We ask that emails regarding swaps not contain any unsolicited advertising. If you have received an email which contains advertising, please let us know at contactus@mumsnet.com.

Seed stitch problem :(

(32 Posts)
LittleNutTree Wed 12-Dec-12 20:57:14

I found a lovely pattern on Ravelry for a striped seed stitch/stockinette stitch blanket but my seed stitch keeps coming out as a rib!! I've tried it twice and worked 5 or so rows each time (to give it time to develop, hahaha!) and have followed the pattern to the letter but it just doesn't seem to be working.

Can anyone help? I feel like crying! <this may seem a tad melodramatic but I'm 9wks pregnant with the future recipient of said blanket! grin>

LittleNutTree Wed 12-Dec-12 20:58:13

Sorry to seem melodramatic, I'm 9wks pregnant with the recipient of said blanket and I may be slightly hormonal! grin

SlimJimBra Wed 12-Dec-12 21:01:45

seed stitch is like rib but offset, how maky sts are theree? or link to the pattern and I'll have a look

SlimJimBra Wed 12-Dec-12 21:02:10

maky=many blush blush

alarkaspree Wed 12-Dec-12 21:02:17

Maybe the pattern is wrong? I am quite new to knitting myself so I'm sorry if this is eye-rollingly basic for you, but if you look for other people's projects knit on the same pattern and see if any have comments, sometimes people will mention that there are mistakes in the pattern.

For seed stitch, you need to knit and purl alternately but if you're knitting back and forth this will come out as starting with a knit stitch (or a purl stitch) at the beginning of each row.

Can you link to the pattern?

And don't worry. You have 7 months to knit this blanket! You will get there.

LittleNutTree Wed 12-Dec-12 21:13:35

Thanks for the speedy replies!
It was a paid pattern so not sure if I'm allowed to link it? I'm new to Ravelry so feel free to advise smile I'm off to check and see if any errors have been reported.

There'll be no eye rolling here alarkaspree, I'm new to knitting too so any help is gratefully appreciated smile

SlimJimBra Wed 12-Dec-12 21:16:12

of course you can link it, but i wont be able to see the pattern without buying it! will see if i can work it out from the pics though

LittleNutTree Wed 12-Dec-12 21:20:17

Thanks SlimJimBra, the link is here

SlimJimBra Wed 12-Dec-12 21:24:11

Ok, it looks nice and simple. How many stitches do you cast on and do you start with k1 p1 all across the sts?

SlimJimBra Wed 12-Dec-12 21:27:06

It looks from the pic that its around 130 sts, but is it an odd number or an even one? If its even you should start each row with the same stitch, if its an even number you should start row 1 on k1, and row2 on p1 if that makes sense

LittleNutTree Wed 12-Dec-12 21:28:02

grin I thought it looked simple too! Maybe it's me who is too simple for the pattern!

You CO 120 stitches, then K1,P1,K1,P1,K1, K10, then K1,P1,K1,P1,K1,P1,K1,P1,K1,P1, K10, etc until last 5 stitches where you K1,P1,K1,P1,K1.

SlimJimBra Wed 12-Dec-12 21:28:23

Its a lovey pattern, by the way, simple and pretty smile

SlimJimBra Wed 12-Dec-12 21:33:15

Ok, so row 2 should read k1 p1 k1 p1 k1 p10 p1 k1 p1 k1 p1 k1 p1 k1 p1 k1 p10 etc to last 5 sts then k1 p1 k1 p1 k1
For seed stitch you knit the knit sts on both sides and p the p sts on each side, whereas with rib you p the back of the k sts and k the back of the p sts

SlimJimBra Wed 12-Dec-12 21:34:11

(Don't you do a few rows of just seed st first though - to set the bottom of the border?)

LittleNutTree Wed 12-Dec-12 21:34:13

The next row is P1,K1,P1,K1,P1,P10,P1,K1,P1,K1,P1,K1,P1,K1,P1, K1,P10, etc until last 5 stitches.

Does that sound right?

LittleNutTree Wed 12-Dec-12 21:35:39

X-post, sorry! So the pattern sounds wrong? It doesn't say anything about knitting a border. I did wonder about that.

tribpot Wed 12-Dec-12 21:36:38

Seed stitch is a real pain in the bum for newer knitters. It should be simple but unless you keep a very careful count, you need to be able to recognise the difference between a knit and a purl stitch visually so you know what stitch you should be doing next.

If you're doing seed stitch on an odd number of stitches it's easier because every row starts with k1. If the bands have an even number of stitches you will have to remember which row you're on as well - extra bum-ache.

And on top of that, if you're not used to having to move the yarn from behind to in front of the needle between every stitch it can be very slow going. All in all, I've stopped advising our newer Woolly Hugs knitters to try seed stitch.

I would start off with a test swatch where you just try to master the seed stitch bit. if you cast on, say, 11 stitches you should find you can do k1, p1 all across the row and end up on a k1. Same thing on the next row and you should start to see how the pattern develops.

If you want to post just the bit of the pattern instruction that talks about how to do the seed stitch, we can advise further. This shouldn't break any copyright - or you could discuss it on Ravelry where the author can see it. We have a group of our own there.

I will say it seems quite possible the pattern is wrong - no-one has knitted yet except you.

Finally I would say as well there are a lot of free patterns on Rav. That one is perfectly nice but I'm not sure I would have shelled out $5.50 for it. Do look around for ideas. But first off let's see if we can get you started on this one!

SlimJimBra Wed 12-Dec-12 21:37:54

The pattern looks wrong to me, but only the first 5 sts, the rest of it looks fine, the seed st in the middle is the right way round but the border seed st is wrong in the pattern

tribpot Wed 12-Dec-12 21:39:01

x-posted with you. The pattern is definitely wrong, it has you purling the knit stitch from the row before, which will create the rib effect you're seeing.

The blanket definitely has a border on, does the pattern say anything about doing that at the end?

LittleNutTree Wed 12-Dec-12 21:39:30

I know $5.50 does seem a lot looking back on it now, especially since it seems that the pattern might be incorrect based on SlimJimBra's post sad I should have just asked here first!

SlimJimBra Wed 12-Dec-12 21:41:40

Ooh, I didn't know there was a mn woolly hugs ravelry group smile

tribpot Wed 12-Dec-12 21:41:48

To be honest, I would comment on the pattern on Rav and say you're concerned it may contain errors. The author has the right of reply but you might give another newer knitter pause for thought.

I'll chart up what I think this is meant to look like for you but in the meantime I would build your confidence by doing a bit of seed stitch as a test piece so you know what you're looking for.

SlimJimBra Wed 12-Dec-12 21:42:56

Sorry sad (but$5 isn't that bad)

SlimJimBra Wed 12-Dec-12 21:45:06

Will hand over to tribpot for the drawing up of a new pattern, I was meant to be having an early night! Good luck smile

LittleNutTree Wed 12-Dec-12 22:01:14

Thank you so much for all of your replies, what a lovely bunch you are smile Don't worry about pointing out the pattern mistake even though I'd paid for the pattern, I'll look more thoroughly for nice free patterns next time!

If you could chart it for me tribpot that would be great smile I'll go and report the error too.

Thanks again. I've knitted a couple of cardigans and various hats before, so although I'm a beginner, I was sure I could manage this!

tribpot Wed 12-Dec-12 22:16:02

Okay - this is my first go at it.

Have a look at the 'Written' tab for the instructions that should match (sort of) to what you have, except I've put the border in.

I wouldn't attempt to do this on 120 stitches straight off, though. I'd cast on 40 and ignore the repeats in the instructions in rows 7 and 8 until you're happy you've nailed it (and the instructions are correct!)

LittleNutTree Wed 12-Dec-12 22:19:44

What a star! I won't start tonight, I'll be up for hours otherwise! I'll report back when I've got going though. Thanks again smile

SlimJimBra Thu 13-Dec-12 06:33:18

Well done tripot, thanks for that. Just a weeny thing - rows 14-16 top right seed st section looks transposed to me?

tribpot Thu 13-Dec-12 07:39:08

Yes, well done SlimJimBra! You were right. I had earlier started the pattern purl knit and then changed it to knit purl, and not completely updated the chart. Tis now fixed.

SlimJimBra Fri 18-Jan-13 14:50:35

How's the blanket going littlenuttree? I have started on a variation of this pattern for a blanket myself and was thinking of you and your blanket while I was knitting smile

LittleNutTree Thu 18-Apr-13 14:10:43

Sorry SlimJimBra! I have just picked this up again and only noticed your January message. I'm frustrated with it to be honest, it looks so simple, but by the time I get to the 2nd or 3rd row of going between knitting or purling, a rib keeps appearing. I can't understand, I'm following tribpot's pattern exactly too sad I'm now 27wks pg so still have a while!! grin

Dutchoma Netherlands Thu 18-Apr-13 17:26:50

If you want to do a seed stitch rather than a rib you need a purl stitch over a knit stitch and a knit stitch over a purl one. So just look at what you have ended with on the previous row, then do the opposite. That goes for everywhere, just look at what presents itself, then do the opposite on the return row. Never mind the pattern. I think $5.50 for a pattern that isn't right is daylight robbery, but I would make a note on Ravelry where it says: report a problem with this page. I looked for it and couldn't see it, not even when I had logged in.

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now