to dislike being physical with dc and to think words should be enough?

(419 Posts)
NeeNawNora Sat 21-Jun-14 23:12:28

I am the stricter of the two of us yet am becoming increasingly frustrated with dp having to be physical in some way with our dc in order to get them to do as he's asked. I don't mean smacking or hurting them but restraining or physically removing things. I don't think this is acceptable as ultimately he's using his strength to overpower them and get his way but still has no control.

For example, dd was climbing on a gate today. He told her to get down, she said it's ok I'm nearly over. He said 'no, get down now' and she continued climbing over. He put an arm round her waist and used the other hand to peel her fingers off before dumping her down and her complaining she could of done it/he's hurt her leg/she's got a splinter etc. I didn't see the need for her to get off (he was impatient to open it to go through) because I like the dc being able to climb and explore when appropriate, but if I had wanted her to I'd have said 'dd, please get down because [insert reason]' and she would mostly likely have listened. If she hadn't I'd have reminded her that there are consequences for not listening and she definitely would've listened.

Similarly tonight, younger dd and ds were racing to get a ball and ds got it first the first time so dp told him to let dd get it first next time. Ds still got it first and dp wrestled it off him rather than just repeat his request. I would've reiterated what I'd asked and then if he still didn't listen I'd have given ds a warning that if he still didn't listen and play/share nicely then he wouldn't be able to play at all.

I just think all the physicality is heavy handed and shows a lack of patience and control. Dp thinks I'm too soft but ultimately the dc listen to me and not him and my way causes less upset. Aibu to think being physical is unnecessary or am I being too soft?

Annunziata Sat 21-Jun-14 23:14:30

You are being very soft. If they were on the road, are you going to wait for them to walk off the road themselves or get them off it before they hurt themselves?

fairylightsintheloft Sat 21-Jun-14 23:17:41

Blimey I'd love it if I could be so sure my kids would listen to reasonable requests and explanations. Sorry but I'm with your dh on this one

WorraLiberty Sat 21-Jun-14 23:19:14

Jeez, who's got the time to keep pussy footing around the kids?

He told her to get off the gate so she should have got off...she thought she didn't have to do as she was told, and learnt that wasn't the case.

Same with the ball, although I would have held my hand out and said sternly "Give it to me please", using my death stare.

If that didn't work, I would have done what your DH did.

SantanaLopez Sat 21-Jun-14 23:19:35

YABU. I think you're being soft.

She shouldn't have been climbing on the gate, so I wouldn't be interested in the 'I'm nearly over' excuse.

If two of them were fighting over the ball, the best thing to do is get it into neutral territory, i.e. Dad.

Icimoi Sat 21-Jun-14 23:20:12

Annunziata, there really isn't any comparison between day to day discipline and the situation where children are in danger. OP, I agree with you: far better to teach the children to do what they are told than to force them to do so by using an adult's greater strength.

RabbitSaysWoof Sat 21-Jun-14 23:20:14

I do what your dh does.

DeepThought Sat 21-Jun-14 23:22:05

Well they don't yet listen so intervening is fine

"Down you get please" "nah"

"Take turns nicely please" "nah"

Sounds like the children are preschool age, maybe infants? Impulsive age, innit.

treaclesoda Sat 21-Jun-14 23:23:00

I don't feel any need to explain why I want small children to do something on each individual occasion. I just want them to understand that I'm adult and when I say 'stop climbing' I mean 'stop climbing' or whatever. I'm with your dh.

WooWooOwl Sat 21-Jun-14 23:23:03

I don't think that you're too soft or that he's heavy handed, you just do things differently. And that's fine, there is no one perfect way to parent children. In fact I think one of the reasons that children do best out of having two parents is that they see two different approaches to achieving the same thing, which in turn allows them to find their own ways of doing things.

You need to let go a little bit and as long as you trust that your DH is ultimately a good parent, just let him get on with it.

Mrsjayy Sat 21-Jun-14 23:23:06

Im with him sorry he asked her to get off she didnt he askec again she didn't he took her orr 6 yr olds dont reason they dont care abouf a lenthy explanation they switch off its really all blah with him, climbing over a gate isnt exploring its doing what you want regardless of anybody else, you need to have control over children they cant police themselves so young, you and their dad are a partnership you need to work this out

Thenapoleonofcrime Sat 21-Jun-14 23:23:20

Depends on their age, with three and under, sometimes removal/direct action is the best way.

Over that, and it's less appropriate, although I did once remove my tantrumming 6 year old from the dinner table in front of all my rellies. That was so embarrassing.

Mrsjayy Sat 21-Jun-14 23:23:38

Sorry lots of typos,

WorraLiberty Sat 21-Jun-14 23:24:53

I was in a shop last week when a child aged around 3, kept climbing up the shelves.

His Mum asked him to stop - he totally blanked her.

She then went on to tell him it was 'dangerous darling' - he totally blanked her.

Then she went on to explain the danger in more depth - again totally blanked.

By the time she went on to explain there would be consequences if he didn't get down, I just wanted to grab the kid, pop him on the floor and get on with browsing stock cubes.

Talk about making a friggin meal of it. I thought at one point she was going to phone a behaviour psychologist to come and talk him down...

RabbitSaysWoof Sat 21-Jun-14 23:26:31

Who's gate was it?

Annunziata Sat 21-Jun-14 23:26:43

Of course you can compare them, the child could have fallen off the gate and hurt herself, they could have battered one another over the ball and hurt themselves.

Mrsjayy Sat 21-Jun-14 23:27:14

Btw I dont thimk your soft I just think he is their dad he isnt harming them you need to let him get on with it

Mrsjayy Sat 21-Jun-14 23:28:29

See worraall blah grin

I don't use it often but I do use it. Yesterday, DD had a splinter which was getting red and sore. I tried logic, I tried bribery, I tried privileges. In the end we held her down and got it out. Painlessly, I might add.

Xcountry Sat 21-Jun-14 23:29:14

It is unreasonable, your children were asked once, didn't do it so there are consequences. Carry on that way and you will have more bother when they are teenagers, "come in at 10" "no im not finished getting pissed in the street yet" what the hell - it doesn't matter because they haven't learnt consequence.

RabbitSaysWoof Sat 21-Jun-14 23:29:35

grin Warra
I think its arse licky, like they are deep down scared of their dc's reactions in public if they just be in charge.

FreudiansSlipper Sat 21-Jun-14 23:29:52

I would often do the long explanations

I soon learnt because I told you then remove him (if needed to) if ds wants to do something an explanation from me why he shouldn't is not going to make much difference

SantasLittleMonkeyButler Sat 21-Jun-14 23:36:43

Your DH is not wrong. Nor are you. You just parent slightly differently and that is fine.

Personally, I ask. Then I tell. Then I remove (e.g. with the DC on the gate).

Mrsjayy Sat 21-Jun-14 23:37:06

Oh I used to do the please dd dont do that you will hurt yourself mummy will be sad if you hurt yourself , then realised she was 2 and staring at me like I was half daft,

WorraLiberty Sat 21-Jun-14 23:40:56

Can you imagine having 3 or 4 kids and having to have a deeply involved conversation, every time you found one of them flushing your car keys down the loo...or hanging their sibling out of the window by their ankles? grin

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now