tue 12-Jan-16 12:19:05

Too similar IMO.

Decanter Tue 12-Jan-16 12:31:15

This might sound strange, but to me, they are actually too different to be used for siblings, in that they don't have the same "feel". I liken it to using a modern name and an old fashioned name, which I get isn't the case here, but they just don't sound right together to me.

RockCrushesLizard Tue 12-Jan-16 12:52:12

Thanks all of you, for taking the time to give me feedback. I think we can safely say Emma is off the list!

How do we feel about

Alexa
Juliet
Elise

?

nextusername Tue 12-Jan-16 12:55:16

Juliet is a lovely name. I find Alexa a little harsh. Elise is OK but I prefer Louise/Louisa.

wigglesrock Tue 12-Jan-16 12:56:38

Oh I love Juliet, that was supposed to be on my list grin. Alexa not so much but I'm not the biggest fan of Alex as a sound in any name. Elise is nice too, I know a 4 year old one, it's lovely on her.

Borninthe60s Tue 12-Jan-16 13:01:44

Ella?

Flingingmelon Tue 12-Jan-16 13:12:15

A dear friend went out with a chap three times before she realised he thought her name was Anna. Her name was Emma.

KoalaDownUnder Tue 12-Jan-16 13:33:54

Anna and Juliet - perfect!
Anna and Tess - gorgeous too.

Or:

Esther
Celia
Rosie
Helena
Lola
Romy
Saskia
Daisy
Camilla

Bubbletree4 Tue 12-Jan-16 13:36:31

Anna and Emma are great together. Both really nice. I'd definitely use them.

stopitcaroline Tue 12-Jan-16 14:31:49

I think Anna and Emma are a bit too close. That said, what about Anna and Emily? Similar sound.

I like the same sorts of names you do. I wouldn't worry too much about Elizabeth being too popular. I mean, there are so many nicknames, so even if there are three Elizabeths in a class, they might be Elizabeth, Lizzie, and Betsy. I think Anna and Elizabeth are wonderful together. I also love Anna and Kate, though prefer Katherine for the full name.

Some more unusual suggestions:
Anna and Louisa
Anna and Leah
Anna and Clara
Anna and Audrey
Anna and Claudia

cecilelliott Tue 12-Jan-16 20:52:31

Ye, agree that Anna and Juliet sound lovely together.

As do Anna and Kate (there are hardly any Kates around these days)

Not so keen on your the other suggestions I'm afraid

Good luck!

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now