ZOMBIE THREAD ALERT: This thread hasn't been posted on for a while.
To think that ils and parents aren't always equal.(32 Posts)
By that I mean when it comes to access to grandchildren.
Dh and I have a crappy relationship with his parents. Too much to go into, but they make very little effort with either of us, cause a lot of stress and are generally pretty rubbish parents to dh.
My parents are the polar opposite. They love both dh and I to pieces. They are always there for both of us and make a huge effort to be a constant part of our lives (which is reciprocated by us too).
Before we had dd, this was never an issue. Pils didn't want much to do with us and we weren't that bothered. Any time we did see them it would be a carcrash to be honest. I have written about them in detail before on here and have been told they are toxic and to go nc. Dh has tried a million times to have a better relationship with them, but has been let down again and again.
Then dd came along.
Suddenly they were getting in touch all the time. Fil started phoning all the time to hear how she was and to make sure we were looking after her properly . Mil was suddenly sweet as pie and inviting us round all the time. However, they never ask about dh or I, and when we are round there pretty much ignore us and solely focus on dd. It's really quite awkward, it's like we aren't even there.
Since dd was born my mum has been a constant support, both practically and emotionally. She has helped out with washing and cleaning when I have been overwhelmed, has supported dh through horrible medical tests, invited us for meals and cooked food dh can eat on his special diet. Mil knew all about the diet, but made a dinner she knew he couldn't eat.
They have offered no help or support when dh has been really ill and they have known we are struggling.
Their only interest is dd. They often complain that they don't get to see her enough and I know that mil resents the fact that my mum gets to see her more. Dd has a completely different relationship with them because of this. She is always so happy to see my mum, but gets really upset at pils because both dh and I are stressed out and the atmosphere is so tense and unnatural.
Aibu to think that if one set of parents make no effort with you as a couple, but are solely interested in their gc that they are bound to see their gc less? Or if they are very interested in having a relationship with their gc should you put everything else aside?
Is there anyone else in a similar situation? What do you do?
Oh and I always see how pils should get to see their gc as soon as your own parents do. This didn't happen with us. I had a cs and was in a state in hospital, I didn't really want people who didn't give a crap about me coming to visit. My parents and grandparents came to check I was ok and to see the baby. I don't think I was unreasonable in that situation, but always see the opinion that they should be equal on here. Aibu?
Frankly I would tell them to take a running jump.
Before you do this first consider....
Does DH have brothers or sisters who would be angry with him for disowning pils?
If something happened to your parents and you needed an urgent babysitter/help would you have alternatives to the pils?
Will DD have plenty of loving aunts and cousins who can love and support her?
Will DH be relieved or distressed at no further contact with his parents?
Can you see no circumstance in your life anywhere where you would miss these people.
I'm sure you can think of a few more questions now you get my drift, and if the answer is you can do without them, then dump them and move on.
Stop seeing them
They sound so awful I wouldn't be surprised if they're trying to establish a pattern so that they can enforce contact.
Stop seeing them before you have that pattern
Bil is treated v badly by them too, so no problem there.
I don't trust pils to look after dd anyway because they have no idea about her signals and cues. They have no respect for us as parents and don't listen to anything we say and so have no idea what to do with her other than jangle keys in her face and constantly try to get her to smile. This means they ignore the fact she is tired or hungry and keep trying to play.
No other babies in the family yet as we are the first to start a family. We have friends with babies though.
Dh can't seem to let go of the hope of a good relationship which makes things really difficult.
I know for sure I wouldn't miss them! Dh might though as they are still his parents at the end of the day. That is why he tries again and again.
This.sounds very like my pil. Mil even actually said to dh and I that she.didn't want to know us, she just wanted our ds. As a result of their awful behaviour and lies dh has went nc and they haven't seen us or ds in 9 months. It's been the happiest 9 months! They are toxic and we didn't want that influence in ds's life nor.him feeling the hurt they have caused dh.
I don't think that PIL should be equal in every case. I think if the paternal grandparents are not as nice / helpful / interested then it is fair enough to have a different level of contact. I have that scenario as my eldest has autism and selective mutism and my MIL cannot and has never been able to understand that this is not 'rudeness' or 'mollycoddling'. She is a very toxic influence on my eldest DS, being of the attitude that if we only telled at him a bit more he would 'come good', and we keep contact short as a consequence. We do however allow contact as she is, after all, my DH's mum, she loves all the kids (just doesn't understand the eldest). But it is entirely her fault that she sees a lot less of the kids than my Mum does.
Laurie - that has to be dh's decision, I can't force him. The only choice I have is to how much of an effort I make with them re dd.
I just wanted to know if I should be putting it all aside for her sake? I think they should make an effort with us too, otherwise we shouldnt really bother, but wasn't sure if iabu.
Cats that is exactly it. They don't even try to hide it! It is clear as day that they are only interested in dd.
Ilike - yes... Because yelling at him will work!
I would love for my pil to show one ounce of affection for my kids!
She's never ever bothered with my kids but DH brothers kids are another story!
Skivvy - that's awful I have to say that my pils obviously love dd. It's just the rest of the crap that's the problem.
I just feel that if you haven't made an effort to have a good relationship with your child, then you cant expect to suddenly have loads of contact with a gc!
I don't speak to my mil anymore she's the most evil woman I've ever ever met and she used to wonder why I never gave my dd her name as her middle name!
Kooth that's the thing my mil left DH when he was 4 so I shouldn't really expect anything for my kids
I think that as a starting point they should be equal. But if one set, whether that be father's parents or mother's parents, makes more effort... then yeah, it seems kind of inevitable that the set making more effort will see the grandchildren more.
I would just be led by your dh here. it's his call.
you arnt leaving dd with them so that's not an issue.
my mil and fil were fantastic to add so it's the luck of the draw.
Skivvy - ugh vile woman!
Thanks mrsg, I think so.
Bodybooboo - I agree. It could just as well have been my parents that were the issue, it just happens that it's my ils in this situation. I know there are some lovely pils out there
As pp have said I think they should start off equal. I like my PIL but we don't really see them very often. They got the right hump when I had DC2 as DH told them we weren't having any visitors in the first couple of days, and they felt they should be able to come round immediately even though we hadn't heard from or seen them for weeks Up until that point I had made every effort to include them so I was actually quite disappointed it ended up that way.
I think you have to take your dh's lead on this. Leave it to him to make arrangements with his parents etc. Don't go out if your way to make contact, screen phone calls and minimise contact.
In an ideal world, all gps would be equally involved in their own dc's and dgc's lives. I would hazard a guess that a family in which both sets of parents treat all their adult children and grandchildren the same in terms of interest, affection and even love is rather a rare thing. Sad, but from my own experience, from talking to friends and from what I read on mnet, I don't think I know one family where there isn't a little niggle or two. Whether it be favouritism between adult siblings, more time spent with one set of gc or gps.
So Kooth, YANBU but in many situations its the ILs that are more supportive and involved. No easy answers.
Dh chose to go nc, they have been vile to him. Favouring his sister and mil saying.things like he ruined her life, he.wasn't planned etc. Despite all that, nc.had to be his.choice, not mine, I would have supported him either way...despite how pil have treated.me and made their dislike obvious. Your dh will only take so much hurt...the important thing is that he decides and you don't influence it.
This sounds very familiar OP.
I know DH wouldn't go no contact as he couldn't deal with the guilt but they're bad people and dysfunctional as fuck.
Am pregnant with first DC but whatever else happens PILs won't be looking after baby alone and won't be seeing DC as much as my parents. They just don't care about us, aren't supportive and don't respect our choices so why would I facilitate a proper relationship between them and our child? Of course they will see the baby and I understand that their DHs parents but you reap what you sow and they're shit parents so, it is what it is unfortunately
But they're not being sidelined because you have decided to favour one side over the other.
They have become sidelined because they neither know you nor care about you, as a family should.
Now your DD is here they're simply reaping what they've sowed.
Turn the question around. Is it fair that people get to treat you badly then rock up wanting their pound of flesh when you've got something they want-simply because they're 'faaaamily'?
Is it good for your DD to see that dynamic?
It wasn't good for me. I was astonished actually at how quickly I cut contact with several family members once I had my children. Seems that while I was fairly sanguine about playing happy families when it was just adults to worry about, when it came to the kind of childhoods my children were to have, and how they would see me as a person and how I dealt with my relationships...all bets were off.
I could have written this thread! We used to see my ils maybe twice a year when we were childless. When dd1 was born we ended up falling out with them as all of a sudden they wanted to visit for extended periods and much more frequently. They essentially demanded to see their grandchild regardless of whether it was convenient to us, and were completely thoughtless, hanging around getting in the way in the week after the birth when i was in pain, bleeding, struggling to breastfeed and on crutches. My parents stayed longer than intended as i begged them to as they helped, my mum even took screaming baby in the middle of the night, but dh had to ask them to leave earlier than they wanted as they were only there for their own benefit. Which sparked massive rows over the next few months and definitely contributed to me getting pnd.
we eventually agreed to see them every three months, but it was very much an issue that my parents would come more like once a month, and they didn't recognise that it was different as ive always been close to my parents and always seen them that much. Both sets lived a long way away so it was always a couple of days visit, and really giving the ILs one in twelve weekends was the most we could stretch to, given my dh would have to work every other weekend, and we would also want to see my parents, his grandparents, his sister, our friends, and god forbid have some quiet family time on our own as dh works so many hours we wouldn't see him in the week. They constantly tried to orchestrate more frequent or longer visits but after the big row, when they really showed how toxic they are, we very deliberately stuck to it, to keep their expectations low, and the relationship remained strained.
their solution was to announce at my daughters christening, when i was pregnant with dd2, that they had just been to see some nice houses for sale in our town! Dh had a very difficult word with them and said we weren't entirely comfortable with them moving right on our doorstep and that we still wouldn't have time to see them very often. They were clearly offended, but it seemed kinder than letting them make such a massive and expensive change only to be disappointed that we didn't suddenly invite them over once a week just because they were local. Geographical distance had never been the issue! However, despite dh thinking they might never speak to him again, they just ignored what he said and within three weeks they had sold their house and offered on one within two miles of us.
I was on crutches with spd for months before and after dd1 was born, but i realised by the time dd2 arrived that i had received biweekly emails from mil going on about the difficulties of their house move and asking after dd1, but not once did she ask how i was, i actually had to question if she even knew i was pregnant!
of course she did know, as they moved in the week dd2 was born and immediately set to engineering visits to see the gcs even before we had left the hospital, they needed to borrow a hoover to clean their new house before furniture arrived, they needed help setting up computer, they had tonnes of dhs useless junk from their loft to give us.
and every time my parents come to stay i am just waiting for them to spot the car on the drive, and start complaining about favouritism, even though they have engineered seeing the gcs much more than my parents and far more than they deserve.
Join the discussion
Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.Register now
Already registered with Mumsnet? Log in to leave your comment or alternatively, sign in with Facebook or Google.
Please login first.