My gym's 'diet challenge' can fuck off!

(69 Posts)

7 weeks ago I signed up to my (women-only) gym's 'Diet Challenge'. It's a tenner to enter and you get recipe ideas. Each week everyone gets weighed and their weight gets displayed on the wall. After 2 months, the person who has lost the most weight wins a facial, a blow dry and their nails done. Not too shabby.

30 of us signed up.

I worked my arse off. I attended the gym 5 x per week and was the strictest with food I've ever been in my life. I'm 5ft1. My start weight was 9st6. 7 weeks later, my weight is now 8st4. I have the highest percentage weight loss from the 30 entries. Some of the other entries began the challenge at 19 stone and did very well but have a lower percentage weight loss.

Now, because I haven't lost the most weight overall (one of the 19 stone entries lost more weight than I did - in sheer number), I win bollock all.

AIBU to think this is an unhealthy way for them to judge weight loss? I would have to have become anorexic to have any chance of winning over the 19 stone entries.

As the competition was set up, it doesn't matter which way the winner was calculated, it was always going to be unfair to one group or the other.

It's like running an art competition or a running race or a spelling bee for children aged up to 16 - the older kids have a far better chance of winning than the younger ones - which is why competitions like this are split up into groups, so the competitions are fair - or as fair as can be.

In the same way, wombles' gym could have split the competition up so that people like her, with only a small amount to lose, weren't competing against the 19 stone people, who would find it easier to lose more, numerically speaking. Perhaps they could have two or three 'classes' in the competition, if they hold it again?

It might be worth suggesting this to them - I think they are more likely to listen if you have a sensible suggestion, than if you just look like you are suffering from sour grapes (it could appear that way - I am not saying that is what I think). It might also be worth pointing out that people with only a little weight to lose could be put off from entering the next competition/diet challenge, if this last one is perceived to have been unfair to that group.

fascicle Sat 28-Jun-14 13:06:46

Implied acceptance. You signed up for this, parted with the cash, attended the weigh-ins and presumably checked on the figures on the wall as the competition progressed. I think you would only have grounds for complaint if there was ambiguity - e.g. if weightloss as a percentage of body weight was also included in the weekly stats.

You have got a point, but the time to raise this was before the challenge started.

MyFairyKing Sat 28-Jun-14 13:09:32

"You can still win, get your arm amputated."

I sniggered. grin

bragmatic Sat 28-Jun-14 13:10:44

I completely agree. It's a ridiculous way to measure results.

Trillions Sat 28-Jun-14 13:27:55

YANBU

WorraLiberty Sat 28-Jun-14 13:35:49

worra assuming the figures the OP gave are correct, she started of with a BMI of just less than 25, so she wasn't overweight at the start of the competition.

Oh I see. I forget that most people tend to judge by their BMI nowadays.

I never go by that as I prefer to 'eyeball' it if you see what I mean?

There are fat people around whose BMI doesn't necessarily reflect their 'figure' and at 5ft 1" weighing 9st 6lb, the OP could well have felt she was one of those people.

I'm 5ft 3" and as soon as my weight hits around 8st 7lb, that's when I know I need to cut back because my zips and buttons start to get tight.

differentnameforthis Sat 28-Jun-14 13:41:56

The winner was the person who lost the most weight. Not %. Actual weight.

You are trying to find a loophole that doesn't exist.

But urgh at the price. Does everyone think that all women want are facial, blow dries & pretty nails?

NoodleOodle Sat 28-Jun-14 13:47:31

Take it as a bit of fun and be thankful that it worked as a good incentive for you. Give yourself a prize of facial, nails, hair. There's nothing else you can do really as they've followed the rules as they stated them so to complain WBU.

In future, suggest categories and % loss,, if they can find enough people to sign up.

sharonthewaspandthewineywall Sat 28-Jun-14 13:50:50

Just because your clothes get tight doesn't still make you fat Worra. If you were wearing a child's size they would get tight doesn't meant you are fat

differentnameforthis Sat 28-Jun-14 14:11:35

Prize!

WorraLiberty Sat 28-Jun-14 14:12:43

Hahaha! grin

I'm talking about my adult size 8/10 clothes. I'm not in the habit of wearing kid's clothes...

When they start to get tight because I'm gaining weight, I reign in the not so healthy food and start exercising more.

My point is, when I start to get fatter around my stomach (mostly) my BMI doesn't reflect the fact I need to lose some weight.

carabos Sat 28-Jun-14 14:22:31

My gym did the same thing during a 12 week boot camp. They explained by saying that their main goal for boot camp was to attract and motivate people who needed to lose weight - give them an initial boost which would carry them through a longer programme. Other people with little or no weight to lose were welcome, but knew they were unlikely to win a prize.

Two main differences - the competition was included in the price of the boot camp, and the prizes were things like T shirts and water bottles - tokens and a bit of recognition rather than making it all about the prize. They wanted the main reward to be the successful weightloss and sense of achievement.

I would wonder about the reasoning behind this type of competition, tbh.

I hated this when I went to WW, whilst breast feeding and after being on steroids.

But, WW reps aren't qualified in what is healthy etc, gym instructors supposedly are.

I would question if they knew anything about effective weight loss and they wouldn't be someone who I would want dietary advice from.

That isn't something I'd want from a gym I am paying for.

itsbetterthanabox Sat 28-Jun-14 14:45:41

Your annoyed that you didn't win a weight loss competition. I assume the point is to become a healthy weight. Which you already were... So you just wanted to look thinner whereas other people were actually aiming on becoming healthier. I don't think giving you a prize for becoming thinner would be a good thing tbh.

Scousadelic Sat 28-Jun-14 14:51:41

As someone who has been 19sone in the past I think YABU. Do you have any idea how much courage it takes to even go into a gym at that size? Have you any clue how hard it is to exercise when you are carrying all that extra weight? So it is not necessarily easy for them.

The terms of the competition were very clearly set out, you didn't win and are now being a bad sport

Darkesteyes Sat 28-Jun-14 15:05:03

Birds the diet industry badly needs regulating.

busyboysmum Sat 28-Jun-14 15:10:43

Yanbu. The Biggest Loser programme started measuring weight loss like this in the first series. Then it was pointed out that it was a ridiculous way to find a winner as clearly those who started off the heaviest would always win. So they changed it to percentage of body weight lost which is clearly the better way to do it. Sounds like they haven't thought it throughpproperly at your gym.

busyboysmum Sat 28-Jun-14 15:13:06
Darkesteyes Sat 28-Jun-14 15:19:18

Do drug and alcohol counsellors hold competitions to see which client can stay clean or sober the longest. No? Then why is it ok to do it to overweight people.

Why is it done AT ALL!

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now