Honest opinions on Meredith...

(55 Posts)
smileygrapefruit Mon 04-Jan-16 01:04:08

...with Edie as nn.

Had mixed reactions in rl.

nashley Mon 04-Jan-16 01:09:17

Interesting names! I quite like them actually! Slightly prefer edie to Meredith but at the end of the day it's totally yours and DP decision. Stuff everyone else!

MeAndCoolioDownByTheSchoolYard Mon 04-Jan-16 01:11:51

I don't like Meredith. It gives me a prissy 'virtue name' vibe like Verity etc. Which isn't a good thing. Plus that tiresome moose from Grey's Anatomy.

Edie is much better. The one I know is just Edie.

smileygrapefruit Mon 04-Jan-16 01:14:01

Oh I don't watch Grey's anatomy. Is that an instant leap when you hear it?

INeedNewShoes Mon 04-Jan-16 01:14:12

I know a lovely Meredyth, nickname Merri. I like both names.

HooseRice Mon 04-Jan-16 01:15:34

Prefer Edith as the long name for Edie. Meredith reminds me of the murder in Italy.

smileygrapefruit Mon 04-Jan-16 01:16:42

Ahh, see I don't like merri but I guess they decide what they choose to be called when older?!

smileygrapefruit Mon 04-Jan-16 01:17:36

Haha murders and moose...poor child!

HeadDreamer Mon 04-Jan-16 01:23:51

I think greys anatomy too. But that shouldn't matter as it is not a kids show.

Pretty name btw.

ifigoup Mon 04-Jan-16 01:24:24

I like Meredith. It sounds American to my ear. Edie is sweet, but for me not the most natural nickname from Meredith.

ZenNudist Mon 04-Jan-16 01:34:22

Like. Pretty, classic, not overdone.

NeedsAsockamnesty Mon 04-Jan-16 01:49:28

I rather like it. You may think that me liking it is not a good thing

sooperdooper Mon 04-Jan-16 01:54:01

I love it, only ever known one Meredith and she was fantastic! Massively underused, without being too try hard.

I wouldn't worry about a nick name now though, let that come naturally.

smileygrapefruit Mon 04-Jan-16 02:10:52

A little mixed but mostly positive so far...My DH actually picked it, he didn't like anything else, and I wasn't convinced at first but it really has grown on me and I love it! In rl it seems to have got really positive reactions or a hmm oh right...

I don't know any other Meredith.

duckduckquack Mon 04-Jan-16 02:14:28

I definitely thought Greys Anatomy immediately but who cares, it's a lovely name. And as an alternative nn you could have Meri (like merry). Go for it!

ItWorks Mon 04-Jan-16 02:23:57

I think Meredith is horrible, sorry.

Marcipex Mon 04-Jan-16 08:52:32

Love it, I know a charming girl called this.

redhat Mon 04-Jan-16 08:54:29

I watch greys anatomy and they all call the Meredith character "Mer/Mare" which isn't a great shortening but is the inevitable one.

GladysTheGolem Mon 04-Jan-16 08:56:54

I hate the character in Greys (she's a whingey, boring git) but love the name!

Noggie Mon 04-Jan-16 09:02:32

I love the name and like Merry or Edie nicknames - BUT I do immediately think of the poor girl murdered in Italy sad like greys anatomy and the Meredith in it so that wouldn't put me off.

Leigh1980 Mon 04-Jan-16 09:06:12

Edie definitely. Meredith reminds me of that horrible woman in Parent Trap!

wigglesrock Mon 04-Jan-16 11:49:22

I never thought I liked Meredith but we have one in our extended family and it's really grown on me - its lovely. She occasionally gets Mere and she used to get Merry as a child.

I'm not as fussed on Edie as a nickname, to my ears its very trendy Wendy at the minute - it seems to be the "alternative" celebrity baby name of choice.

timelytess Mon 04-Jan-16 11:50:08

Meredith is great, Edie is horrible.

Fabsolutely Mon 04-Jan-16 11:56:04

I like Edie. Meredith sounds sensible and a bit joyless.

Hadron21 Mon 04-Jan-16 11:57:04

Beautiful name. Also love Merry nn.

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now