Elizabeth Joan

(38 Posts)
extracrunchy Sat 27-Jul-13 22:52:53

So it's going to be a girl!

The only name DH and I can agree on is Elizabeth (traditional and easily shortened to something quirkier - any ideas as an aside??) and we'd like to commemorate DF's mother with Joan as a middle name. I was pretty happy till I floated it with my sister who was thoroughly scathing and now I'm having doubts...

What do you think??

NarkyNamechanger Sat 27-Jul-13 22:54:10

Hmm I like the idea but really not keen on Joan. Sorry!

extracrunchy Sat 27-Jul-13 22:59:19

That's what I'm thinking... Wish my sis didn't get in my head! I thought initially Joan was an inoffensive middle name along the lines of Jane, and also maybe a bit fashionable nowadays with the vogue for old fashioned names, but am I actually considering embarrassing poor DD for life?! grin

NarkyNamechanger Sat 27-Jul-13 23:09:17

Did your mil have a middle name you could use?

squoosh Sat 27-Jul-13 23:16:46

Joan is not the prettiest of names, no two ways about it, having said that I think honouring your daughter's Granny trumps 'prettiness'. Think of Joan from Mad Men and it doesn't sound too bad!

Besides, it will be a middle name, how often do we think about our middle names?

GeordieCherry Sat 27-Jul-13 23:21:08

Joan of Arc, Joan Armatrading. I've always been fond of it. And Elizabeth is a lovely name

MrsOakenshield Sat 27-Jul-13 23:24:59

Elizabeth is lovely - do you have to shorten it? It's lovely as it is.
Joan - hmmm. Well. Maybe it's so unusual now as to be quite interesting?

BlueStarsAtNight Sat 27-Jul-13 23:25:42

It's ok. Quite a placid, staid kind of name. It's not very exciting but not offensive.

squoosh Sat 27-Jul-13 23:31:04

Shakespeare mentions her in Love's Labour Lost, 'While greasy Joan doth keel the pot'.

Poor old Joan!

notanyanymore Sat 27-Jul-13 23:34:20

Love it!! I'd go for Effie as NN
Middle name of Joan is perfect because its a link with her family. Middle names are personal anyway IMO because who ever introduces themselves with their full name anyway? Much nicer to use it for a family connection that means something then go for something 'pretty' but ultimately irrelevant (which middle names kind if are if they don't have any kind of personal significance)

NurseRatchet Sat 27-Jul-13 23:36:39

My mum is called Joan. She is in her late forties and HATES being called Joan. It is awful.

ExcuseTypos Sat 27-Jul-13 23:41:20

I know someone with a year old baby called Elizabeth Joan then another name which I won't reveal as it may out me. I think this really works

Could you add another name to 'soften' the Joan?

TiggyD Sat 27-Jul-13 23:43:51

Have you given birth to a 60 year old?

YABU.

extracrunchy Sat 27-Jul-13 23:49:29

Haha not yet!

Mollie272 Sun 28-Jul-13 00:00:13

I have an Elizabeth - it's a lovely name! She's known as Lizzy (but NEVER Liz), I like Libby as a nn for Elizabeth too. Is your DH really set on using Joan? My other dd has a middle name that I wouldn't have chosen if it didn't have special family significance.

thechildrensparkle Sun 28-Jul-13 00:05:39

I like it. I'm 53 and everyone I grew up with had an auntie Joan. How about modernising it a tiny bit and going for Joanne perhaps?

Ilovemydogandmydoglovesme Sun 28-Jul-13 00:05:57

What's his mum's middle name?

extracrunchy Sun 28-Jul-13 09:36:14

No idea - will find out!

Wbdn28 Sun 28-Jul-13 09:46:08

Joan is a lovely understated name. Elizabeth Joan goes really nicely and would be a great choice with the family connection too.

JoniR Sun 28-Jul-13 09:55:39

I like Elizabeth Joan. I'm a Joan and love the name, although I've always been known as Joni as my Nan was also Joan. Joni is a younger sounding version if you're worried about Joan sounding too old.

NeoMaxiZoomDweebie Sun 28-Jul-13 10:01:41

Joan is lovely! It's very pretty with Elizabeth too. Gorgeous.

Weegiemum Sun 28-Jul-13 10:02:33

Elizabeth Joan is my Mil's name, so clearly we weren't going there. She's not too keen on it either, but that's probably because she's always been known as Joan, which she thinks is the most boring name around!

NeoMaxiZoomDweebie Sun 28-Jul-13 10:03:02

Joanne isn't modern childrensparkle! It's too recent....I am 40 and half my class was called Joanne! Joan is just old fashi

NeoMaxiZoomDweebie Sun 28-Jul-13 10:03:35

Posted too soon..."Joan is just old fashioned enough to be cool again.

EatYourCrusts Sun 28-Jul-13 10:06:42

Oh my god I LOVE Elizabeth Joan. I can't believe people dislike it.
Joan is amazingly cool. In fact Joan Elizabeth might be a better name.
Joanie is super cute.

Shut up everyone else. Joan is a fab name.

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now