Edgar Otto

(37 Posts)
pygmy Fri 02-Aug-13 11:30:54

Nice or not nice?

I like both Ed and Eddie as nicknames.

MrsBungle Mon 05-Aug-13 20:10:43

It's a surname in Scotland. I like it as a first name and agree its certainly less boring than Edward. I quite like otto too.

ellesabe Mon 05-Aug-13 20:08:58

It sounds like Ed Grotto...

tigerdriverII Mexico Sun 04-Aug-13 01:01:51

Love these joke threads

formicadinosaur Sun 04-Aug-13 00:57:43

Otto is great.

rockybalboa Sat 03-Aug-13 11:30:36

Love Edgar. Unfortunately I have reasons for hating the nn Ed so was never going to work for us. Had to have a a major battle with DH over it though as he was very very very very keen on Edgar. It is a super cool name and not old mannish at all. Think Egg from This Life. Swoon...

YoMamma Sat 03-Aug-13 11:27:43

Love Edgar but I don't think it goes well with Otto

PicardyThird Sat 03-Aug-13 07:19:44

It sounds like a late-19th-century German. I think Otto, although I don't like it personally, has that old-man-chic vibe, but Edgar definitely doesn't. Has good nickname potential, though (Ed or Eddie).How about Edward?

sleepdodger Sat 03-Aug-13 07:18:07

I know a 2yo Edgar and he's a cutie

Love Edgar, I recently met one and instantly really liked the name. I really like Otto too but I'm afraid for me I hear garrotte too when they're said together

Yika Sat 03-Aug-13 07:14:30

I love it, that's one of the nicest name combinations I've seen on here.

mathanxiety Sat 03-Aug-13 07:09:43

Like them both, but like Layl77 I hear another word in there somewhere -- garotte.

I know an Edgar who has always been Eddie.

Layl77 Sat 03-Aug-13 05:42:01

Edgar Otto sounds like there's 'rot' in there somewhere. Both fine but not together

williaminajetfighter Sat 03-Aug-13 05:13:29

Edgar Allen Poe. Can't go wrong...

almapudden Sat 03-Aug-13 04:54:28

Love it.

everlong Sat 03-Aug-13 04:32:54

Gorgeous.

kiwik Sat 03-Aug-13 01:08:29

Love it.
Edgar is great - strong, and different to the more usual Edward, which is a bit overused.
I adore the name Otto, but DH didn't, so I had to call the cat Otto.

Rhubarbgarden Fri 02-Aug-13 23:29:32

I love Edgar. It was my second choice for ds. I like Otto too.

sonlypuppyfat Fri 02-Aug-13 21:29:45

Words fail me

Ikeameatballs Fri 02-Aug-13 21:24:40

I much prefer Otto to Edgar which I really don't like. I also don't think that they work together, they tend to run into each other and are stylistically very different.

LegArmpits Fri 02-Aug-13 21:23:11

Love love love them both, but I think they run better the other way around.

Capitola Fri 02-Aug-13 21:22:08

I love them both, but would go with Otto as a first name.

KateCroydon Fri 02-Aug-13 21:19:23

awful awful awful.

Mind you, I quite like Tyler...

Timpani Fri 02-Aug-13 16:42:36

I love Edgar!! And tbh it's what you love that matters right? I've given DS1 a very marmite name and I'm sure a few people turned up their noses but no one has really said to my face "ugh, that's awful" or anything.

I would call DS2 (if it's a DS) but it really doesn't go with our surname. I love Edward too!

LazyMonkeyButler Fri 02-Aug-13 14:27:26

Oh dear, Edgar is awful - sorry. Otto is fine, but reminds me of the school bus driver in the Simpsons.

Having said that, we met a 3 year old Edwin on holiday recently and he was a very sweet little thing which did make the name grow on me over the week. Maybe meeting an Edgar would work in the same way?

dyslexicdespot Fri 02-Aug-13 14:26:15

Both are very nice.

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now