which name do you prefer?

[emmav6]

we have a short one syllable surname & struggling with a good first/middle name match.

would love some honest opinions on these names please?

Eloise May F
Eloise Josephine F
Abigail May F
Imogen May F
Ellie May F

[ems942]

Imogen or Abigail... Ellie May is overdone

[susurration]

Imogen is my favourite. Can be shortened to Immy if you want.

[ThroughThickAndThin01]

Eloise Josephine

Not just Ellie as you have the option of shortening to Ellie with Eloise anyway.

[LauraChant]

Eloise May is my favourite followed by Imogen May.

[manicinsomniac]

Abigail May is my favourite.

Also like Imogen May and Eloise Josephine

[StrangeGlue]

Eloise Josephine - beautiful!!

[getbusyliving]

Ellie has been done to death
Imogen I really dislike this name, but am in the minority as everyone seems to love it
Abigail will probably be Abbey
So I'd go for Eloise out of your options but I don't like the mn you picked to go with it. Also Eloise will end up another Ellie

[seaoflove]

May is SUCH an overused middle name (along with Rose and Grace) of be tempted to avoid it entirely.

[MarieJeanne]

Eloise Josephine

[ashesandfire]

Eloise Josephine. Love Eloise

[emmav6]

Think i may have to disappoint family & choose my own middle name as i'm not sure on them either :( may has been passed down but my mum didnt use it with me so might just be selfish & pick my own.... although that could take a while to decide too haha
Thanks for all your input, it's really helping
Em xx

[Sophronia]

Abigail May (although I'd prefer Abigail Josephine), or Eloise Josephine.

[Peachyfacegurl]

I like Abigail best out of your first name options and Josephine for a middle name- lovely

[NadiaWadia]

Eloise Josephine is lovely. May has a nice sound, but has been done to death in recent years. Imogen and Abigail are also lovely names.

Ellie sounds quite nicknamey and 'little girl-y' and has also been done to death. You could use the nickname 'Ellie' from Eloise anyway, as pp pointed out.

[MamaLazarou]

Eloise, definitely.

[2Blessed0301]

Abigail May is Beautiful :) my fav

[CakeRattleandRoll]

Another vote for Abigail May (or Abigail Josephine, also lovely).

[Zakken]

Eloise, definitely. But not with May, which has become a default second name with the current generation.

[LemonYellowSun]

Eloise Josephine

[beedeepullen]

I think I have to 100% agree with getbusyliving

[PallasCat]

Eloise Josephine

[RemusLupinsBiggestGroupie]

Eloise May

[Meredithgraze]

Love Eloise but anything with May,Mai,Mae is totally overdone these days. Ellie on its own is lovely.

[ButterflyOfFreedom]

Imogen