Another mum keeps blaming my DD for things her DD does. AIBU to feel peed off?

(27 Posts)
NameChangeCat Wed 23-Jan-13 00:02:06

DD is 15. Her friend is also 15

Friend's DD has recently done something that she shouldn't have done. My DD was out with her at the time, along with some other friends, but went home when the friend started doing it as she's a pretty sensible girl and doesn't like to get involved in any trouble.

The friend's parents contacted the school and DD was hauled into the head teacher's office and got a telling off even though she wasn't involved.

I then spoke to the friend's mum about it and said DD wasn't involved but she refused to believe me and keeps phoning up and making references to said bad behaviour and seems to think my DD is as bad as hers. She refuses to accept her DD was the only one at fault and seems to want to deflect the blame onto DD. I've also heard that she's mentioned it to other parents too and made out my DD took part.

Sorry this is so vague but I'll give my identity away if I am specific about what happened. It's nothing illegal btw, but something that is dangerous for a teenage girl to do.

Musomathsci Wed 23-Jan-13 00:05:16

Have you spoken to the school? Even if you can't convince your friend that your DD wasn't involved, I wouldn't be happy to have the school thinking she was a troublemaker.

Other than that, I don't think there is much you can do, except be thankful that your DD is sensible and encourage her to stay away from her daft 'friend'.

MidnightMasquerader Wed 23-Jan-13 00:06:02

It seems like you're both refusing to believe that your own DDs could possibly have been involved.

Are you are certain she wasn't there when it all took place? At the risk of sounding all <insert random cop show name> - does she have an alibi...? hmm

NameChangeCat Wed 23-Jan-13 00:07:11

I have spoken to the school but it fell on deaf ears and their attitude seemed to be that as this parent reported it then that's that and that it does no harm to remind a child to be sensible.

I've told her from now on she is to stay well away from that friend. I think the mum is very embarrassed about it but is trying to convince herself that other kids are as bad too

NameChangeCat Wed 23-Jan-13 00:08:08

MidnightMasquerader, my DD wasn't involved, as I have already said.

HermioneE Wed 23-Jan-13 00:13:51

How do you know the other mum's version of events is wrong, OP?

If she came on here she would probsbly post a virtually identical thread. Neither of you know for sure what happened and you both blame the other girl.

MidnightMasquerader Wed 23-Jan-13 00:18:44

I know you already said she wasn't involved, but that wasn't what I was asking.

HopAndSkip Wed 23-Jan-13 00:19:40

I would just encourage her to stay away. Did the school speak to the other girl too? Maybe mention to the school if they haven't.

seeker Wed 23-Jan-13 00:22:24

I would always be wary of being certain that your daughter wasn't involved- honestly.

I agree with all the others.

Seems like her DD and your DD could have told their moms similar stories. Perhaps, maybe?

Time for a BigChat.

HecateWhoopass Wed 23-Jan-13 07:41:48

How do you know your daughter wasn't involved?

If it's nothing more than 'because she told me' - then how are you any different from the other mother who believes that she was because her daughter told her?

If you have independent witnesses to confirm that she wasn't involved - then it is very simple to prove it, so take those witnesses to the school, who can then tell the other mother the truth.

curiousuze Wed 23-Jan-13 07:50:29

I used to use this story with my parents all the time 'I wasn't there! I was already home! It was [insert name here] who bought the drink/had the party/used the condom.'

Teenagers are sneaky, OP.

Groovee Wed 23-Jan-13 08:11:17

How do you know she wasn't involved? Teenagers have a tendancy to stretch the truth to their own version.

IneedAsockamnesty Wed 23-Jan-13 08:28:58

Fwiw if 3 of my children said they didn't do something then it means they didnt,the others well chances are they did.

How do you know she didnt?

Unless it was something obvious like "I knew she didn't do it because they were downing vodka and my daughter was very obviously not drunk when she walked in" then I really don't see how you can be so sure your DD didn't do anything, teens do fudge things a bit.
Out of curiosity, did she mention anything before the school told her off? (Not sure why the school are involved as it seems to have happened out of school?)

milf90 Wed 23-Jan-13 10:17:02

I agree with pp, she could be lying to you - unless she was at home with you when it all happened because she left before?

CrapBag Wed 23-Jan-13 10:28:14

So your DD told you she wasn't involved, sounds like your friends DD is saying the same. You have absolutely no way of knowing that your DD didn't take part in anything. You are believing your child, your friend is believing hers. YABU.

We would need more info to assess the situation properly.

FWIW, a friend of mine at scholl decided to hang about with some other girls from her class one evening. They went up to the school and set fire to the bins. I know my friend didn't do it, she wasn't the type and didn't hang out them after and she was scared but it didn't stop her getting into trouble with the others.

diddl Wed 23-Jan-13 10:32:02

Why are the school involved?

Unless I´ve misread, it didn´t happen at school?

Well, as I understand it, the other girl is blaming your daughter.

Your daughter might be doing the same.

NameChangeCat Wed 23-Jan-13 11:11:11

A deputy head has called me this morning.

Other girl has come clean and said that my DD wasn't involved and did go home before it took place. Deputy head has apologised profusely and is going to speak to the other parent and clarify matters.

I do not wish to go into detail but as I said, I knew my DD hadn't taken part and had proof that she hadn't.

Flobbadobs Wed 23-Jan-13 11:15:12

Defintetly keep DD away from this girl as much as possible. We've recently had to stop DS from hanging around with a couple of friends for similar reasons. The problem is that she risks being found guilty by association if she goes anywhere with her from now on.
YANBU to be upset, you knew she was innocent and could prove it.

NameChangeCat Wed 23-Jan-13 11:42:29

Luckily DD has said she doesn't want to spend any time with this girl again. DD is pretty sensible and says she doesn't want to be guilty by association.

Glad it's all resolved now and you can rest easy.
You are very lucky to have a sensible 15 YO DD.

diddl Wed 23-Jan-13 12:13:25

I don´t understand why your daughter was "hauled into the headteacher´s office" on the say so of another girl & her parents.

The other girl was obviously blaming your daughter then.

But you weren´t asked about it all, even though you could have proved that she wasn´t there/didn´t do it-thus preventing her getting unnecessarily told off?

Flobbadobs Wed 23-Jan-13 14:03:44

Sounds like your Dd has the sensible head that I hope my DS will sprout at some point! Glad it's sorted grin

Floggingmolly Wed 23-Jan-13 14:26:39

So your dd's friend got into trouble, and when her mum found out she contacted the school?? Why? And the school interviewed your daughter because some loon implicated her in some incident which took place outside school?
Hard to believe...

Floggingmolly Wed 23-Jan-13 14:28:01

Btw, what are the other "things" your dd is being blamed for?

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now